![]() |
Can you see it?
|
Can you see it? YES
|
Did it have anything to do with any of the four hobbits?
|
It is in the Silm?
|
Did it have anything to do with any of the four hobbits? Yes
It is in the Silm? No |
Did it have more to do with Sam then the others?
|
Does it have more to do with any of the hobbits more than the others?
|
Galadriel's mirror?
Was it encountered before the breaking of the Fellowship? |
Did it have more to do with Sam then the others? NO
Does it have more to do with any of the hobbits more than the others? YES Galadriel's mirror? NO |
Does it have more to do with Merry then the others?
|
Does it have more to do with Pippin than the others?
|
Telchar?
|
It's been fourteen days. What about starting a new one, unless
Telchar comes back? |
I'd say go for it. Go ahead and set a new question.
|
Okay, but I can't get to a computer most Sundays.
However... ask away. |
Is it living?
|
Is it living? #1
No. It's not a living thing. |
An event?
|
Yes. It's part of an event. #2
|
Does it involve hobbits?
|
|
First Age?
|
Third age?
|
Does it involve hobbits? #3
No. Did it involve the Dunedain of the South? #4 No. First Age? #5 Yes. Third Age? No. |
Did it involve the Valar?
|
Does it involve Feanor and/or any of his sons?
|
Is it after the awakening of the elves?
|
First Age of the Sun?
|
|
Did it involve the Valar? #6
No. Does it involve Feanor and/or any of his sons? #7 No. Is it after the awakening of the elves? #8 Yes. First Age of the Sun? #9 Yes. Before the Dagor Bragollach? #10 No. |
|
Does it involve any of the Sindar?
|
After the Year of Lamentation?
|
Did it involve the Valar? #6
No. Does it involve Feanor and/or any of his sons? #7 No. Is it after the awakening of the elves? #8 Yes. First Age of the Sun? #9 Yes. Before the Dagor Bragollach? #10 No. Was the family of Hurin (in this case including) involved? #11 No. Does it involve any of the Sindar? #12 Yes. After the Year of Lamentation? #13 No. |
before Awakening of Men?
|
before Awakening of Men? #14
No. |
Since the chronology of events/people in the First Age
can be a bit tricky (at least for me) I thought it might clarify things to give two dates in reference to questions above: The Dagor Bargollach--- F.A. 465 The Year of Lamentation F.A. 472. |
Was it the hunting and death of Carcharoth by Thingol and his warriors, and Huan?
|
Does it happen at Menegroth?
|
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:41 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.