Hurt and Heal VIII: The Elves

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Is there interest in an Elf Hurt and Heal? I don't think
it's been done (I'm too lazy to check). If so, I'd start
by nominating Aredhel , Miriel, and Finduilas.

(I generally share Harry Mudd's views on male/female
androids as applied to elves).

[Urwen]

Me join. Me nominate Serinde,Idril and Maeglin

[Rikae]

Nominate Maedhros, Maglor & Galadriel, second Aredhel.

[the phantom]

I'll third Aredhel, second Miriel, Maedhros, and Maeglin, and I will nominate Elrond, Feanor, and Nerdanel.

NOMINATIONS

Three- Aredhel

Two- Miriel, Maedhros, Maeglin

One- Elrond, Feanor, Nerdanel, Maglor, Galadriel, Serinde, Idril, Finduilas

(How many votes does it take to be cemented?)

[Urwen]

Have you really no knowledge in A.K.A's?

Let me clarify: Miriel=Serinde

[satansaloser2005]

Have you really no knowledge in A.K.A's?

Let me clarify: Miriel=Serinde

Hun, you're not making sense here. You're the one who nominated Serinde after Tuor had already put up Miriel, rather than just seconding the original idea. So please don't insult people when you said it in the first place. I'll edit the list accordingly in a second.


Also, I'll second Galadriel.

[satansaloser2005]

Three: Aredhel, Miriel (Serinde), Maedhros

Two: Maeglin, Galadriel, Elrond

One: Feanor, Nerdanel, Maglor, Idril, Finduilas


I also thirded Maedhros and seconded Elrond (just for kicks). Mentioning it so their repositioning makes sense. I think that's accurate, right?

[the phantom]

Have you really no knowledge in A.K.A's?

Let me clarify: Miriel=Serinde
Indeed, that's the first thought that I had, but seeing as you NOMINATED her rather than SECONDING her, I could only assume that you had someone else in mind (for instance, perhaps you had meant to type Saeros or Singollo) and so I kept "Serinde" on the list assuming you would clarify at a later time.

And in the end you did in fact clarify, so....

[Loslote]

I'll second Nerdanel and Finduilas, and nominate Beleg and Felagund.

[Macalaure]

I'll third Nerdanel, second Beleg Cúthalion, Finrod Felagund, Idril Celebrindal and Maglor, and nominate Amarië, Caranthir, Fingon, Turgon, and Voronwë.

Yay for aliases. :)

(There's no limit on the number of people you can nominate, is there? :rolleyes: )

[Urwen]

I'll pop in again. I think I'll third Idril,second Finrod and nominate Luthien,Celebrimbor and Ereinion

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Nominate Arwen and that wacky skate-boarding elf Legolas.
Second Luthien.
-----------------------------------------------------------



Three: Aredhel, Miriel (Serinde), Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril Celebrindal,

Two: Maeglin, Galadriel, Elrond, Finduilas, , Beleg, and Felagund,
Maglor, Luthien.

One: Feanor, Celebrimbor and Ereinion
Amarië, Caranthir, Fingon, Turgon, and Voronwë.
Legolas. Arwen.

[the phantom]

I third Beleg and Maglor, second Celebrimbor and Caranthir, and nominate Curufin and Eol.

THREE: Aredhel, Miriel, Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril, Beleg, Maglor

TWO: Maeglin, Galadriel, Elrond, Finduilas, Finrod, Luthien, Celebrimbor, Caranthir

ONE: Feanor, Gil-galad, Amarië, Fingon, Turgon, Voronwë, Legolas, Arwen, Curufin, Eol

[Pitchwife]

I third Finrod and Lúthien, second Feanor and Voronwë, and nominate Elu Thingol and Glorfindel.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Unless there's some objection, it looks like definitely in:
Aredhel, Miriel, Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril, Beleg, Maglor, Finrod Felagund,
Luthien Tinuviel
And since it's hard to see an elf contest without him, Feanor .

That's 10 so far. 10 more to go.

TWO: Maeglin, Galadriel, Elrond, Finduilas, , Luthien, Celebrimbor, Caranthir

ONE: Gil-galad, Amarië, Fingon, Turgon, Voronwë, Legolas, Arwen, Curufin, Eol and Voronwë, Elu Thingol and Glorfindel.

[Eönwë]

I nominate Cirdan and Ecthelion, and second Eol and Turgon.

[Urwen]

I third Eol and Maeglin,second Amarie,and nominate Aegnor

[Loslote]

I'll third Caranthir, second Ecthelion, and nominate Haldir.

PS: I had a long debate with myself, but decided that I could not, in good concience, nominate Figwit. :(

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Unless there's some objection, it looks like these are in:
Aredhel, Miriel, Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril, Beleg, Maglor, Finrod Felagund,
Luthien Tinuviel, Eol, Maeglin
And since it's hard to see an elf contest without him, Feanor .

That's 12 so far. 8 more to go.

THIRD: Caranthir

TWO:, Galadriel, Elrond, Finduilas, Celebrimbor, Caranthir,
Ecthelion, Amarie, Eol, Turgon

ONE: Gil-galad, Amarië, Fingon, Voronwë, Legolas, Arwen, Curufin, Voronwë, Elu Thingol and Glorfindel, Haldir, Aegnor,

(Always assuming I haven't miscounted). :)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Looking ahead:
Copying Eonwe's Rules for Hurt and Heal Dwarves:
(Oops, rather late for the excellent nominating Rules) :o

From 20 to 7 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts are allowed.

From 6 to 4 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts ar not allowed: a player has to hurt 2 different characters and heal one, or he may use only 1 hurt and 1 heal.

When but 3 characters are left each player has either a hurt or a heal.

Wait for at least three posters to vote prior to you voting again. (I believe it was wait for four posters in the past.
Is three okay?)

When nominating contestants, each player is allowed a maximum of three nominations and three secondings.

[Pitchwife]

Tuor, Voronwë should have TWO, I seconded him above. And Lúthien and Caranthir show up double in your tally.

EDIT: Forget about Lúthien, I see you fixed that. And thanks for the Rules - so did my seconding Voronwë not count?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

EDIT: Forget about Lúthien, I see you fixed that. And thanks for the Rules - so did my seconding Voronwë not count?

I don't have the energy to redo all this, so unless there are strong
objections I'd say let the nominations count because...

In the words of MST3000 (if you don't know, just Google it :) )

Repeat to yourself it's just a show,
I should really just relax.

[Rikae]

Second Elu Thingol.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Looking ahead:
Copying Eonwe's Rules for Hurt and Heal Dwarves:
(Oops, rather late for the excellent nominating Rules)
[When nominating contestants, each player is allowed a maximum of three nominations and three secondings].

From 20 to 7 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts are allowed.

From 6 to 4 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts ar not allowed: a player has to hurt 2 different characters and heal one, or he may use only 1 hurt and 1 heal.

When but 3 characters are left each player has either a hurt or a heal.

Wait for at least three posters to vote prior to you voting again. (I believe it was wait for four posters in the past.
Is three okay?)

it looks like these are in:
Aredhel, Miriel, Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril, Beleg, Maglor, Finrod Felagund,
Luthien Tinuviel, Eol, Maeglin, Caranthir, Feanor

That's 13 so far. 7 more to go.

THIRD:

TWO:, Galadriel, Elrond, Finduilas, Celebrimbor,
Ecthelion, Amarie, Eol, Turgon, Voronwë, Elu Thingol

ONE: Gil-galad, Amarië, Fingon, Legolas, Arwen, Curufin, Glorfindel, Haldir, Aegnor




__________________

[Urwen]

I'll third Amarie.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

it looks like these are in:
Aredhel, Miriel, Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril, Beleg, Maglor, Finrod Felagund,
Luthien Tinuviel, Eol, Maeglin, Caranthir, Feanor, Galadriel, Amarië
That's 15 so far. 5 more to go.

THIRD:

TWO: Elrond, Finduilas, Celebrimbor,
Ecthelion, Turgon, Voronwë, Elu Thingol

ONE: Gil-galad, Fingon, Legolas, Arwen, Curufin, Glorfindel, Haldir, Aegnor

[satansaloser2005]

Seconding Legolas. And Arwen I suppose.

[Macalaure]

I'll third Celebrimbor, Ecthelion and Legolas and nominate Fingolfin.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

it looks like these are in:
Aredhel ar-feiniel, Miriel, Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril Celebrindal,
Beleg Strongbow, Maglor, Finrod Felagund, Luthien Tinuviel, Eol,
Maeglin, Caranthir, Feanor, Galadriel, Amarië,
Legolas Greenleaf, Celebrimbor, Ecthelion of the Fountain
That's 18 so far. 2 more to go.

THIRD:

TWO: Elrond, Finduilas, Arwen, Turgon, Voronwë, Elu Thingol

ONE: Gil-galad, Fingon, Curufin, Glorfindel, Haldir, Aegnor, Fingolfin

[Urwen]

Third Finduilas and Elwe.:smokin:

[Eönwë]

I would like to re-nominate Cirdan (since it seems he's been forgotten) and second Gil-Galad

[satansaloser2005]

Whoops. Third Gil-Galad, because I'd seconded him last night and only now realized that the post didn't....erm, post.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

it looks like these are in:
Aredhel ar-feiniel, Miriel, Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril Celebrindal,
Beleg Strongbow, Maglor, Finrod Felagund, Luthien Tinuviel, Eol,
Maeglin, Caranthir, Feanor, Galadriel, Amarië,
Legolas Greenleaf, Celebrimbor, Ecthelion of the Fountain,
Gil-Galad (btw, he was an elven king :) )
That's 19 so far. 1 more to go.

THIRD:

TWO: Elrond, Finduilas, Arwen, Turgon, Voronwë, Elu Thingol, Cirdan

ONE: Fingon, Curufin, Glorfindel, Haldir, Aegnor, Fingolfin

As ofr now, looks like some heavyweights won 't make the final cut. Psst, don't tell Hugo.

[the phantom]

I would third Elrond, but I already voted him. I would second Curufin, but I already voted him as well.

Um... Wait- Fingolfin! He hasn't been approved?! Well then, I second him!

[Tuor in Gondolin]

It looks like these are in:
Aredhel ar-feiniel, Miriel, Maedhros, Nerdanel, Idril Celebrindal,
Beleg Strongbow, Maglor, Finrod Felagund, Luthien Tinuviel, Eol,
Maeglin, Caranthir, Feanor, Galadriel, Amarië,
Legolas Greenleaf, Celebrimbor, Ecthelion of the Fountain,
Gil-Galad (btw, he was an elven king )
That's 19 so far. 1 more to go.


How about a special round, sort of like the NCAA
playoff game between the 64 and 65 seeds in their
basketball tournament?

The first of the TWO NOMINATIONS (see list below) to get three
votes (starting now) gets in. Vote for only one
at a time. if no one gets three votes after three
people vote then you can revote?

TWO NOMINATIONS
Elrond-0
Finduilas-0
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-0
Fingolfin-0

[Urwen]

Elrond-0
Finduilas-1
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-1
Cirdan-0
Fingolfin-0

[satansaloser2005]

Elrond-0
Finduilas-1
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-1
Cirdan-0
Fingolfin-0



Huh? No one's voted yet. And if you're voting, you A: can only vote for one, and B: already put up a vote for Finduilas. I don't get what's going on here. Explain?


Darn it, I already voted for the people I want in. Just gotta sit back and watch, I guess. :p

[Urwen]

Want explanation? I'll give it to you. I voted for her already,yes,but that wasn't counted,so I had to do it again. See?

[satansaloser2005]

Want an explanation? I'll give it to you. I voted for her already, yes, but that wasn't counted, so I had to do it again. See?

Aha! I knew I had to have missed something. That makes more sense. Thanks! :)


So I guess that means our last two elves are Finduilas and Elu Thingol?

[Urwen]

That I can't tell.You'll have to wait for Tuor.:smokin:

[the phantom]

The first two people on the list to receive THREE votes advances, so no, Thingol and Finduilas have not been officially elected.

In addition, the rule is we can only vote for one of these people at a time. To cast another vote we must wait until two other Downers cast a vote. Thus, either Thingol or Finduilas does not currently have a vote (for the sake of the tally I subtracted Thingol's vote).

I will cast my vote for Elrond.

Elrond-1
Finduilas-1
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-0
Fingolfin-0

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Sorry for any confusion. Just vote for one
at a time in this prelim. Thanks.
Think I'll go with Cirdan, since he was active
in Middle-earth since before the Noldor returned
to Beleriand through into the Fourth Age.

Elrond-1
Finduilas-1
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-0

First to get to three votes gets in. (I just thought it would
be a way to give everyone's favorite not yet in na chance).

[satansaloser2005]

Oh, duh. Sorry about that; I thought you meant the next two to get thirded (since all had two) not the first in this list to receive three votes. My mistake. *blushes*

[Nogrod]

I'll go for Finduilas and Fingolfin. But where did Thingol's first vote disappear?

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0 (1?)
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-1

[Tuor in Gondolin]

I'll go for Finduilas and Fingolfin. But where did Thingol's first vote disappear?

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0 (1?)
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-1
__________________

The idea was to have one vote at a time as a sort of playoff to get
the last candidate, for a total of 20. So how about counting your first cited vote
(for Finduilas)? If so, and therefore not counting Thingol's vote, the
total so far would be

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-0
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-0

Again, sorry for the confusion.

[Loslote]

I'll vote for Voronwë, making the total:

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-1
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-0

[the phantom]

And now a vote for Fingolfin-

Elrond-1
Finduilas-2
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-1
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-1

[Urwen]

Ok,let's finish this. I'll vote for Finduilas again.

Elrond-1
Finduilas-3
Arwen-0
Turgon-0
Voronwë-1
Elu Thingol-0
Cirdan-1
Fingolfin-1

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Thanks to all for voting and putting up with errors.

And now for something completely different. Twenty elves enter.
One elf leaves.
Let the kinslaying begin.

RULES

From 20 to 7 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts are allowed.

From 6 to 4 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts ar not allowed: a player has to hurt 2 different characters and heal one, or he may use only 1 hurt and 1 heal.

When but 3 characters are left each player has either a hurt or a heal.

Wait for at least three posters to vote prior to you voting again.

This Hurt and heal is dedicated to elves.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (10)

[the phantom]

Hurt Amarie and Idril, Heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (10)

[Urwen]

Double hurt Maedhros(for me namesake),heal Aredhel
Aredhel ar-feiniel (12)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (8)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (10)

[Mnemosyne]

Hurt Aredhel and Finduilas; heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

[Nerwen]

Hurt Aredhel and Amarië, heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

EDIT:crossed with Mnemo and didn't notice until now.

[the phantom]

Hurt Amarie and Idril, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (8)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

[Mithalwen]

Heal Idril, Double hurt Luthien (for Finrod).

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

[Urwen]

Double hurt Maedhros,heal Idril:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (12)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (10)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (10)

[the phantom]

Merely a voting update, as it's easy to get off count with X-posting...

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Nerdanel Hurt Maglor Heal Amarie

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Amarie, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (9)

[Mnemosyne]

Double Hurt Finduilas; heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (8)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (10)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

[Loslote]

Hurt Luthien; Hurt Maeglin; Heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Help Idril Celebrindal Double Hurt Caranthir

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Amarie, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (13)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

[Urwen]

Double hurt Maedhros,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (7)

[satansaloser2005]

Heal Maedhros, double hurt Finduilas.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (10)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (5)

[autume98]

Heal Fea, double hurt Finduilas.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (9)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)

[Macalaure]

Double-hurt Aredhel, heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)

[Nogrod]

Now what is this crusade against Finduilas? C'mon!

Heal Finduilas, double hurt Amarië (who knows about her and her character anyway?), stayed in Valinor... *phewwt*

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (2)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)

One double hurt to Amarië and you get yourself to the killer list! :rolleyes:

[satansaloser2005]

Kill Amarië. :Merisu:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (deaded)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Beleg

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (11)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Amarië (deaded)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)

Kill Amarië.

[the phantom]

Double hurt Idril, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)

***************

Amarië killed by Sally

[satansaloser2005]

In the rush for the kill, I forgot to add that I was heaingl Maedhros as well. Thus, an updated tally as such.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (10)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (10)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Hurt Eol and Aredhel, heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (4)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

[Nogrod]

Heal Finduilas, double-hurt Beleg (what a fine elf, but how bad in choosing his alignments!)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (5)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

[autume98]

Double hurt Finduilasl, heal Fea

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (10)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Feanor Hurt Maedhros Heal Galadriel
(cross posted, corrected)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (9)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Idril, heal Maedhros.


Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (7)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

[Loslote]

Double-hurt Luthien; heal Maedhros:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (13)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (9)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (5)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (3)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Hurt Finduilas (preparing her for the kill) and Legolas (somebody has to do it), heal Maglor.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (13)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (5)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)
Finduilas (2)


Dead:
Amarië (Sally)

[Mnemosyne]

Kill Finduilas; heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (14)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (5)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Galadriel, heal Feanor.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (14)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (5)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)

[Loslote]

Double hurt Luthien; heal Beleg:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (14)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Luthien Tinuviel (3)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)

[autume98]

Double hurt Galadriel; heal Finrod Felagund:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (14)
Nerdanel (11)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Luthien Tinuviel (3)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Luthien Tinuviel (3)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (8)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)

[Macalaure]

Hurt Lúthien and Aredhel, heal Caranthir

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Luthien Tinuviel (2)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (9)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)

[satansaloser2005]

Thank you, Mac, dear. :)


Kill Luthien. Heal Serinde. *winks at Duck* (Pet Virae? Heh.)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Miriel (11)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Luthien Tinuviel (2)
Eol (9)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (9)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Do I get points for assists? :smokin:

[satansaloser2005]

Do I get points for assists? :smokin:

Obviously! :D

[Loslote]

Aww. I wanted to kill Luthien. :p

Anywho, Hurt Miriel; Hurt Eol; Heal Aredhel:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (8)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (9)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[Nerwen]

Hurt Eol and Idril; heal Maglor:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (7)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (9)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[the phantom]

Heal Caranthir, Double Hurt Idril

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (7)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[Urwen]

Heal Idril,double hurt Eol

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (5)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Double hurt Aredhel, heal Idril

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (5)
Maeglin (9)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[Mithalwen]

Double hurt Maeglin , heal Idril

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (5)
Maeglin (7)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[Urwen]

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Double hurt Eol,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (3)
Maeglin (7)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Aredhel, heal Serinde.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Miriel (11)
Maedhros (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (3)
Maeglin (7)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (7)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

EDIT: x'd with Urwen. *blinks, is confused* Ah, got it. Tally (and my move) updated accordingly.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt MaedhrosHurt Maeglin Heal Galadriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Miriel (11)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (3)
Maeglin (6)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Hurt Eol and Aredhel, heal Maeglin

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Miriel (11)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (2)
Maeglin (7)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[Urwen]

Kill Eol,and heal his wife:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Miriel (11)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Eol (0)
Maeglin (7)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Correcting the list, then hurting Aredhel and Idril and healing Serinde.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Miriel (12)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Maeglin (7)
Caranthir (10)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Mithalwen]

Hurt Caranthir (for Tathren) Hurt Miriel Heal Idril.


Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Miriel (11)
Maedhros (11)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Maeglin (7)
Caranthir (9)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Aredhel Hurt Maeglin Hurt Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Miriel (11)
Maedhros (10)
Nerdanel (12)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Maeglin (6)
Caranthir (9)
Feanor (12)
Galadriel (8)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Gil-Galad (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
__________________

[Thinlómien]

Heal Galadriel (hey come on!), hurt Gil-galad, hurt Míriel

Feanor (12)
Nerdanel (12)
Maglor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Miriel (10)
Maedhros (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Gil-Galad (9)
Galadriel (9)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Caranthir (9)
Idril Celebrindal (7)
Maeglin (6)
Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

(Reordered the list according to the amount of points, hope that's ok...)

PS. Tuor you seem to hate my favourite character! If I was around longer, this would be an open war! :p Now I just have to trust others not to let him down...

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Thinlomien:
PS. Tuor you seem to hate my favourite character! If I was around longer, this would be an open war! Now I just have to trust others not to let him down...

No, if I did he'd get double hurts, like a few people do who like
to strategize their favorites :p (not you, I think).

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Orinally posted by Thinlomien:
PS. Tuor you seem to hate my favourite character! If I was around longer, this would be an open war! Now I just have to trust others not to let him down...

No, if I did he'd get double hurts, like a few people do who like
to strategize their favorites :p (not you, I think).

[the phantom]

Heal Maedhros, Double hurt Idril

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (9)
Gil-Galad (9)
Idril Celebrindal (5)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Urwen]

And you hate mine. She has lowest score on the list...:(

Well,not anymore!

Double hurt guess who,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (10)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (9)
Gil-Galad (9)
Idril Celebrindal (5)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)
Maedhros (9)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

[Lalaith]

Killing all the girls again, eh?

Double hurt Ecthelion, heal Idril.

[autume98]

Hurt Aredhel hurt Galadriel; heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (8)
Gil-Galad (9)
Idril Celebrindal (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (9)we
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

[Macalaure]

Heal Maedhros, hurt Aredhel and Legolas

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (8)
Gil-Galad (9)
Idril Celebrindal (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

[the phantom]

Double hurt Idril, heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (8)
Gil-Galad (9)
Idril Celebrindal (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Thinlómien]

Since all you cuties are taking care of Maedhros, I can concentrate on Galadriel and Finrod seems pretty good still... (my three definite favourites <3 and no, you can't really turn this against me 'cos I won't be around to play much anyway... :p)

Heal Galadriel
double-hurt Gil-galad. He's so boring!

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (9)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

[the phantom]

Killing all the girls again, eh?
Only the girl (Idril) who I discovered was elected illegally upon looking back at the nomination process (she was given two votes from one person).

I'm fine with a victory by one of the other ladies- Aredhel, Miriel, or Nerdanel.

[Urwen]

Well the,you wouldn't mind this:

Double hurt Maglor,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (9)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (9)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

[Pitchwife]

Hey now, I don't check the Downs for 2 days, and what do I come back to? Misogynist slaughter. What's the matter with you folks? :rolleyes:

Double-hurt Caranthir (the faceless one among the Feanorians)
Heal Galadriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (7)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

Dead:
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Idril Celebrindal Hurt Maedhros Hurt Feanor

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (7)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (5)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

Dead:
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[the phantom]

Heal Maedhros, Double Hurt Idril

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (7)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (3)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Nogrod]

Killing all the girls again, eh?That seems to be the only guiding line people seem to follow anyway. Shame on you! ;)

Heal Idril, double-hurt Gil-Galad.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (7)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (5)
Idril Celebrindal (4)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarië (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eöl (Urwen)

[Urwen]

Double hurt Caranthir,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (5)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (3)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maehdros Heal Aredhel
(Hmm. Seems to be a bit of an anti-female bias here.)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (5)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (3)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[the phantom]

Heal Maedhros, Double Hurt Idril

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (5)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (5)
Idril Celebrindal (2)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Pitchwife]

(Hmm. Seems to be a bit of an anti-female bias here.)
Indeed. Not at all gentleman-like.
Unfortunately, Aredhel isn't exactly my favourite she-elf either, and Idril looks like she's beyond saving.

Double-hurt Caranthir, heal Maglor

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (3)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (2)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)

[Macalaure]

Double-hurt and kill Idril, heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (3)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (0)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (3)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (7)
Idril Celebrindal (0)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (9)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)

[the phantom]

Heal Maedhros, Hurt Gil & Finrod

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (3)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)

[Urwen]

Double hurt Caranthir,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (1)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (8)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (6)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)

[Nogrod]

Oh Mac, what did you do? No-one's ever beyond saving... :)

Hurt Gil-Galad and Echtelion, heal Caranthir

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (4)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (5)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)

[the phantom]

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (2)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (5)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)

[Urwen]

Oh,well you're wrong!

Time to go down to zero and up to ten!

Double hurt Caranthir,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (0)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (5)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)

There.Maedhros is next.

[Macalaure]

Oh Mac, what did you do?Satisfied my thirst for blood. :D


Heal Maedhros, double-hurt Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (5)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Urwen)


Urwen, I think there have to be three or four turns before you can take a turn again. Only Nogrod took a turn between your two.

[Thinlómien]

Heal Maedhros, double-hurt Gil-galad...

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (3)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Urwen)

[satansaloser2005]

So since Urwen's move was out of turn (it happens to us all in the heat of the moment, so no worries) the tallies should read like this.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Caranthir (2)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (3)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)


I don't feel right taking the kill myself (dang principles) but I'll be making a move in a bit.

[autume98]

Hmm...i think i should get my first kill...double hurt Caranthir; heal Fea

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (3)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)

[satansaloser2005]

Heal Feanor, hurt Aredhel and Legolas.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (13)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (10)
Gil-Galad (3)
Legolas Greenleaf (7)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Galadriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (13)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Gil-Galad (3)
Legolas Greenleaf (7)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)

[Nogrod]

You guys killed Caranthir? Really? Would you love Legolas as Orlando Bloom rather than the Tolkien version? :mad: :D

Okay. I'll give you the easy one...

Double hurt Gil-Galad (what is he, a soul-less boasting do-gooder)? Heal Maeglin.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (13)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Gil-Galad (1)
Legolas Greenleaf (7)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)

[autume98]

Thanks for the easy one Nog. Hurt Gil-Galad hurt Aredhel Heal Legolas

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (13)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)

[Macalaure]

Hurt Aredhel and Feanor, heal Maglor

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (8)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)

[Rikae]

Double hurt Legolas, heal Aredhel.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (7)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (6)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)

EDIT: Ooops, list wasn't up to date.

[satansaloser2005]

Sweetheart, your list....what the what?

[Pitchwife]

You guys killed Caranthir? Really? Would you love Legolas as Orlando Bloom rather than the Tolkien version?
Can't see what one has to do with the other.

Hurt Ecthelion (OK, a Balrog-slayer, but another faceless one)
Hurt Nerdanel (seriously, how does she deserve to lead the tally?)
Heal Finrod

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (6)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (6)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)

EDIT: Oops, copied Rikae's earlier outdated list. Corrected now, I hope.

[Rikae]

Pitch, your list is out of date, too...

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Nerdanel (Pitch has a point) and heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (6)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (6)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)

[Pitchwife]

Pitch, your list is out of date, too...
Yeah, sorry. I hope I've got it right now.
And sally's copied my EDIT-comment:p. We all should take a little more time with this (or go to bed, in my case).

[satansaloser2005]

Yeah, sorry. I hope I've got it right now.
And sally's copied my EDIT-comment:p. We all should take a little more time with this (or go to bed, in my case).

Shhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. :p



I don't know why I keep removing the beginnings of the quote tags but forgetting to take off the end. *headdesks*

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (6)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (6)
Maedhros (9)
Maeglin (6)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)

[Nogrod]

Pitch: the two had nothing in common but the frustration of certain popular characters being immune to negative votes while the "usual suspects" seemed to gather the votes - with the females to go as dispendables...

Anyway, double-hurt Echtelion (what is the interest in him anyway?), heal Maeglin.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (4)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (6)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)

[autume98]

double-hurt Echtelion heal Maglor.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Ecthelion of the Fountain (2)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (6)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)

[satansaloser2005]

Deaded. Heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (6)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Hurt Aredhel and Legolas, heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (5)
Maedhros (12)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

We've had a miscount. Tally is as such.


Deaded. Heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Legolas Greenleaf (5)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)




Is that correct?

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Heal Galadriel Hurt Maglor Hurt Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (12)
Legolas Greenleaf (5)
Maedhros (9)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Legolas, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (10)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (12)
Legolas Greenleaf (3)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)

[Loslote]

Caranthir? Really? Sure, he was a bit...odd, but...:(

Hurt Legolas; Hurt Celebrimbor; Heal Nerdanel.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (4)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (9)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (12)
Legolas Greenleaf (2)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)

[Urwen]

Time for kill...
and heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (9)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (12)
Legolas Greenleaf (0)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

[Mithalwen]

How could you kill lovely, wise Idril and save the drippy Miriel and Nerdanel who is a total nonentity. Baffling... I will avenge!

Double hurt Nerdanel, Heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (9)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (12)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas without the tautologous Greenleaf :rolleyes: (Urwen)

[Lalaith]

Heal Aredhel double hurt Celebrimbor
Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (12)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas without the tautologous Greenleaf (Urwen)
Today 09:09 AM

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Galadriel, heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas without the tautologous Greenleaf (Urwen)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Miriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (12)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (10)
Maedhros (9)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas without the tautologous Greenleaf (Urwen)

[Thinlómien]

Heal Galadriel (speaking of trying to kill truly heroical and cool females...), hurt Nerdanel, hurt Fëanor...

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (9)
Maeglin (7)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas without the tautologous Greenleaf (Urwen)

edit: xed with Tuor and edited accordingly... grrr.

[Urwen]

Sorry for this,Ar,but I will make it to you later.

Double hurt Maeglin,heal YOU!

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (9)
Maeglin (5)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas without the tautologous Greenleaf (Urwen)

[autume98]

Double hurt Maeglin; heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (10)
Maeglin (3)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas Greenleaf (Urwen)

[the phantom]

Hurt Maeglin, Hurt Finrod, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (11)
Maeglin (2)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas Greenleaf (Urwen)

[satansaloser2005]

Maeglin is dead. Heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)




Kill count:
Four: Sally
Two: Tum, Urwen
One: Mnemo, Mac

[Macalaure]

Double-hurt Aredhel, heal Maglor

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (12)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)


Kill count:
Four: Sally
Two: Tum, Urwen
One: Mnemo, Mac

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)


Kill count:
Four: Sally
Two: Tum, Urwen
One: Mnemo, Mac

[Urwen]

Double hurt Celebrimbor,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (5)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (13)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)


Kill count:
Four: Sally
Two: Tum, Urwen
One: Mnemo, Mac

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Nerdanel, heal Maedhros (naturally).

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (10)
Celebrimbor (5)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)


Kill count:
Four: Sally
Two: Tum, Urwen
One: Mnemo, Mac

[autume98]

Hurt Miriel Hurt Celebrimbor, heal Beleg Strongbow

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Celebrimbor (4)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (11)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)


Kill count:
Four: Sally
Two: Tum, Urwen
One: Mnemo, Mac

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Galadriel, Heal Celebrimbor

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Beleg Strongbow (11)
Celebrimbor (5)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (9)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)

[Nogrod]

And then you killed Maeglin... oh you goody-goody-lovers... :rolleyes:

Okay, let's bring in new suspects.

Double hurt Beleg (nice guy but so bad in picking loyalities), heal Aredhel...

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Celebrimbor (5)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (9)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Galadriel. Heal Serinde.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Celebrimbor (5)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Galadriel (7)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)

[autume98]

Double hurt Galadriel. Heal Finrod Felagund.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Celebrimbor (5)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)

[the phantom]

Double Hurt Galadriel, Heal Celebrimbor

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Celebrimbor (6)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (3)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)

[Urwen]

Double hurt Celebrimbor,heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Celebrimbor (4)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (3)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)

[Thinlómien]

Heal Galadriel
- come on, what's the problem with you! Possibly about the coolest Elf woman there was, not any witless babe lacking will of her own, nor a childish rebel.

Double hurt Celebrimbor
- I'm sorry but I've got to give somebody to the blood hounds...

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Celebrimbor (2)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (4)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Death. Heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (4)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Pitchwife]

Next thing you'll probably hang his corpse on a pole and bear him galumphing across Nebraska...

Double-hurt Nerdanel
heal Galadriel
(how you folks can prefer a womb on legs to the Lady of Lórien is utterly beyond me)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[the phantom]

Nerdanel wasn't just a "womb on legs", Pitch! She was an amazing artisan and said to be quite wise, and was one of the few people who could ever calm down Feanor at any point.

Double Galadriel, Heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (8)
Beleg Strongbow (9)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (3)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Urwen]

Could we make a comeback,Ar? YES!

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Beleg Strongbow (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[the phantom]

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Beleg Strongbow (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (3)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Thinlómien]

Heal Galadriel, double hurt womb on legs :p
I like her hair colour and if she indeed was an artisan herself (I don't remember) that's cool, but if a woman's main merit is giving birth to seven sons and being able to handle her husband, that's not my idol type of woman...

Although, Míriel is even worse, a whiny lady who gave birth to the greatest jerk in Arda and decided to do nothing else in her life. :p

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Beleg Strongbow (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (4)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (8)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Beleg Strongbow (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (4)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (8)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Pitchwife]

Nerdanel wasn't just a "womb on legs", Pitch! She was an amazing artisan and said to be quite wise, and was one of the few people who could ever calm down Feanor at any point.
Maybe (although I don't know where you get the artisan bit from), but we don't see that her famous influence on Feanor ever had much effect.
Whereas Galadriel, a match for both the loremasters and athletes of the Eldar in her youth, who had great Feanaro himself smitten with her beauty but didn't act like a groupie around him, while on the other hand being one of the few Elves who ever were unselfishly friendly with Dwarves, etc. etc., is what in your book?

Double-hurt Nerdanel, heal Galadriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (10)
Beleg Strongbow (7)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Urwen]

Now,who threatens Ar most?

Ah,yes,he makes her look like no good...

Then,he has to go!

Aredhel ar-feiniel (11)
Beleg Strongbow (7)
Feanor (9)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Urwen, could you please put who you're hurting/healing in your post? Not a big deal, but it makes it a lot easier when silly people like me are too lazy to check the list to see who you dealt with. Thanks!


Anyway, to business. Double hurt Aredhel, heal Feanor.

I'll be back for Galadriel later. ;)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Beleg Strongbow (7)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Thinlómien]

Heal Galadriel, hurt Nerdanel and Beleg

Aredhel ar-feiniel (9)
Beleg Strongbow (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (6)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (5)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Pitchwife]

Double-hurt Aredhel for a change
Heal Nerwen Artanis aka Galadriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (7)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (5)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[the phantom]

although I don't know where you get the artisan bit from
Tolkien, of course! :p

Nerdanel's daddy was quite a craftsman and she inherited his skills, though she used them in a different manner. If I'm remembering correctly she was the one who was amazing at carving.

D-Hurt Galadriel, Heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (7)
Beleg Strongbow (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Aredhel. Heal Maedhros.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (11)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedros Heal Miriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (12)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
__________________

[the phantom]

Also Nerdanel was the only red-headed female in Middle-Earth. That ought to count for something too. :D

[Thinlómien]

Heal Galadriel, double hurt Beleg (I used to like him but nowadays I just can't understand him given what a jerk Túrin was)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (4)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (6)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (12)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[the phantom]

D-hurt Galadriel, heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (4)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (4)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (12)
Nerdanel (7)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[Pitchwife]

Also Nerdanel was the only red-headed female in Middle-Earth. That ought to count for something too.
I'll grant you that one!:D
And I'll take your word as to her carving skills, I'm just curious about the source (I know about her dad, of course, but I couldn't find anything about her own artistic activities).

Nevertheless,

Double-hurt Nerdanel, heal Galadriel
(thanks for the help, Lommy - even though I disagree about Túrin!)

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (4)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (11)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (12)
Nerdanel (5)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[autume98]

Double-hurt Beleg, heal Finrod

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Beleg Strongbow (2)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (12)
Nerdanel (5)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Beleg's dead. Also, heal Nerdanel.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (12)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)

[the phantom]

D-hurt Galadriel, heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Galadriel (3)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (12)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)

[Thinlómien]

Heal Galadriel, double-hurt Miriel

What's her main merit? Dying?


Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Galadriel (4)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)

[Pitchwife]

Double hurt Nerdanel, heal Galadriel

And bedtime for me. Á vala Manwë!

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Galadriel (7)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (4)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)[/QUOTE]

[autume98]

Double Hurt Galadriel; Heal Nerdanel

And bedtime for me. Á vala Manwë!

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (11)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Galadriel (5)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (4)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)

[the phantom]

D-Hurt Galadriel, Heal Maedhros

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Galadriel (1)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (5)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Galadriel's dead. I'm gonna try to properly fix the tally.

ETA: Never mind, sir Phantom did it for me. Also, putting the hurt on Aredhel and healing Nerdanel.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (10)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Thinlómien]

Jerks. Sally, when you fix it, could you add double-hurt Míriel heal Maedhros there for me? Good night people! :)

ps. Phantom you were supposed to have dinner. :mad:

[satansaloser2005]

Heh heh heh. I think Tum misquoted a bit. But that's rather funny anyway. :)


ETA: x'd with Lommiekins. ^_^

[satansaloser2005]

Per Lommie: Double hurt Miriel, heal Maedhros.


Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (8)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[the phantom]

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (8)
Nerdanel (6)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

EDIT: ha ha! x-post

[Loslote]

Hurt Miriel; Hurt Miriel again; Heal Nerdanel:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (12)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (7)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[the phantom]

D-hurt Finrod, Heal Aredhel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (10)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (7)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[autume98]

Double hurt Finrod, Heal Miriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (8)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (7)
Nerdanel (7)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Finrod, heal the ginger (Nerdanel).

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (6)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (7)
Nerdanel (8)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Loslote]

Double hurt Miriel; heal Finrod.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (7)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (8)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[the phantom]

D-hurt Finrod, heal Miriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (5)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (8)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Double Hurt Maedhros Heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (5)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Nogrod]

With Lommy's beautiful description of her... I'll double-hurt Miriel... and heal, well, the faithful...

Aredhel ar-feiniel (6)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (6)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Loslote]

Yay, Nog! :D

Hurt Miriel; Hurt Aredhel; Heal Finrod.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (7)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (3)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Finrod, heal Serinde. Poor dear.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (5)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[the phantom]

D-hurt Finrod, Heal Miriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (3)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (11)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Nogrod]

Hey!

Heal Felagund, hurt Maglor and Maedhros (good guys but too many points right now to make it unintresting).

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (4)
Maedhros (8)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)[/QUOTE]

[Loslote]

Double-hurt Miriel; Heal Finrod *insert much grumbling*:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (5)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (5)
Maedhros (8)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (3)
Nerdanel (9)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Double-hurt Aredhel, heal Nerdanel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (3)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (5)
Maedhros (8)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (3)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[the phantom]

D-hurt Finrod, Heal Miriel

Aredhel ar-feiniel (3)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (3)
Maedhros (8)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Double hurt Finrod (:eek::D) and heal Serinde.

Aredhel ar-feiniel (3)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (1)
Maedhros (8)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Loslote]

Hurt Aredhel; Hurt Miriel; Heal Finrod:

Aredhel ar-feiniel (2)
Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (2)
Maedhros (8)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Kill Aredhel, heal Maedhros

Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (2)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (10)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)

[the phantom]

Hurt Finrod, Hurt Maglor, Heal Miriel

Feanor (10)
Finrod Felagund (1)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)

[satansaloser2005]

Finrod's dead. Heal Serinde.

ETA: Oh yeah, I can hurt another person. Taking one from Feanor.

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[the phantom]

Woo hoo!!! It's all in the family now! :D

[Loslote]

Bother. :mad:

Hurt Miriel. Heal Maedhros.

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally :mad:)

EDIT: xed with le Nebraskans; fixed total.

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Hurt Maedhros Heal Nerdanel

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (5)
Nirdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally )

[Thinlómien]

Feel like saying "jerks" again. :D

Heal Maedhros, hurt Míriel.

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (9)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally )

[satansaloser2005]

*snuggles Lommie*

Hurt Maglor, heal Serinde.

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (8)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[the phantom]

Hmmm... Now what do I do? I like everyone left. Well then....

Hurt Maglor, Hurt Nerdanel, Heal Miriel

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Reminder: only one Hurt each now.

Hurt Maedhros Heal Nerdanel

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Urwen]

Heal Miriel (not popular like her later namesake to me,but still a namesake...)
And hurt Maedhros (in spite of person who killed Ar)

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (7)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (7)
Nerdanel (11)

[the phantom]

Reminder: only one Hurt each now.
So are we not going by the rules you posted, because they say from 6 to 4 players you are still allowed two hurts and a heal, so long as the hurts are given to different characters (no double-hurts). Or by "each", is that actually what you meant- that one is only allowed one hurt for each character, rather than one hurt for each Barrow-Downer.

And speaking of double hurts no longer being allowed, here's an amended tally...

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (8)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (7)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Loslote]

Hurt Miriel; Heal Maedhros:

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Thinlómien]

Hurt Miriel and heal Maedhros - and hurt Fëanor too if that's allowed.

Feanor (9/8)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Tuor in Gondolin]

Reminder: only one Hurt each now.
The Phantom:
So are we not going by the rules you posted, because they say from 6 to 4 players you are still allowed two hurts and a heal, so long as the hurts are given to different characters (no double-hurts). Or by "each", is that actually what you meant- that one is only allowed one hurt for each character, rather than one hurt for each Barrow-Downer.


You are quite correct. I was thinking of, I believe, some past rules leading to present vague word formulation. The error is clearly mine. :o

[Urwen]

Hurt Maedhros,heal Miriel...

*sighs* things are dull without Ar around...:(

Feanor (9)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Thinlómien]

Corrected count (since my Feanor hurt was allowed)

Feanor (8)
Maedhros (9)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)

[satansaloser2005]

Hurt Maglor and Feanor. Heal Maedhros.

Feanor (7)
Maedhros (10)
Maglor (6)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Loslote]

Hurt Miriel; Heal Maedhros:

Feanor (7)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (6)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Hurt Feanor and Miriel, heal Maglor

Feanor (6)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (7)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[the phantom]

Hurt Maglor and Nerdanel, Heal Miriel

Feanor (6)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (6)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Hurt Maglor and Feanor, heal Serinde.

Feanor (5)
Maedhros (11)
Maglor (5)
Miriel (6)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Loslote]

Hurt Miriel; Hurt Maglor; Heal Maedhros:

Feanor (5)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (4)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Macalaure]

Hurt Feanor and Miriel, heal Nerdanel

Feanor (4)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (4)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (11)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[Nogrod]

I don't believe I'm doing this, but whatever... but looking at the persons I like all and the difference in the votes...

Heal Fëanor, hurt Nerdanel.

Feanor (5)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (4)
Miriel (4)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)

[satansaloser2005]

Hurt Maglor and Feanor, heal Serinde. (I'll make her last as long as I can, darn it, even if she does have to die eventally.)


Feanor (4)
Maedhros (12)
Maglor (3)
Miriel (5)
Nerdanel (10)

The Dead
Amarie (Sally)
Finduilas (Mnemosyne)
Luthien (Sally)
Eol (Urwen)
Idril (Mac)
Caranthir (Tum)
Gil-Galad (Tum)
Ecthelion (Sally)
Legolas (Urwen)
Maeglin (Sally)
Celebrimbor (Sally)
Beleg Strongbow (Sally)
Galadriel (Sally)
Aredhel (Mac)
Finrod (Sally)