Noldo?

Male?

Maglor?

Born in Valinor?

Noldo? Yes
Male? Yes
Maglor? No
Born in Valinor? Unknown

Ever a king?

Did he live in Nargothrond?

Enerdhil?

Did he come from the house of Finwë?

Ever a king? Not really
Did he live in Nargothrond? No
Enerdhil? No
Did he come from the house of Finwë? No

Aranwë?

Does he have a name?

Any mortal blood?

Edit: What was I thinking? Of course not if he might've been born in Valinor! Kindly disregard my nonsense.

Instead. . .

Married a member of the House of Finwe?

Lived in a hidden kingdom?

Did he fight in the fourth and/or fifth battles of Beleriand?

Aranwë? No
Does he have a name? Yes
Married a member of the House of Finwe? No
Lived in a hidden kingdom? Yes
Did he fight in the fourth and/or fifth battles of Beleriand? No, not that I know of at least.

Did he live in Gondolin?

Voronwë?

Did he know Tuor?

Ecthelion?

Did he live in Gondolin? No
Voronwë? No
Did he know Tuor? No
Ecthelion? No

Did he know Turin?

Did he ever meet any of the Valar?

Hmmm . . .
 

. . . a hidden kingdom, but not Gondolin or Nargothrond . . .

Doriath? A Noldo in Doriath?

*ponder ponder*

Is he in HoME?

Ufedhin?

My dear Nilp, you're too clever for your own good. Yes, it is indeed Ufedhin, the traitor that brought Doriath's destruction. The thread is thine.

HoME... No wonder I wasn't getting anywhere.
 

Third Age?

A person?

An object?

If so, would it hurt a lot if I dropped it on your head?

First Age?

Place?

Oooh! Oooh!
 

I got the thread! And they pre-empt me! :D

Hmmm . . .

Third Age? No, not in ME, enedwaith.
A person? Yes
An object? No
If so, would it hurt a lot if I dropped it on your head? Could you hit me with . . . it? :p
First Age? Yes
Place? No

Elf?

Man?

Born in Middle-earth?

Olvar?

Elf? Yes
Man? No
Born in Middle-earth? Yes
Olvar? No

Noldo

Woodelf?

Lived in Gondolin??

Noldo No
Woodelf? No
Lived in Gondolin?? Yes

Noldo/woodelf combo?

Died in Gondolin?

Noldo/woodelf combo? No
Died in Gondolin? Unknown

Is it Voronwe?