What would you do?

[Lindalirien O Lorien]

I waas wondering if you were an elf in Valinor during Feanor's rebellion what would you do? Would you follow him or stay behind? Why?

[Fingolfin II]

I'd follow him because all my mates would (if I was a Noldo) so I'd stand by them. If I was a Vanyar or Teleri I'd stay. After the kinslaying, I'd probably return to Valinor with Finarfin.

[Lord of Angmar]

I would hope to think logically in such a situation and come to the decision that remaining in the bliss of Valinor would be the best idea...

...but you never know, I am a sucker for emotionally charged arguments.

[The Mushroom]

I'm a hobbit all through so I wouldn't be in Valinor anyways, but if I was an elf...hmmm... I'm not entirely sure. I think I would stay in Valinor. I'd prefer the easy life and (hehehe) I wouldn't want to go on an adventure! ;)