:eek: Well...person = living, place = place, event =event, item = object. Am I wrong on any of these? If it isn't one of those, I'm going to guess ...

Concept?

Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival?

Object? No
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Can it move? No
A place? Nope
Event? No

Concept? No
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No

(Hi there, Telch. Good to see you back. :) )

Good Eru, what can it be? Material element is out, concept is out, it is not a where, when, why, whom, so is it how? Do I make no sense? Yes, the latter seems more likely.

Thanks SPM :)

Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person?

I'm not out of ideas yet.
 

Something intangible (song, language, etc.)?

Object? No
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Can it move? No
A place? Nope
Event? No
Concept? No
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No

is it how? Non
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.

Well then, is it a language?

Is it a song?

Object? No
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Can it move? No
A place? Nope
Event? No
Concept? No
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
is it how? Non
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.

Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet

:D

Is it something spoken?

I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that?

Object? No
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Can it move? No
A place? Nope
Event? No
Concept? No
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
is it how? Non
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet

Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not

Is it specific to one race/culture?

Is it a poem?

as a by question, mostly to all those participating: Shoud The Saucepan Man be lynched??? ;) :D

Object? No
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Can it move? No
A place? Nope
Event? No
Concept? No
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
is it how? Non
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not

Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
Shoud The Saucepan Man be lynched??? No :p :D

Thanks - that makes it all so much more clear :mad: :D

It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? :confused:

A dream?

Is it specific to only one individual?

Methinks that once we figure out of what sort it is, there won't be too many choices to pick from...

Object? No
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Can it move? No
A place? Nope
Event? No
Concept? No
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
is it how? Non
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
Shoud The Saucepan Man be lynched??? No

Thanks - that makes it all so much more clear No ;)
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Methinks that once we figure out of what sort it is, there won't be too many choices to pick from... That depends on what "sort" you identify

:smokin:

If the topic title '20 Questions on ME' means what I think it means, I think we're already past the limit and the Saucepan Man should tell us the answer, and start a new question.

Is the involved single individual a hobbit?

At last ...
 

Object? No
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Can it move? No
A place? Nope
Event? No
Concept? No
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
is it how? Non
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
Shoud The Saucepan Man be lynched??? No
Thanks - that makes it all so much more clear No
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Methinks that once we figure out of what sort it is, there won't be too many choices to pick from... That depends on what "sort" you identify

Is the involved single individual a hobbit? Yes! :D

Was the involved hobbit Frodo?

Back to normal
 

Object? No
Third Age? Yes
Living? No
Can it move? No
A place? Nope
Event? No
Concept? No
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
is it how? Non
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
Shoud The Saucepan Man be lynched??? No
Thanks - that makes it all so much more clear No
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Methinks that once we figure out of what sort it is, there won't be too many choices to pick from... That depends on what "sort" you identify
Is the involved single individual a hobbit? Yes!

Was the involved hobbit Frodo? No

Was it Sam?

Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Is the involved single individual a hobbit? Yes!
Was the involved hobbit Frodo? No

Was it Sam? Um ... No. :D

I'll get there... eventually...
 

Was the involved hobbit Merry?

You got there!
 

Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Is the involved single individual a hobbit? Yes!
Was the involved hobbit Frodo? No
Was it Sam? Um ... No.

Was the involved hobbit Merry? N .. er ... yes, actually.

Did the involvement happen before the Hobbits and Strider reached Rivendell?

Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Is the involved single individual a hobbit? Yes!
Was the involved hobbit Frodo? No
Was it Sam? Um ... No
Was the involved hobbit Merry? N .. er ... yes, actually

Did the involvement happen before the Hobbits and Strider reached Rivendell? Oh no.

Did the involvment happen after Merry left Isengard?

Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Is the involved single individual a hobbit? Yes!
Was the involved hobbit Frodo? No
Was it Sam? Um ... No
Was the involved hobbit Merry? N .. er ... yes, actually
Did the involvement happen before the Hobbits and Strider reached Rivendell? Oh no.

Did the involvment happen after Merry left Isengard? Yes

After the Battle of Pelennor Fields?

Did the involvment happen after the Ring was destroyed?

After the escape from Moria?

3 strikes!
 

Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Is the involved single individual a hobbit? Yes!
Was the involved hobbit Frodo? No
Was it Sam? Um ... No
Was the involved hobbit Merry? N .. er ... yes, actually

After the Battle of Pelennor Fields? Yes
Did the involvment happen after the Ring was destroyed? Yes
After the escape from Moria? Yes

Did it happen in the chapter "The Scouring of the Shire"?

Getting closer ...
 

Something intangible (song, language, etc.)? Ah - yup.
Is it something like the name for a weekday, a month, season, time of festival? No
Is it a title? - as a title of a book or a title of a person? Nein
Well then, is it a language? Nay
Is it a song? Niet
Is it something spoken? Negatory
I believe there was a phrase in LOTR that talked about the songs of Rohan being rich and rolling as their lands, something like that, at least. Anything related to that? 'Fraid not
Is it specific to one race/culture? No
Is it a poem? No
It must then be: The vision that Iluvatar showed the Ainur? I'm sorry, but that is not correct.
A dream? That's a negative
Is it specific to only one individual? It involves a specific individual
Is the involved single individual a hobbit? Yes!
Was the involved hobbit Frodo? No
Was it Sam? Um ... No
Was the involved hobbit Merry? N .. er ... yes, actually

Did it happen in the chapter "The Scouring of the Shire"? Indeed it did.