The Mirthies

[Vuelve]

If you could make up an award like the Oscar and give it to one of the characters, what would it be?


Peace,
Vuelve

[Kransha]

Well, the Middle-Earth Mirthies Award Show would have categories for book-verse stuff, not just characters. That's a prospect to go on. It would be sort of like the SAG Awards, more so than like the Oscars at least. Now, votes would not be based on how generally good someone is, just how much you think they deserve the votes for....

Stuff along the lines of...
~Best Overall Character~
~Best Female Character~
~Best Male Character~
~Best Cameo Appearance~
~Best Overall Villain~
~Best Monster/Creature Character~
~Best Comedic Character~
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~
~Best Overall Death Scene~

Yeah...stuff like that...must think of my votes.

[Elennar Starfire]

Hmm, what about the equivalent of the Razzies? (The Evil smilie is gone! *sniffle* :( )

~Worst Overall Character~
~Worst Female Character~
~Worst Male Character~
~Worst Cameo Appearance~
~Worst Overall Villain~
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~
~Worst Comedic Character~
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~
~Worst Overall Death Scene~


For Worst Death Scene...Aragorn's fake one.
For Worst Female Character...Arwen.

Hmm, this is hard!

[Meneltarmacil]

Good topic! Let me see what I can do...

Worst Overall Villain: The pig-orc at the Pelennor Fields who should have been a lot scarier-looking.

Worst Monster/Creature Character:
Those big ugly mutant hyena things that have the nerve to call themselves "wargs".

[Lëowen]

Hmm...

Worst Overall Character: Legolas! "A diversion!" That has to be one of the worst lines ever.
Worst Female Character: ARWEN *shudder*
Worst Male Character: Uh...can I say Legolas again?
Worst Comedic Character: Gimli. At least hobbits are supposed to be rather funny.

[Rilwen Gamgee]

Let's see... Possible awards might be:

~ Best/worst hairstyle: (Any ideas?)
~ Most dramatic last line: Sam (He has the last line, so it MUST be dramatic! ;) )

Also, are we judging from the books or the movies?

[Firefoot]

I thought it was books...but everyone's replying for movies.

Best Death Scene: Boromir's
Worst Overall Villian: Sauron's spotlight eye
Best/Worst Female Character: Eowyn/Arwen
Worst Comedic Character: Gimli
Best Monologue: Aragorn's before the black gate

[Vuelve]

Since the Oscars is a movies award show, I intended the Mirthies tho be movie based also.But since nothing here on Middle Earth Mirth goes as planned it doesent really matter.Let 'controled' chaos ensue!!!


Peace,
Vuelve

[Kransha]

For the movies... (in my opinion)

~Best Overall Character~ Sam
~Best Female Character~ Galadriel
~Best Male Character~ Aragorn
~Best Cameo Appearance~
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Treebeard
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin/Merry
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ "This day we fight"
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen
~Worst Male Character~ Legolas again
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ Sharku (warg-rider)
~Worst Overall Villain~ Gothmog (orc)
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ "Frodo Monologues"
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor

In the books...(once again, in my opinion)

~Best Overall Character~ Faramir
~Best Female Character~ Eowyn
~Best Male Character~ Aragorn
~Best Cameo Appearance~ Ghan-Buri-Ghan
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Treebeard
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ "Wrathy Eomer"
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Denethor

There are no 'worsts' in the book that I'd be willing to post.

[Elennar Starfire]

Nonono, no worsts in the books! Just movie worsts. Bests in the books are good.

I definately agree with Denethor being the Worst Death Scene.

[Sleepy Ranger]

People I have an idea. Make categories. Put in nominess. Then we vote.

[rutslegolas]

good thing sleepy
lets see i have a category:-
best character ever:sam
aragorn
legolas
gimli
saruman
etc.

now can the next one who posts add the other categories and nominesses

[Vuelve]

Yes sleepy ranger has a very good idea, but don't keep to the traditional catagories; make some up.This is Middle Earth Mirth you know!:D Make up some catagories like Best hairdo, Worst hairdo,...etc...have fun with it.

Peace,
Vuelve

[Sleepy Ranger]

~Best Overall Character~ Aragorn, Sam, Frodo, Faramir, Galadriel
~Best Female Character~ Galadriel, Eowyn, Rosie Cotton
~Best Male Character~ Aragorn, Sam, Faramir, Frodo, Pippin, Merry
~Best Cameo Appearance~ Balrog, PJ, PJ's son, PJ's daughter
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman, Sauron, Balrog, Shelob
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Treebeard, Balrog, Shelob
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin, Merry, Gimli
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn, Gandalf, Theoden
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir, Denethor, Witch-King, Theoden
~Best Battle~ Pellenor, Helm's Deep, Morannon
~Best Maia~ Gandalf, Saruman, Sauron, Balrog
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Destruction of Ring, Theoden's death, Boromir's death, Pippin's song/Faramir's charge at Osgiliath
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Grima, Gollum
~Most missed character~ Glorfindel, Tom Bombadil, Old Man Willow, Imrahil, Elladan, Elrohin, Halbarad, The Barrow-Wight
~Best hairdo~ Legolas, Frodo, Sam, Pippin, Galadriel, Arwen

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas, Arwen, Haldir, Elrond
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen, Rosie Cotton
~Worst Male Character~ Legolas, Haldir, Elrond
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ, PJ's kids
~Worst Overall Villain~ Gothmog, Witch-King, Sauron's eye
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Witch-King, Shelob
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli, Legolas, Pippin
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo, Bilbo, Sam
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor, Haldir
~Worst Maia~ Sauron, Gandalf, Saruman, Balrog
~Worst Hairdo~ Pippin, Sam, Arwen, Eowyn, Haldir

Ok people Voting starts now(please give a reason for your vote). I'll count them and the awards will be given at the end of this month. Voting starts now. One vote per category :)

[Sleepy Ranger]

~Best Overall Character~ Aragorn (Whats not to like baout him?)
~Best Female Character~ Eowyn (Killed the WK)
~Best Male Character~ Aragorn (See above)
~Best Cameo Appearance~ PJ (Gah Fat guy)
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman (Much better than Sauron)
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Balrog (Balrogs are cool er hot)
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin (Fool of a Took)
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn (It was perfect)
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir (The only good one if you ask me)
~Best Battle~ Pellenor (It just looked fantastic)
~Best Maia~ Gandalf (But the best)
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song/Faramir's charge at Osgiliath (*sniff sniff*)
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum (Evil person)
~Most missed character~ Tom Bombadil (Him not being there was dissapointing)
~Best hairdo~ Galadriel (Neat hair)

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas (A diversion)
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen (You stole my horse)
~Worst Male Character~ Legolas (Above)
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ (Hey he gets 2)
~Worst Overall Villain~ Gothmog (This guy looked baaad)
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Shelob (Too small)
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli (Did anyone laugh?)
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo (.....)
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor (Why can't they just burn him...and why did Gandalf push him in?)
~Worst Maia~ Sauron (Eye with a tractor beam)
~Worst Hairdo~ Haldir (I hated him)

[Sharkû]

This topic would be A LOT better and less of a list topic if you folks gave reasons, not just names. Hint, hint.

[galadriel'smaiden]

~Best Overall Character~ Elrond (Good speeches)
~Best Female Character~ Galadriel (beautiful/terrible..!)
~Best Male Character~ Faramir
~Best Cameo Appearance~ Sean Astin's daughter as Elanor
~Best Overall Villain~ Mumakil rider guy w/ the neat makeup
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Da Fell Beast
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Sam @ end of TT (corny, but good)
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Theoden (I know your face)
~Best Battle~ Helm's Deep (the initiation of battle gave me *shudders*
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song (home is behind...)
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Deagol
~Most missed character~ Elladon/Elrohir
~Best hairdo~ Arwen at the end ( i know, she shouldnt be here, but still, good hair net thingy!)

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas (And in case you didnt know- A diversion!)
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen
~Worst Male Character~ Gimli
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ, carrot man
~Worst Overall Villain~ Sauron and his fakey eye
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Treebeard (FAKE!!!!)
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli, again
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Boromir (gag, splutter, barf)
~Worst Hairdo~ Aragorn (excellent preformance, lack of shampoo)

[Nimrothiel]

Um, did Sleepy Ranger not just do that?

Here are my choices; they are a combination of the books and the movies:

Best overall character: Faramir (only person other than Aragorn who resisted the temptation of the Ring; exellent captain of the army)
Best male character: Aragorn (come on, he gets to be the king, and look at what he goes through to get there)
Best female character: Eowyn (takes out the Witch-King, need I say more?)
Best creature: Treebeard (best visual effects done on an inanimate object ever; plus his voice sounded exactly the way I thought it should)
Best monster: The Watcher in the Water (the scene was a little longer than it should have been, but the visuals were worth it)
Best villain: Sauruman (Sauron is just a flaming eyeball, Sauruman is much more active in carrying out his plans for world domination)
Best monologue: Aragorn's "This day we fight" speech (exellent, it set the tone for the scene very well; but his voice got a little funny in some places)
Best dramatic scene: Faramir and his men riding to their doom (Pippin's song added a lot more feeling to this scene, but it was good just by itself)
Best death scene: Boromir's (most realistic looking, plus most moving)
Best comic character: Pippin ("Fool of a Took!" and "What about elevenses, lunch, dinner, supper, afternoon tea?! He knows about those right?" kill me every time)
Best Maia: Gandalf (who knows how many centuries old, and he still kicks a$$)
Most missed chacter: Glorfindel (having Arwen rescue Frodo just killed that whole scene)
Best supporting character: Samwise Gamgee (do I really need to explain this one?)

And now for the other end of the stick:

Worst overall character: Sauron (he just stays in Barad-dur all the time and looks around; even Legolas is better than that)
Worst male character: Haldir (totally unnecessary at Helm's Deep, and his death scene was terrible)
Worst female character: Arwen (in far too many scenes, and her acting wasn't that great)
Worst creature: The Wargs (give me a break, they looked like hybrid hyenas!)
Worst monster: Shelob (about half the size I imagined, and not terribly frightening)
Worst villain: Sauron (see "Worst overall chacter")
Worst monologue: Any of Frodo's (well, his last one in "Return of the King" wasn't too bad, but he just killed the rest of them)
Worst dramatic scene: Faramir and Frodo squaring off over the one Ring (let me just say that this never happened that way, and Faramir resisted the temptation of the Ring)
Worst death scene: Haldir's (not in the book, and a waste of slow-motion effects which also made the awful scene longer)
Worst comic character: Gimli (I'm not even touching this one)
Worst Maia: Sauron (see "Worst villain")
Least missed chacter: Tom Bombadil (sorry, but his constant singing in the books really annoyed me)
Worst supporting character: Grima Wormtongue (reminded me too much of Snape from "Harry Potter")

[Iaurhirwen]

I have filled in my ballot and there are no hanging chads ;)

Best Overall Character: Aragorn (He's the king!)
Best Female Character: Galadriel (I have always felt a connection to her)
Best Male Character: Aragorn (I love the man)
Best Cameo: Write in for Viggo's son (without him we wouldn't have had Viggo)
Best Villain: Saruman (I just shiver every time i see him)
Best Creature: Treebeard (He gave us a taste of Tom Bombadil)
Best Comedy: Pippin (It comes in pints)
Best Monolog: Aragorn (Rousing Courageous)
Best Death: Theoden (He made me cry)
Best Battle: Pellenor (One mumakil down, two mumakil down . . . )
Best Maia: Gandalf (Is there really any better?)
Best Dramatic Moment: Pippin's song/Faramir's charge (I listen to it every day)
Most pitied character: *Smeagol* (He's such a cute little thing)
Most missed: Tom Bombadil (Hey, his boots are yellow!)
Best Harido: Legolas (If you can fight battles without misplacing a strand - you must be good)

Worst overall character: Arwen (I can't believe she almost left!)
Worst female character: Arwen (stupid scene stealing, elf impersonating . . . .)
Worst Male Character: Elrond (He was mean, Elrond is not mean)
Worst Cameo: PJ's first (that was icky)
Worst Villain: Sauron's Eye (Gothmug was also Lux so I couldn't bring myself to vote for him)
Worst Monster: Shelob (Wasn't that scary)
Worst Monologue: Frodo (I just didn't like it)
Worst Maia: Sauron - when he was just an eye (he was cool with a body)
Worst Hairdo: Haldir (It didn't match his eyebrows)

[galadriel'smaiden]

Nimrothiel: Yes, Sleepy Ranger did just do that; i copied and pasted and changed the answers. I am lazy. ;)

[Sleepy Ranger]

Creature/Monster is one category Nimthel. :(
We've had decent looking resluts so far. And most of them have a decided winner but there are still lots of voting days left.
The results so far are-

~Best Overall Character~ Aragorn(2), Elrond, Faramir
~Best Female Character~ Eowyn(2), Galadriel(2)
~Best Male Character~ Aragorn(3), Faramir
~Best Cameo Appearance~ PJ, Elanor, Viggo's son
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman(3)
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Balrog, Fell Beast, Treebeard(2)
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin(4)
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn(3), Sam
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir(2), Theoden(2)
~Best Battle~ Pellenor(2), Helms Deep
~Best Maia~ Gandalf(3)
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song(4)
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum(2), Deagol
~Most missed character~ Tom Bombadil(2), Twins, Glorfindel,
~Best hairdo~ Galadriel, Arwen, Legolas
~Best supporting character~ Samwise Gamgee

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas(2), Sauron, Arwen
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen(4)
~Worst Male Character~ Legolas, Gimli, Haldir, Elrond
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ(3)
~Worst Overall Villain~ Gothmog, Sauron(3), Shelob
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Shelob(2), Treebeard, Wargs
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli(2)
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo(4)
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor, Boromir, Haldir
~Worst Maia~ Sauron(3)
~Worst Hairdo~ Haldir(2), Aragorn
~Worst dramatic scene~ Faramir and Frodo squaring off over the one Ring
~Least missed chacter~ Tom Bombadil
~Worst supporting character~ Grima Wormtongue

Looks like Aragorn's dominating the fields people so far hes leading in three awards including Best Overall Character
:eek:

[symestreem]

Most missed scene: the Houses of Healing (this will change after EEE RotK)
Scene that made the most shivers run up my spine: the ending of the battle of Helm's Deep. That was just heroic. Runner-up: Galadriel's "but there were some who resisted. A last alliance of men and elves marched against the armies of Mordor...". It's also heroic!

[Sleepy Ranger]

Please do not include scenes that will be covered in the EE.

[rutslegolas]

my votes:-Best Overall Character-aragorn
Best Female Character-eowyn
Best Male Character-aragorn
Best Cameo Appearance-elanor
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman(3)
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Balrog
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Theoden
~Best Battle~ Pellenor
~Best Maia~ saruman
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum
~Most missed character~ ,Glorfindel,
~Best hairdo~ Legolas
~Best supporting character~ Samwise Gamgee

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen
~Worst Male Character~ Legolas
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ
~Worst Overall Villain~ Sauron
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Shelob
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor
~Worst Maia~ Sauron
~Worst Hairdo~ Haldir
~Worst dramatic scene~ Faramir and Frodo squaring off over the one Ring
~Least missed chacter~ Tom Bombadil
~Worst supporting character~ grima

i dont have any reasons just felt like voting them

[Thorongil]

I'll go with this:

~Best Overall Character~ Gandalf
~Best Female Character~ Galadriel
~Best Male Character~ Gandalf
~Best Cameo Appearance~ PJ
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Balrog
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir
~Best Battle~ Pellenor
~Best Maia~ Gandalf
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum
~Most missed character~ Glorfindel
~Best hairdo~ Legolas (don't really care about this, but I'll give Leggy one)
~Best supporting character~ Samwise Gamgee

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen
~Worst Male Character~ Legolas
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ
~Worst Overall Villain~ Gothmog
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Shelob
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor
~Worst Maia~ Sauron
~Worst Hairdo~ Haldir
~Worst dramatic scene~Faramir and Frodo squaring off over the one Ring
~Least missed chacter~ Tom Bombadil
~Worst supporting character~ Grima Wormtongue

[Eowyn Wenhamir]

Um ahem Nemrothiel:

Sam was not even mildly tempted by the Ring. He WORE it at didn't get possessed.

No offence to Faramir. He did very well.

[Luthien_ Tinuviel]

Best Overall Character: Sam, how could I say otherwise? :D
Best Female Character: Éowyn, I've always liked her best
Best Male Character: Sam, he's the bestest hobbit ever
Best Cameo: Beregond, he's spiffy
Best Villain: Gollum, the treacherous sneak.......
Best Creature: Bill the Pony :D
Best Comedy: Any light-hearted hobbit jokes
Best Monologue: Well, okay, here's a movie one: Sam's speech in Osgiliath
Best Death: Theoden
Best Battle: The Battle of the Pelennor Fields!
Best Maia: Gandalf, of course
Best Dramatic Moment: Movies: Pippin's song/Faramir's charge, books: The Cracks of Doom and The End of All Things.....
Most pitied character: Sam, poor guy...... And Frodo.....
Most missed: The movies need more Beregond!
Best Harido: Boromir- it always looks messy but good.

Okay, this is going to have to be all movies........

Worst overall character: Gollum, not because of a bad performance, but because he's a sneak.......
Worst female character: None.....
Worst Male Character: Elrond (He was Agent Elrond, so wrong....)
Worst Cameo: PJ's first (it's just weird)
Worst Villain: Sauron, but that's a compliment........... Worst as in bad would go to the orc whose warg Aragorn got attached to......
Worst Monster: The wargs
Worst Monologue: None......
Worst Maia: None
Worst Hairdo: None! (That I can think of).....

[Sleepy Ranger]

~Best Overall Character~ Aragorn(3), Elrond, Faramir, Gandalf, Sam
~Best Female Character~ Eowyn(4), Galadriel(3)
~Best Male Character~ Aragorn(4), Faramir , Gandalf, Sam
~Best Cameo Appearance~ PJ(2), Elanor(2), Viggo's son, Beregond
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman(5), Gollum
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Balrog(3), Fell Beast, Treebeard(2), Bill
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin(6)
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn(5), Sam(2)
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir(3), Theoden(4)
~Best Battle~ Pellenor(5), Helms Deep
~Best Maia~ Gandalf(5) Saruman
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song(7), The Cracks of Doom
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum(4), Deagol, Sam, Frodo
~Most missed character~ Tom Bombadil(2), Twins, Glorfindel(3), Beregond
~Best hairdo~ Galadriel, Arwen, Legolas(3), Boromir
~Best supporting character~ Samwise Gamgee(4)

~Worst Overall Character~ Legolas(4), Sauron, Arwen, Gollum
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen(6)
~Worst Male Character~ Legolas(3), Gimli, Haldir, Elrond(2)
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ(6)
~Worst Overall Villain~ Gothmog(2), Sauron(5), Shelob
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Shelob(4), Treebeard, Wargs(2)
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli(4)
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo(6)
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor(3), Boromir, Haldir
~Worst Maia~ Sauron(5)
~Worst Hairdo~ Haldir(4), Aragorn
~Worst dramatic scene~ Faramir and Frodo squaring off over the one Ring(3)
~Least missed chacter~ Tom Bombadil(3)
~Worst supporting character~ Grima Wormtongue(3)

The results so far.

[rutslegolas]

aragorn seems to be leading:smokin:

[Nimrothiel]

Sorry about splitting up the category Sleepy.:( When I said that Faramir was the only other man who resisted the Ring, I meant just that. Sam may resemble a man, and hobbits may be distantly related to men, but as we don't entirely know this for certain I think of hobbits and men as two different races.
Huh, Aragorn's winning; there must not be any Leggy-boppers looking at this topic.:cool:

[Duncariel]

~Best Overall Character~ Elrond (He's one of the most solid characters)
~Best Female Character~ Eowyn (need I explain?)
~Best Male Character~ Elrond...
~Best Cameo Appearance~ Viggo's son
~Best Overall Villain~ Saruman
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ The Witch King (that's who I want to be when I grow up)
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Denethor (I went to the movie for the fourth time just to see him fly off the pinnacle of Minas Tirith)
~Best Battle~ Helms Deep (but for the Elves it would have been perfect)
~Best Maia~ Gandalf
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song (*sniff*)
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum
~Most missed character~ Glorfindel,
~Best hairdo~ Galadriel
~Best supporting character~ Merry (he doesn't ever get any credit)

~Worst Overall Character~ Arwen
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen
~Worst Male Character~ Frodo (grrrrr)
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ
~Worst Overall Villain~ Shelob
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Wargs (If that was even part wolf, then I'm a hobbit)
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Frodo (double grrrrrr)
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Haldir
~Worst Maia~ Sauron
~Worst Hairdo~ Aragorn
~Worst dramatic scene~ Arwen dropping the book (don't ask me why, that just always bothered me)
~Least missed chacter~ Tom Bombadil
~Worst supporting character~ Grima Wormtongue

That was possibly one of the most blasphemous things I've ever done (to the books, mind you). But it was fun anyway.

[Vuelve]

Hmmm.. this topic seems to have gotten a little out of hand, this is not quite what I had in mind.It looks like something that should be moved to the movies section.I didn't mean for you to take Oscar seriously.Example; Best overall character, Best cameo, etc... I meant for this to be a little more mirthical, maybe a little random just not too random.Maybe I should have asked you to think more along the lines of MTV movie awards.This was not supposed to turn into a poll to vote on.If I would have wanted that I would have put it in the movies as a poll.I meant for you to make up silly awards and give them to characters.
On a lighter note here's some examples.Forgive me if they're not too mirthical, I seem to lack in that category.

Best Scream/Shriek Award -Nazgul
Best or worst maybe spazing fit award- Frodo(nobody can do it like Frodo can.)
Captain Obvious Award- Legolas(for the "a divirsion" bit and something else I just can't think of it at the moment.)

Peace and sorry for the misunderstanding,
Vuelve:smokin:

[rutslegolas]

its ok vuelve but we enjoy the topics its quite fum is;int it sleepy???:smokin: :smokin:

[Vuelve]

its ok vuelve but we enjoy the topics its quite fum is;int it sleepy???

LOL hey rutslegolas could you run that by me again?:D

Sorry about my previous post I was quite rude wasn't I.By all means let the voting continue.

Peace,
Vuelve

[Firefoot]

Well, for a few random things:

Worst singer: Tom Bombadil - that "hey dol derry dol" gets annoying.
Best singer: Movie Pippin. I like all three of his songs.

And here are my votes:
~Best Overall Character~ Sam - he's one of my favorite characters and of all my favorites he is best portrayed in the movies.
~Best Female Character~ Eowyn
~Best Male Character~ Sam
~Best Cameo Appearance~ Viggo's son
~Best Overall Villain~ The Witch King
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ The Watcher in the Water
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn - I love his Black Gate speech!
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir
~Best Battle~ Pelennor Fields (not including the Siege part. Just the actual battle)
~Best Maia~ Gandalf
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Faramir when Denethor says all those things to him.
~Most missed character~ Glorfindel
~Best hairdo~ Galadriel
~Best supporting character~ Sam

~Worst Overall Character~ Arwen
~Worst Female Character~ Arwen
~Worst Male Character~ Elrond - he scares me, especially when he smiles *shudders*
~Worst Cameo Appearance~ PJ
~Worst Overall Villain~ Sauron's spotlight. I mean eye.
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~ Lemming Hyenas. Er, wargs.
~Worst Comedic Character~ Gimli - he has some of the worst lines.
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~ Treebeard - he just drones on and on and on...
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor - I thought it was dumb.
~Worst Maia~ Sauron
~Worst Hairdo~ Aragorn
~Worst dramatic scene~ Frodo and Faramir...
~Least missed chacter~ Tom Bombadil
~Worst supporting character~ Grima

[Lyta_Underhill]

~Most missed character~ Glorfindel According to theonering.net, Glorfindel might not be missed at all, but supposedly appeared at the coronation! They've got pictures too...

Glorfindel pics (http://www.theonering.net/scrapbook/view/12658)

~Worst Female Character~ Arwen
~Worst Male Character~ Elrond - he scares me, especially when he smiles *shudders* Am I the only person who *likes* Arwen and Elrond? (I was mad at Elrond before ROTK, but after seeing his look at the coronation, I am no longer mad at him...), and I've always thought Arwen to be stronger than many others I won't name! ;) (and not in that "Xenarwen" way from FOTR, either...)

OK, so this is "The Mirthies" and not a beef thread...sometimes I just have to spout. Thanks for your indulgence! :)
Once I get the hang of it, perhaps I'll contribute!

Signing off from Cerin Amroth, Cheers!
Lyta

[Nimrothiel]

THAT'S GLORFINDEL?!!!:eek: He looks...stoned or something.:confused: I now have a different person/character to vote for in the category "Worst Cameo"!

[Elennar Starfire]

Best nose: Faramir

[Nimrothiel]

Wait, is that "Best Nose" or "Biggest Nose"?;) (Curses upon the head of whoever got rid of the evil smiley!!!) Either way my vote doesn't change, and I'm not poking fun at Faramir.

[Elennar Starfire]

Nor am I.

[Thorongil]

I have one: Worst eating scene... Definately Denethor:D

[Vuelve]

I have one: Worst eating scene... Definately Denethor

*Yuck* I had a bottle of water with me in the theater and I felt like throwing it at the screen whenever he came on.He made me so mad.


EDIT: This is my 100th post!!!!! WOOOO!!! Do the wave!!!!

[Sleepy Ranger]

People. Vote. Vote Vote. 9 more days

[galadriel'smaiden]

I think the worst eating scene was Gollum and the fish @ the begining of ROTK. EEEEEEW.....! :eek:

[Thorongil]

Well, Gullum eats ugly too, but Denethor was worst I think, mainly because of the blood.

[Lalaithwen]

~Best Overall Character~ Sam
~Best Female Character~ Eowyn
~Best Male Character~ Aragorn
~Best Cameo Appearance~ PJ
~Best Overall Villain~ Sauron
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Shelob
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Witch-King
~Best Battle~ Helm's Deep
~Best Maia~ Gandalf
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Pippin's song/Faramir's charge at Osgiliath
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum
~Most missed character~ Tom Bombadil
~Best hairdo~ Arwen

I couldn't decide on any of the worst ones so I decided not to vote on those

[Luthien_ Tinuviel]

Best Attempted Ballet-like Fall by a Non-Ballet Student: Movie Frodo, for that fall in Mordor when he's supposed to be avoiding the Eye of Sauron.....

Best Eye-rolling: Movie Frodo again, it's rather obvious why.....

Best Bowage: (That has an odd ring to it......) The part of King Elessar's coronation where everyone bows to the hobbits.

[The Saucepan Man]

Best Eye-rolling: Movie Frodo again, it's rather obvious why..... ... although Sauron was rather miffed not to be given the award for his performance during the destruction of the Tower of Barad-Dur. :D

[Luthien_ Tinuviel]

He has his own award, though..... Best Performance as a Searchlight by an Animated Lighthouse.

[Lalaithwen]

These votes are on behalf of my best friend:
~Best Overall Character~ Pippin
~Best Female Character~ Arwen
~Best Male Character~ Aragorn
~Best Cameo Appearance~
~Best Overall Villain~ Saurman
~Best Monster/Creature Character~ Smeagol
~Best Comedic Character~ Pippin
~Best Character Monologue/Speech~ Aragorn’s 1 in ROTK
~Best Overall Death Scene~ Boromir
~Best Battle~ Helm’s Deep
~Best Maia~
~Most Dramatic Moment~ Sam in ROTK
~Most Pitied Person/Creature~ Gollum
~Most missed character~
~Best hairdo~ Arwen

~Worst Overall Character~ Denethor
~Worst Female Character~ Eowyn
~Worst Male Character~ Denthor
~Worst Cameo Appearance~
~Worst Overall Villain~ Sauron….kinda lame
~Worst Monster/Creature Character~
~Worst Comedic Character~
~Worst Character Monologue/Speech~
~Worst Overall Death Scene~ Denethor……there could have been a bit more drama…….or blood or screaming
~Worst Maia~
~Worst Hairdo~ Aragorn……..too greasy (hehe)

[Oddwen]

May I offer:

Best Wave: The crowd for Boromir the Disco King; Osgiliath, TTT EE

The Akimbo Award: Frodo falling when released from the Eye; RotK.

Scariest Sudden Appearance: Elrond, Frodo's dream sequence; FotR.

Best Car(t) Chase: Hobbit children chasing Gandalf; FotR.

Hobbit Most Knowledgable of the Lands Outside of the Shire When He Shouldn't Have Been: Merry, of Treebeard; TTT.

Best Sigh: Arwen; TTT.

Best Hug: Aragorn with the rock on the plains of Rohan; TTT.

Best "I'm A Hero And I Saved Your Life Be Thankful I Acknowledged You" Look: Aragorn, after saving Boromir from the cave troll; FotR EE.

Worst Closeup: The Mouth of Elrond, TTT

Third Worst Eating Scene: Bilbo, pigging out on cheese, FotR.

Happiest Person in the Trilogy For All the Wrong Reasons: Smeagol, when he gets the Ring and puts it on; RotK.

[Luthien_ Tinuviel]

Best Digusting Makeup Worn by a Good Character: Frodo, during the Flight to the Ford, FOTR

Most Obvious Line: Legolas, ROTK.... "A diversion!"

Worst Pseudo-Jewelry Commercial: Legolas and Aragorn's reunion, TTT- "You're late. You look terrible. Here. Have a girly necklace."

Best Range of Looks, Stares, Frowns, Scowls, Grins, and Winces: Sean Astin, in the role of Sam, o' course! :D

[Nimrothiel]

For "Worst Closeup" I'd have to say Denethor (eating the cherry tomato; bleah.)

[Oddwen]

Best Disgusting Makeup Worn By A Good Person Not Included In A Finished Film: Frodo, in a Gollum-like state.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v58/Oddwen/frodosupercreep.jpg

(Isn't that awesome?)