Did it involve Men of the House of Hador?

Was it the hunting and death of Carcharoth by Thingol and his warriors, and Huan? #15
No.

Does it happen at Menegroth? #16
No.

Nauglimir was involved? #17
No.

Did it involve Men of the House of Hador? #18
No.

Does it happen in Doriath at all?

Was there any violence involved?

Did it involve Lúthien?

Does it happen in Doriath at all? # 17
Yes.

Was there any violence involved? # 18
No.

Did it involve Lúthien? # 19
No. But she certainly could be said to
have an interest in the event.

Hmmm . . . was it Daeron spilling the beans to Thingol?

If not, did it involve Daeron at all?

Hmmm . . . was it Daeron spilling the beans to Thingol?
No.

If not, did it involve Daeron at all?
No.

Beren entering Doriath?

After the Death of Thingol?

Was it...the Sack?
________
YA-1

Is it something that someone said/declared/decided etc.?

Beren entering Doriath?
No.

After the Death of Thingol?
No.

Was it...the Sack?
?

Is it something that someone said/declared/decided etc.?
Yes. It's something someone spoke aloud.

During the Feast where tensions between Daeron and Turin exploded out in front of the king?

During the Feast where tensions between Daeron and Turin exploded out in front of the king?
No.

Hint: The event in question takes place outside of Doriath,
and while not violent in itself, its outcome leads to violence.

:confused:

Does Thingol say it?

Is it Luthien escaping from that big tree Thingol put her in?

(I meant the Sack of Doriath, but thats wrong I guess)
________
Glass Bongs

Does Thingol say it?
No, but an elf does.

Is it Luthien escaping from that big tree Thingol put her in?

(I meant the Sack of Doriath, but thats wrong I guess)
That's correct. It's before the sack of Doriath.

Sweeet.
________
Portable Vaporizer

Sweeet!
 

:D

First Age?

Third Age?

First Age?
Yes.

Third Age?
No.

Perhaps part of an earlier answer will help. The event occurred
between:

The Dagor Bargollach--- F.A. 465

The Year of Lamentation F.A. 472.

so its an event?

an event that help evil?

I'm still confused about whether it actually happens in Doriath or not.

Does Beleg say it?

were on a new question there dear firefoot

Did it happen in West Beleriand?

That's what I thought too, but Tuor is still answering questions, so apparently not...

D'oh!
 

Didn't notice that . . . thanks, Firefoot.

Hmmm . . . is it in TS77's Of Beren and Lúthien?

so its an event?

an event that help evil?
The outcome of the event was a victory for evil.
So I guess the answer is yes.

I'm still confused about whether it actually happens in Doriath or not.

Does Beleg say it?
Does not happen in Doriath.
Beleg does not say it.

Did it happen in West Beleriand?
Yes.

Hmmm . . . is it in TS77's Of Beren and Lúthien?
Yes. A partial version of it.

Was the Elf who said it named?

Was the Elf who said it named?
Yes! Especially since he was a speaker.

Well, it could be an anonymous speaker . . .
 

Said by Edrahil?

Oath to Finrod (or something like that)?

Said by Edrahil? No.

Oath to Finrod (or something like that)?
No. But you're getting somewhat warmer.

Cool!
 

Finrod's singing against Sauron, then?

Finrod's singing against Sauron, then?
Yes! Your turn.

I decided on that after listening to some old
audio tapes I have, most of JRRT reciting
bits of his works, but also of CT doing excerpts
of Beren and Luthien, which is more extensive
concerning the Sauron/Finrod singing duel
then in The Silmarillion, since it gives more
of Finrod Felagund's bit. Btw, I think JRRT
is a better speaker then CT. It's curious
JRRT was rather defensive about his speaking.
It seems quite clear.

Sweet!
 

Ask away!

Living?

Living? Yes.

It it one of the Children of Illuvatar?
________
Edsel Villager

It it one of the Children of Illuvatar? No.