AGood Essay on Tom Bombadil.

[Elendur]

I just found this excellent essay on 'Who is Tom Bombadil'. Even though I dont agree with some things that he wrote, such as Hobbits are afraid of trees, I beleive it is worth reading. I found alot of points he made very interesting. It made me kindof second guess my theory of who Tom is, and now I am flustered again.

Have fun reading. http://www.cas.unt.edu/~hargrove/bombadil.html

[Halbarad]

Not bad. A good dicussion of the anomaly and enigma argument that was here somewhere a while ago.

[Phil The Balrog]

Y'know... i was just sorta resigned to the fact that Tom Bombadil was unsolvable, and inherently so. But reading that essay, man, thats compelling stuff. I've never heard a more thorough argument or a more logical one. Maybe that just attests to my "newness" but even so... very very thoughtful essay.

[Elendur]

I am reviving my old thread to let it be discussed more. This essay is excellent and I want to see what more people think of it.

[Anunia]

I find this essay very intersting. The arguments are very good, but I don't agree some things -- I don't think hobbits are afraid of trees. I like it very very much.
It's a very good theory sustained by very good arguments.

[Daniel Telcontar]

The author is an excellent writer, and very good at finding arguments for his theories. I also like that he presents us with all aspects, so that we may ourselves decide what we think is right. I really enjoyed reading this article, thanks Elendur!!

[*Varda*]

<font color=white> Yes i saw that essay a couple of months ago. It was pretty interesting, particularly the idea about Tom and Goldberry being Aule and Yavanna although i don't believe it myself.

~*Varda Elentari*~

[Joy]

Just found this essay and was going to post it, so I did a search and found it was already here.

So, I'll just second that! It is an excellent article. Very though out and commpelling.

[Alkanoonion]

Thanks for the great read, I missed the article the first time round. smilies/biggrin.gif

[burrahobbit]

I like this one better (http://forum.barrowdowns.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic&f=1&t=001272).