Was it used by Merry?

Is it in the Hobbit?

In FR?

The obligatory question:
 

If I dropped it on Nilpaurion Felagund's head, would it hurt a whole lot?

Was it used by Gimli?

Was it used by Merry? No
Is it in the Hobbit? No
In FR? No
If I dropped it on Nilpaurion Felagund's head, would it hurt a whole lot? Yes
Was it used by Gimli? No

Was it used by pippin?

Was it used by pippin? No (See post 4200 ;) )

Used by Sam?

As for the pippin thing, short attention span strikes again!

Used by Aragorn?

Used by Sam? No
Used by Aragorn? No

Was it used by Frodo?

In TTT?

Used by Legolas?

Frodo?


I'm getting really confused.

Just to recap, it was used by a member of the fellowship who was a hobbit, right?

Was it used by Frodo? Yes (to reiterate: more or less)
In TTT? No
Used by Legolas? No
Just to recap, it was used by a member of the fellowship who was a hobbit, right? Yes (see above)

Was it made in Mordor?

Was it ever in the Shire?

Was it made in Mordor? No
Was it ever in the Shire? Yes

Is it moveable by one person?

Was this thing never mentioned before the hobbits returned to the Shire?

If you light it, will it burn?



Sorry, but that whole 'if you prick us, do we not bleed' line is stuck in my head

Is it moveable by one person? No
Was this thing never mentioned before the hobbits returned to the Shire? Yes (It wasn't before mentioned)
If you light it, will it burn? No

Wow
 

Was it something that Frodo inherited from Bilbo? That is: Something he got when he inherited Bag End or got from Bilbo in Rivendell?


............................

And of topic: WOW this must by far be the longest thread in the history of the Barrow Downs... 106 pages. :eek:
It's amazing what you've done!!! Im honored :smokin:

Was it something that Frodo inherited from Bilbo? That is: Something he got when he inherited Bag End or got from Bilbo in Rivendell? No

is it something that Frodo brought home from his journey?

is it something that Frodo brought home from his journey? No

Was it with Frodo when he sailed away?

Is it a building (or Hobbit hole)?

Was it with Frodo when he sailed away? No
Is it a building (or Hobbit hole)? No

Part of a building?

Part of a building? No

Is it made of stone?

Is it made of stone? No

Wood?

Metal?

Is it made of mithril?

Wood? No
Metal? Yes
Is it made of mithril? No

is it a tool or a piece of equipment?

is it a tool or a piece of equipment? No