Would you rather.....

[Elfchick7]

Ok, y'all, I don't know if this has been done before. IF IT HAS I APOLOGIZE. :D

Anyway, I'll put a ME related "would you rather..." up. The next person answers, then post their own "would you rather..."

Ready? Here goes:

Would you rather lembas or cheesecake? ;)

[Estelyn Telcontar]

As this is a game, I'm moving it to the Mirth forum. Please read and post there - thanks!

[Ataralasse]

Lembas. I'm not big on cheesecake.

Would you rather live in Mirkwood or Loth-Lorien?

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Would you rather live in Mirkwood or Loth-Lorien?
Mirkwood! (who readeth, understand) But I'd make it look like Lothlórien.

Would you rather have a cup of tea with Gandalf or Lobelia?

[The Might]

Well Lobelia might be offended if I turned her down, but an umbrella hit is better then bolts of lightning, so I'll go with Gandalf

Would you rather cut Mouth of Sauron's head or let him go?

[Thinlómien]

I'd rather let him go, I'm anti-capital punishment.


Would you rather fire Sam from his gardening job or doom Gaffer to eternal lack of taters?

(I know I'm nasty. :Merisu: )

[The Might]

I'd fire Sam and then send him off on some important quest

Would you rather eat cram or Eowyn's soup ;)?

[The Sixth Wizard]

Cram. Eowyn can't cook. I've never had any of her cooking, but I know.

Would you rather rub Frodo's feet after climbing Mount Doom or climb the whole mountain by yourself?

[Rikae]

Climb the mountain. Fresh air, great view...um, of Mordor...but still, doesn't sound too bad.

Would you rather recieve a big ol' smooch from Gothmog, or from Gollum?

[The Might]

Gollum, since I'm not sure what Gothmog is
At least I can think Gollum was once a Stoor

[Boo Radley]

Would you rather have to fire the Witch King for incompetence, or be Gollum's personal masseuse?

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Witch-King leads, of course. *shrugs*

Would you rather be a Wizard (of the Istari) or a simple hobbit farmer?

Seriously, please, if possible :)

[Volo]

Probably a hobbit farmer wishing I was an Istari.

Hmm... but then again, that wouldn't make the bost common hobbit.

No! I'd be an Istari wishing I was a hobbit farmer.

Would you rather have the one ring or farmer Maggot's mushroom patch?

[Elfchick7]

Farmer Maggots mushroom patch. The ring is more trouble than it's worth.


Would you rather:

visit Edoras or Lothlorien

[The Might]

Edoras, ales and Rohirric food is definitely more to my likilng then lembas
Plus, too much lembas is bad if you're a mortal

Sorry, I forgot asking last time

Would you rather, destroy the Ring or keep it for yourself? :Merisu:

[Thinlómien]

Err... I'd rather do neither, because the ring shouldn't be kept and destroys your mental health but I wouldn't like to go on a suicide mission to Mordor...

I'd keep it and force Gandalf take it the next time he comes. :Merisu:

Would you rather eat Gollum's half-eaten fish or meat given you by orcs?

[the guy who be short]

I'd rather eat raw fish (which is perfectly good for you) than potential man-flesh.

Would you rather headbutt Legolas or Gimli?

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

That depends. . .Agression wise I would rather headbut Gimli for being a stuppor dwarf, but for my own skull sake i would rather headbut Legolas. . .

wait it would be next to impossible for me to headbut Gimli. . .ok Legolas it is, but for practical reasons.


Would you rather defeat Sauron in a duel or stay at home eating a pie?

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Well, that depends on many factors. Mainly what type of duel it would be, and what type of pie it would be.

Would you rather visit Amon Hen (the Hill of Seeing) or Amon Lhaw (the Hill of Hearing), presuming you could see/hear all that's going on in the whole Middle-Earth?

[Rikae]

I think that, being 75% blind, I'd get more out of a visit to Amon Lhaw.
:Merisu:
I look better than I look (I hope).

Would you rather walk the length of tha Anduin with the Red Book of Westmarch balanced on your head, or listen to Eowyn singing the Red Book in its entirety?

[Ataralasse]

Eowyn has a nice voice, and while I'm sure walking down the Anduin would be a great camping trip, I can't help thinking of how long it would be.

So ... red book sung.

Would you rather be an Elf captured by Dwarves, or a Dwarf captured by Elves?

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

A dwarf captured by elves. Whoever it might be would feed the prisoners their leftovers, and I'd rather have elves' leftovers than dwarves' leftovers. (I'm thinking bacon fat, etc *shudders*)

Anywho, would you rather dance with a hobbit or an elf?

[The Might]

A hobbit; Elves have so much time to practice I couldn't be able to keep the pace with them

Would you have liked being a beacon guardian or a woodman?

[Elfchick7]

A woodman! Would you rather spend a week as Gollum or as Lurtz?

[TheGreatElvenWarrior]

Which week? The week that the get killed? I'd rather not...

Would you rather go to Mordor or Angband?

[Babidi Buu]

I would rather go to Mordor. it Is one of my Favorite vacation spots ^_^ Angband, I dont really know much about it. :(

Would you rather marry Gothmog(Piggy-Potato) or the Mouth of Sauron?

[TheGreatElvenWarrior]

Defenentely the Mouth... he has so much power, second only to Sauron, plus I bet he gives really good kisses. (Him being the Mouth and all)

Would you rather have married Lotho Sackville-Baggins or Ted Sandyman?

[Lindale]

Lotho...not a fan of old nobility (who didn't really get the gold), but then I'd rather have that than a goon.

Cater at Bilbo's party or be a cook at Elrond's house?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Bilbo's pad! "Party on dude!"
(Elves are too laid back).

Would you rather ski down Caradhras or Gundabad?

[Lindale]

erm.... Caradhras. Gundabad, too far.. or so I think. Isn't that where Durin awoke? :Merisu:

Dive at the seas that once were Beleriand, or once were Numenor?

[Thinlómien]

Beleriand, most definitely. Númenor would be interesting but all the most legendary places are in Beleriand, and besides there's much more to explore.

Would you rather live in the original Minas Tirith (before it became Tol-in-Gaurhoth ;)) or the Minas Tirith of Gondor?

[Lindale]

Tol-i-Gaurhoth. As you said, Beleriand is much more exciting. So is the First age, as compared to the third.

Take side with Aldarion, or with Erendis? :p

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Aldarion. You get to sail all over Middle-earth and
party on as one of the Beautiful People, with
no doubt, lots of dates with primitive hotties.

Would you rather hang out with Gollum or Smeagol? :D :mad:

[Babidi Buu]

Smeagol. You never know what gollum is up to..

Would you Rather have Aragorn battle the Witch-King or the King of the Dead battle the Witch-King? (If Eowyn either died or Didn't battle witch-king.)

[TheGreatElvenWarrior]

King of the dead, you see he's not a man per se...

Would you rather fight next to Turin or Hurin?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurin! You can't trust (do business with)
that hothead Turin. Hurin has all my confidence.
As someone once observed
in a different situation.
I thought Santino was a bad Don, rest in peace.
Michael has all my confidence. :cool:


Would you rather have a bottle of Old Vinyards or a shot of an entdraught.

[Elfchick7]

old vinyards, I'm more than tall enough as it is.

would you rather walk through Mordor barefoot with the witchking after you, or go through Moria with no means of navigation aside from your own intelligence?

[Lindale]

old vinyards, I'm more than tall enough as it is.

would you rather walk through Mordor barefoot with the witchking after you, or go through Moria with no means of navigation aside from your own intelligence?

erm... I'd go for the Witchking. I don't wish to die of starvation. I'd rather be... I don't know, either dead-quickly or undead.

Take the oath of Feanor or be an Orc?:D

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Take the oath of Feanor or be an Orc?:D

Be an Orc, of course! What's wrong about the Orcs anyway?

To send into Middle-Earth, Saruman or Radagast?

[Babidi Buu]

To send into Middle-Earth, Saruman or Radagast?

Probably... Radagast, I dont really know much about him but im guessing he's one of the good guy's. and from what i heard he's alot better then Saruman!

Would you Rather..

Be an Orc during the Charge of the Rohirram at Pelannor or Battle against Smaug?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Be an Orc during the Charge of the Rohirram at Pelannor or Battle against Smaug?

If the book (not movie charge) The Rohirram Charge, since
you might survive, while against Smaug...

Would you rather be...a young orc carrying a message by
Shelob's lair or sent to get the Goblin King a nice
fish for dinner?

[Babidi Buu]

Would you rather be...a young orc carrying a message by
Shelob's lair or sent to get the Goblin King a nice
fish for dinner?

Get the Goblin King a Nice fish for dinner, Doesn't sound to dangerous and sounds easy enough.:p

Would you Rather be an Orc of Mordor or an Orc of Isengard?

[Gollum the Great]

Isengard. Saruman was way cooler.


Would you rather ride a great eagle or a hell-hawk (the fell beasts)?

[Caladarasiel]

Ummm let me think this is such a hard descision I pick Eagle!

Would you rather be a prisoner to Sauron or Sarauman?

[Lindale]

Saruman na lang. Orthanc would be lovelier than Mordor, I guess

Visit at her respective home Morwen, Erendis, Ancalime, or Niniel?

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

I get the feeling Morwen would be more interesting than the others, so I choose her.

Would you rather go clubbing with hip young things from Rohan or Gondor?

[Lalaith]

Oh, good call.
On reflection...I'd rather eat out with Gondorians, but I think the Rohirrim would make better ravers...

Would you rather align yourself with the North or South Kingdom?

[Galadriel55]

the north. they're more interesting

would you rather be an orc lost in Fangorn Forest or a hobbit surrounded by all 9 nazguls?

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

An Orc. It might escape the trees and Ents, but the Hobbit has no chance. Plus I could curse and slaver and snarl to my heart's content.

Would you rather fight the Watcher in the Water or Treebeard?

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

Treebeard! First of all he isn't slimy and does not hide in weird places, but mostly I chose him because I know by which means he can be defeated. I will most likely loose any fight, but I have most information about treebeard.


Would you rather beat Denethor with a shovel or throw Legolas into Mount Doom?

[Galadriel55]

Beat Denethor with a shovel. He deserves it for being so mean to Faramir and so rude to Gandalf. Plus, Legolas is still too young to die! lol

OK. Would you rather tickle Smaug or try to throw a lasso at a Nazgul?

[Folwren]

Throw a lasso. There is a chance I might miss and not be noticed.

Would you rather become a shirriff and betray all your friends to the Big Men, or would you rather be loyal and be locked up in the lockholes?

[Galadriel55]

Would you rather become a shirriff and betray all your friends to the Big Men, or would you rather be loyal and be locked up in the lockholes?

Be loyal - you will be released anyways when Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin come back, and you will be a hero, and you will have many friends. Whereas I doubt that the former sheriffs had many friends left after Saruman was killed.

Oh god! It's getting harder and harder to come up with new things!
How about this: face an angry Turin Turambar or get caught by Thorin Oakenshield while stealing his father's jewel (I forget what its called)?

[Diamond18]

Since it's unclear what I've done to anger Turin, I'll assume that I'm in the right and he's being unreasonable, so I'll go with that. I'd rather not be stealing anyone's jewels.

Would you rather be an Elf or a Hobbit?

(I'm surprised this one hasn't been asked as it's a rather basic one. :p)

[Galadriel55]

a hobbit. I don't care much for living for thousands of years; it gets boring after a couple of hundred...:)

Here's another simple one:would you rather be Merry or Pippin?

[Galadriel55]

Since no one seems to want to answer this one, I'll do it myself. I'd rather be Merry - I would prefer Theoden's copany to Denethor's.
Here's a different question, and hopefully people will answer.

Would you rather be Saruman or Grima Wortongue?

[Diamond18]

Saruman. Grima has no luck with the ladies.

Would you rather be eaten by Shelob, or die of starvation in Mordor?

[Galadriel55]

die in Mordor. At least people will say that you died because of unfortunate circumstances, not your own lack of fighting skills or vigilance or whatever else I needed to pass Shelob. (it's not your fault that you died)

would you rather be Morgoth or Sauron?

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

I'd rather be Sauron. Morgoth must get so annoyed, walking around with a limp all the time. :p

Would you rather drink at the Prancing Pony or the Green Dragon?

[elronds_daughter]

Definitely Morgoth. Sauron got owned. (EDIT: Yes, I know Morgoth's doom is inevitable. But more powerful being = more epic destruction.)

Would you rather have Gandalf angry with you or do battle with Aragorn?

[Eomer of the Rohirrim]

Double post! :smokin:

Next person, answer both questions.

[Galadriel55]

The Prancing Pony sounds more interesting, since you have hobbits, men, and sometimes dwarves to talk to.
I'd rather have Gandalf get angry at me, since it doesn't specify who I am and what I've done. I'll assume I'm not a Nazgul or Grima Wormtongue or any other evil character. Maybe I'm Pippin, and he yells "Fool of a Took!" at me. Even if I did do something wrong, Gandalf will get angry to make sure that I don't do it again, not for any other reason.

If you were to visit one of the following Elven settlements, which one would it be?
Rivendell, Lothlorien, Grey Havens, Mirkwood, or Hollin (Eregion) when it still existed?

[elronds_daughter]

Mirkwood, definitely. As long as the spiders mind their own business. :)

Would you rather live with Beorn or Quickbeam?

[Galadriel55]

Beorn would be more lively.

Would you rather be Beren or Aragorn?

[sassyfriend]

I would be Aragorn

Would u rather be killed by Aragorn or Legolas?

[Elfchick7]

Legolas, I feel that he'd make it quicker.

Would you rather have to fight a balrog or Saruman?

[Galadriel55]

Balrog. Just throw him off a cliff. You never know what tricks Saruman is up to.

Would you rather visit Caras Galadhon or Cerin Amroth?

[sassyfriend]

Caras galadron

Would u rather walk on snow or walk on water?

[Pitchwife]

Water, because this includes the ability to walk on snow, which is just frozen water.

Would you rather ride an Eagle or a Fell Beast?

[Bom Tombadillo]

Fell beasts are explicitly said to stink, so Eagles.

Would you rather be a good or evil Ainu? (Assume an approximately equal chance of success for each side).

[sassyfriend]

Good

Would you rather be forced to stay 40 in Mordor or Moria?

[Galadriel55]

Moria, because it wasn't always evit and it's more mysterious. And away from Sauron.

Would you rather be Sauron or Morgoth?

[sassyfriend]

Sauron

Would u rather remember 9/11 or Be in a war?

[Galadriel55]

Would u rather remember 9/11 or Be in a war?

I'm not sure how that is related to ME...

That depends on which war it is. If it's one of those romanticised long-ago wars, then go to war. But if you're talking about relatively modern wars, then 9/11. I guess 9/11 for a final answer.

Would you rather be captured in Dol Guldur or in Barad Dur?

[sassyfriend]

Bararad dur

Would u rather be stepped on by ents or by a troll

[Bom Tombadillo]

Trolls. One could probably live out one's entire life before an Ent got around to stepping off of you . . .

Then again, if you're being stepped on by a troll, you probably won't have a life to live out much longer.

Would you rather be in the army of Saruman or Sauron?

[Galadriel55]

Saruman. I think that Ugluk is cooler than Grishnakh.

Would you rather be a Ranger of the North or of Ithilien?

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Ithilien. I really like that place. It's... I don't know, I think it's greener. Plus, you get Henneth Annun with the lovely waterfall. In the North, I'd only get "random ruins after being kicked out of Butterbur's Inn and walking three days in wet clothes, Part Two".

Would you rather be sent to negotiate with Smaug or the Mouth of Sauron?

[sassyfriend]

With smaug

Would u rather have a fight with Aragorn or Boromir?

[Bom Tombadillo]

Boromir. He seems to be a generally worse fighter than Aragorn, so as I am I'd be more likely to survive; and assuming the fight is on even terms, I'd fight Boromir because I don't like him as much.

Would you rather go with Frodo and Sam to Mount Doom or with Merry and Pippin to Isengard?

[Aganzir]

Isengard with Merry and Pippin. Even if the start is nasty, in the end there's food, drink and a cool wizard - whereas if I went with Frodo and Sam, all I got would be hunger, thirst, despair and missing fingers.

Would you rather be a Man in the First Age or an Elf in the Third?

[sassyfriend]

Elf in the third

Whould you rather Hear verbal fights from Aragorn/Boromir or Boromir/Legolas

[Galadriel55]

Boromir/Legolas. We hear a lot from Legolas/Gimli and Boromir/Aragorn, but not from Boromir/Legolas. It would be interesting to see how they pursuade each other.

Would you rather be Turin or Nienor (regardless of gender)?

[sassyfriend]

Not sure who they are so i'll say turin

would u rather have an Orc or a Troll for a pet

[Galadriel55]

Not sure who they are so i'll say turin

They are brother and sister with a tragic fate. They appear in The Silmarillion, Children of Hurin, and Unfinished Tales.

Orc. They are easier to kill once they get too pesky.

Would you rather be saved by Gwaihir or Thorondor?

[sassyfriend]

Gwaihar

Would u rather cry with Pippin or Boromir

[Nerwen]

Gwaihar

Would u rather cry with Pippin or Boromir
Meaning?:confused:

[sassyfriend]

If something sad happend....

[Elfchick7]

Pippin, he would do something funny to cheer me up.

Would you rather live in Lake Town or Edoras?

[Morthoron]

Would you rather live in Lake Town or Edoras?

Lake access property is always more valuable. That is, after Smaug does his final belly flop, of course. ;)

Would you rather be on the ship with Elendil sailing to the shores of Middle-earth, or on the ship with Frodo sailing to Valinor?

[sassyfriend]

valinor

would u rather hug Aragorn or Legolas?

[Aganzir]

Aragorn. I prefer Men to Elves.

Would you rather bite off Beren's hand or Frodo's finger?

For future reference, it's more fun if you explain your answer briefly.

[Galadriel55]

Would you rather bite off Beren's hand or Frodo's finger?

Which one of them are you?

He bit me, and I was not gentle.

;) :D

Beren's hand. I like wolves better than Gollums. So I'd rather be Carcharoth that ol' Stinker.

Would you rather be at the Long Expected Party or the Unexpected Party?

[sassyfriend]

At the long expected party I think it would be cool to party with hobbits and Gandalf :D

Would you rather dance with Aragorn or Gandalf?

[Galadriel55]

Aragorn. I don't see Gandalf as a dancing type.

Would you rather face a Nazgul or a Barrow-wight?

[sassyfriend]

A nazgul so I can kick some baddie butt!

Would you rather die like Aragorn or like Boromir?

[Galadriel55]

Hmm... both are rather interesting deaths. They both accept their death in the end, but Aragorn dies peacefully and Boromir in a fight. Boromir also has a redemption moment in his last breath...

I think Boromir, just because of the "romantic" point of view of dying in a battle.

Would you rather defend Helm's deep or Dunharrow in a battle?

[sassyfriend]

Defend helms deep because i'd be with the best fighters!

Would you rather kiss an orc or Gollum?

[Aganzir]

Which one of them are you?
I was actually Beren in a WW game some time ago, and Shastanis Tinúviel was my lover. But Frodo is one of my favourite characters.

I'd rather kiss an orc. Think of the taste of Gollum's 500-year-old mouth, especially after all that fish! Besides there's this really hot orc in one of the movies.

Would you rather be the Steward or the King?

[sassyfriend]

The steward because I'd rather serve the King

would u rather fly on an eagle or a fell beast?

[Galadriel55]

I was actually Beren in a WW game some time ago, and Shastanis Tinúviel was my lover. But Frodo is one of my favourite characters.

Rikae's game? And I just meant your siggie. That's not from the game.... is it?

An eagle. They would help me. The fell beasts, on the other hand, would bring me straiht to Sauron.

Would you rather be Maedhros, Maglor, Celegorm, Caranthir, Curufin, Amrod, or Amras?

[sassyfriend]

Amrod even though i don't know who s/he is.

Would you rather Boromir had the one ring or Aragorn?

[Galadriel55]

Aragorn. He would give it back to Frodo on the first chance. We all know what Boromir would do. ;)

Amrod even though i don't know who s/he is.

They are all sons of Feanor. First Age stuff.

Would you rather recieve a sack of lembas or a coil of elvish rope as a gift from Lorien?

[Bom Tombadillo]

Sack of lembas. OMNOMNOM! :D

Would you rather be Feanor or Frodo?

[Galadriel55]

Feanor, because I wouldn't want to end my days in Middle Earth in melancholy.

Would you rather be Saruman or Radagast?

[Aganzir]

Rikae's game? And I just meant your siggie. That's not from the game.... is it?
Yes that one. And I know you did but it just reminded me of being Beren. ;) The sig is not from the game because regardless of what might have happened in private, Shasta and I never publicly bit each other. I bit several Downers in Finlandmoot though.

I'd rather be Saruman because, well, I would be him rather than Radagast. I have this thing for power, you know... and for all the colours of the rainbow.

Would you rather wear Narya, Nenya or Vilya?

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Nenya. You know, water. Even though I never understood that logic, Vilya has sapphire (blue = water) and Elrond commands Bruinen, so... But whatever.

During the days of the major final battles of the War of the Ring, would you prefer to be in Minas Tirith or Erebor?

[Aganzir]

Minas Tirith because my dwarven RPG character of nine years is going home and the new one will be a dashing young nobleman from Minas Tirith - which means that I'm head over heels for all things Gondorian at the moment. Silly reason I know.

Would you rather follow Fëanor, Fingolfin or Finarfin?

[Galadriel55]

Fingolfin. Feanor is to Feanorish, and those who stayed in Aman may be wise but bo-oring.

Would you rather be Bilbo in the "There and Back Again" story, or Merry or Pippin's role in LOTR?

[Bom Tombadillo]

Bilbo, certainly. Every coherent argument I can put together for why it'd be better seems to apply equally to Merry and Pippin, but it just seems like Bilbo gets a generally happier ending.

Would you rather have to fight Fingolfin or Morgoth?

[Galadriel55]

Morgoth. Why would I even want to fight Fingolfin? I'd rather do something crazy and noble.

Would you rather be a Vanya, Noldo, or Teler?

[sassyfriend]

Have no ideal who/what these are but I'd choose Vanya.

would u rather sword fight with Aragorn or Boromir

[Galadriel55]

Aragorn. No particular reason.

Would you rather stay with Bombadil or with Treebeard for a week?

[Bom Tombadillo]

Hmmmmn. I'd probably kill my good twin; his incessant singing might be nice for a few minutes, but it would get annoying fast. On the other hand, Treebeard . . . yeah, no real downsides there.

Would you rather have to tell Sauron you stole his ring or Feanor you stole a Silmaril?

[Galadriel55]

To answer you, Bom, tell Sauron. It's no great news after all!

Would you rather live in Hobbiton or Bree? (I don't think this was asked before... was it?)

[sassyfriend]

In hobbitton cause its peaceful

Would you rather sing with orcs or Aragorn

[Galadriel55]

Aragorn, doubtless. He might even teach me some ann-thenath...

Would you rather visit ME for a few days in the beginning of the Second or the Fourth Age?

[sassyfriend]

Possiable second age because thats when the fellowship's together right?

Would you rather prank Legolas or Gandalf

[Legate of Amon Lanc]

Possiable second age because thats when the fellowship's together right?

Would you rather prank Legolas or Gandalf

That was Third Age, but whatever :)

As for the question - definitely Gandalf! I mean, there is nothing fun about pranking Legolas - but with Gandalf, whoo, that must be exciting! I mean, dangerous and fun to see and try to expect his reactions! :smokin:

Would you rather have Denethor (the Steward) or Thingol as your boss?

[Bom Tombadillo]

Thingol, definitely.

Would you rather be a King of Men or an average Elf?

[Galadriel55]

Average Elf. I'm not really the one for power.

Would you rather have to fight Carcharoth or Huan?

[sassyfriend]

I'd fight huan

Would u rather prank Elladan or Boromir

[Galadriel55]

What is it about pranking?

And Elladan. Cause I know in advance how Boromir would react... :D

Would you rather be in the company of Elladan, Elrohir, or Arwen for a year?

[sassyfriend]

Well I think it'd be funny to prank people in the fellowship,etc

I'd wanna be with the twins I think they are cool for bros!

Would you rather have a singalong or a dancealong with the fellowship?

[Elfchick7]

A singalong, because I love to sing. =)

Would you rather have to help Gimli or the Sackville-Bagginses adjust to our modern world?

[Folwren]

The Sackville-Bagginses, because I think they'd adjust better.

Would you rather break the rules in Rivendell or in Lothlorien?

[Galadriel55]

Rivendell. It has a more adventurous, nauhty, rule-breaking feel to it. Also, Elrond is more "lenient" than Calaborn and Galadriel...

Would you rather be Gollum or Frodo?

[Bom Tombadillo]

:eek: What a silly question. Frodo, of course.

Would you rather be Grima or Bill Ferny?

[Folwren]

Bill Ferny. At least he's not shot by hobbits.

Would you rather fight Saruman or Gandalf?

[Galadriel55]

Saruman. What's the point of fighting Gandalf?

What a silly question.

I'm sure the question is offended. :p And I took a while to decide when I asked myself that question.

Would you rather remain and die with Finrod or Barahir?

[sassyfriend]

I would remain with barahir

Would you rather argue with Gimli or Gollum

[Galadriel55]

Gimli, since it's pointless to argue with Gollum. You'll never know what his final thoughts are on the matter.

Would you rather bother Gandalf or Sauron with "would you rather" questions?

[Folwren]

Gandalf. I wouldn't bother Sauron with ANYTHING, even if it was something important, much less with something pointless and annoying like this.

Would you rather spend a night in the Old Forest or in Mirkwood?

[Galadriel55]

Old Forest. It fascinates me more.

Would you rather be a hobbit drowning in the Brandywine or a Man in Anduin?

[sassyfriend]

Hobbit in brandywine

Would u rather poke fun at Frodo or Aragorn

[Galadriel55]

Aragorn. He has a broader sense of humour, and he just seems more pokable-funable. :D

Would you rather pair with Aragorn or Faramir when going on a quest that needs 2 people?

[Aganzir]

Faramir because I have a thing for Gondorian Dúnedain.

Would you rather kiss the Witch King or the Barrow-Wight?

[Galadriel55]

Wight. It's just thematic. :smokin:

Would you rather be Saruman's or Denethor's personal servant/waiter/etc.?

[Bom Tombadillo]

Mmmn. Saruman seems better, but based on how he treats Grima . . . Plus I'd have to deal with Orcs. So, Denethor, but just barely.

Would you rather be Frodo or Sam?

[Galadriel55]

Bom, what is it with cats? A cat signature, a cat avatar... ;)

Sam. I don't really know why. Possibly because he feels closer than Frodo.

Would you rather talk with Cirdan or with Celeborn about ME?

[Bom Tombadillo]

*whispers* She knows too much. Send in the catsassins.

*ahem* Anyways, I'd rather talk with Cirdan. He was there at Cuivienen, right?

Would you rather be trapped in Moria or Shelob's lair? (assuming, of course, that you don't encounter the Balrog).

[sassyfriend]

Moria rather face orcs then spiders any day! Shudders

Would u rather be cought off guard by Aragorn or Faramir

[Rune Son of Bjarne]

Not that I am quite sure what you mean by "caught of guard", but any sensible person would chose Faramir. Aragorn is simply much better at everything.

Who would you rather be rescued from a Wight attack by, Gildor or Tom Bombadil?

[Galadriel55]

I need to be rescued from the likes of me? What utter nonesense! :p

Anyways, old Tom. Gildor is for nazgul, Tom is for wights.

Would you rather be trapped in a barrow and rescued, or take the longer way around the Downs and never get to see them (but safely continue on your way)?

[Bom Tombadillo]

Hmmn. With the knowledge that I have? The barrow, of course. But with the knowledge of the average Middle Earther, I would certainly take the long way.

Would you rather steal something from Smaug or get into a fight with one of the Ringwraiths?

[Blind Guardian]

Ringwraiths definitely.


Would you rather be Melkor or Sauron?

[Galadriel55]

Melkor. Angainor and the Void are a better option in my eyes than two midgets with a Ring and nowhere in particular. Plus, I get to have Silmarils! And I'd rip those wings off me Balrogs once and for all! :D

Would you rather visit Nogrod or Belegost?

[sassyfriend]

Nograd even though i have no ideal who or what ur talking about :confused:

would u rather hear the lament for Gandalf or Boromir

[Galadriel55]

Nograd even though i have no ideal who or what ur talking about

Nogrod and Belegost were Dwarven cities in the Blue Mountains at the times of the First Age.

I'd rather hear the lament for Boromir. For some reason I always thought that it had a complex melody.

Would you rather explore Amon Hen or Amon Lhaw?

[sassyfriend]

Explore Amon hen cause I like places with waterfalls and stuff like that :D Nature friend

Would you rather play chess or tic with the fellowship

[Galadriel55]

I was going down nostalgia lane, looking at all the faces on this thread... And I've decided to revive it, for fun and absolutely no profit.

Rules of the game: the first person asks a "would you rather" question. The next person must answer (with a brief reason), and post the next question. Simple as that.


Would you rather play chess or tic with the fellowship

Chess. I would lose, of course, but it would be interesting to see how different people play and how long it takes each of them to beat me.


Would you rather hear one of Maglor's songs, or one of Daeron's?

[Alassë Estel]

I think I would rather hear songs of Daeron's. If Luthien herself danced to his music, it was probably very fine indeed.

Would you rather find yourself trapped up an evergreen tree by fire, goblins, and evil wolves, or wake up within the cold, clammy, barrow of a wight?