Well, you guessed right Amanduial. It was indeed Envinyatar. I yield the thread to you.

*bump*

Amanduial?

Well I'll just take it over then.

If we were in a different world I would be attacking Hookbill the Goomba

Maybe Me?....or Sleepy?

Nope sorry it's neither

TORE?

No sorry it's not TORE, however I will add a hint the different world is a 2D world.

Morai
 

it's an anagram of Mario.

Correct and your thread.

and the question is

you may think I'm a star, but I'm only a well-known goof

Gil-Galad?

thanks Saucey...


hmm...Boromir88?

the man with the pan
 

Yes, the name means "starlight". goof is a clear clue.

Next one
 

Fordim?

Hmm I think it is more cryptic and am thinking about pulpits and altars ......

alatar?

Lmp?

you be thinking correct, Mistress Mithalwen.

And Mistress Bracegirdle has it!

platform for those of religious persuasion = altar
an article = a

Place the article within the platform and you get alatar.

Pray continue, Mistress Bracegirdle. :)

Thanks Mithalwen. Your musings rung a bell.

Alright then....

Another name for a hobbit with horse sense.

I'm going to take a stab at burrahobbit. Yet I think it's much more cryptic than that.

Nice guess Glirdan, but not who I had in mind.

Merry Brandybuck

He's a hobbit that had ridden a horse (if I remember correctly) plus the whole knight of Rohan bit.

No, it is not Mister Brandybuck, though you are right to consider the small equestrian element. Take note that it is another name for certain hobbit.

Mister Underhill

Frodo's nom de voyage and his PT is DRead Horseman.

We have a winner! Very good Mithalwen. Mister Underhill was also Frodo's alias while at the Prancing Pony, but I like your connection much, much better!

Your turn on the pitcher's mound!

Why thank you .... try this:

Does he give a tinker's cuss?

Argh, all I can think of is The Saucepan Man. Though I'm not too fond of the image of him cacophonously cussing that springs to mind! ;)

It is indeed the Saucepan Man... and the answer to the question may well be no. :D Sorry for the delay in replying.. I was otherwise engaged yesterday playing the Fairy Godmother :D

Fairy Godmother? Not Middle-earth Mafia I trust! :p

Alright then, back to business.

This Downer might be mistaken for a midnight snack!

Morsul, maybe? I seem to recall him being associated with chocolate chip cookies.

Absolutely correct, Alcarillo. Morsul in the Dark it is. Your up!

*bump*

Morsul?

Its Alcarillo's turn actually...

Pedant ;) My mistake.

Well, bringing this thread into the new year then...

Chemistry + The Downs = ?

;)

Hookbill the Goomba?

Abercrombie of Rohan for her Downer Periodic Table?

Passing the thread to the man with the pan.

Ta very much. :)

The signature of a royal artist?