Is it within the confines of Arda?

Is it within the confines of Arda? Uh-huh

Is it east of Tol Eressëa?

Is it east of Tol Eressëa? No

Good grief, Nilp, you're determined to cause me headaches all over the forum, aren't you? Here, werewolf... ;) You're probably getting ready to post something really strange yet thought-provoking in the Books forum, aren't you? Just to confuse me more. ;) :D

I'm probably going to kick myself when I find/hear the answer.

Have living Elves ever been there?

Have living Elves ever been there? No

Firefoot, just remember your Arda geography, and you'll get the answer. ;)

Is it in the Sil?

I don't think I'll be confusing you in Werewolves anymore . . . ;)

Bloody wolves. :(

Endewaith:
Is it in the Sil? Yes

Oh, and I just have to make these changes (after I refreshed myself in the geography of Arda):

Is it west of the Misty Mountains? Yes/No
Is it east of Tol Eressëa? Yes/No

Is it Ekkaia?

Have any Ainur ever been there?

Mettare got it.
 

I am looking for Ekkaia, the Encircling Seas.

Your turn, Mettare :)

:D Yay! :D

OK, I'm thinking of something. :)

I thought Ekkaia was the same thing as the Great Sea. :rolleyes: I could have sworn I looked it up, too.

Nice one, Mettare.

Third Age?

Tangible?

Living?

Third Age? No
Tangible? Yes
Living? Yes

:)

Elf?

Elf? Yes


Third Age? No
Tangible? Yes
Living? Yes

:)

Noldo?

Noldo? Yes, I think...


Third Age? No
Tangible? Yes
Living? Yes
Elf? Yes

:)

First Age?

First Age? Yes


Third Age? No
Tangible? Yes
Living? Yes
Elf? Yes
Noldo? Yes, I think...

:)

Second Age?

First Age?

Is his/her primary home in Middle-earth east of the Anduin?

Second Age? No
First Age? Yes, as I already said ;)
Is his/her primary home in Middle-earth east of the Anduin? No


Third Age? No
Tangible? Yes
Living? Yes
Elf? Yes
Noldo? Yes, I think...
First Age? Yes

:)

Male?

Male? Yes


Third Age? No
Tangible? Yes
Living? Yes
Elf? Yes
Noldo? Yes, I think...
First Age? Yes
Second Age? No
Is his/her primary home in Middle-earth east of the Anduin? No

:)

Killed in one of the Battles of Beleriand?

Killed in one of the Battles of Beleriand? No


Elf? Yes
Noldo? Yes, I think...
First Age? Yes
Second Age? No
Third Age? No
Is his/her primary home in Middle-earth east of the Anduin? No
Male? Yes

:)

Did he die before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?

Did he die before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad? No


Elf? Yes
Noldo? Yes, I think...
First Age? Yes
Second Age? No
Third Age? No
Is his/her primary home in Middle-earth east of the Anduin? No
Male? Yes
Killed in one of the Battles of Beleriand? No

:)

Did he die in combat?

Was he part of the lordship of one of the Hidden Realms?

Born in Middle-earth?

Did he die in combat? Yes
Was he part of the lordship of one of the Hidden Realms? If you mean whether he was a ruler of a Hidden Realm, then no, if you mean whether he lived in one of the Hidden Realms, then yes.
Born in Middle-earth? I really don't know, sorry

Elf? Yes
Noldo? Yes, I think...
First Age? Yes
Second Age? No
Third Age? No
Is his/her primary home in Middle-earth east of the Anduin? No
Male? Yes
Killed in one of the Battles of Beleriand? No
Did he die before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad? No

:)

EDIT: I'm going away for about 10 days so you'll either have to wait till I come back or... I don't know... :confused:

Did he live in Gondolin?

i meant, was he of great favour in any of the Hidden realms, such as Gwindor was a lord in Nargothrond, or Glorfindel in Gondolin

Was he related to Feanor?

Did he live in Nargothrond?