BarrowWights? Nazgul

Dorlas?

Ummm...Gil-Galad, if you narrow your first guess a bit, you'll have it

Witch-King? :p

so its Barrow-Wights? or the Prince of Cardolan in Barrow-Wight form to be more exact...

Sorry, Gil-Galad, NightKnight got it! :)

Gil-Galad, sorry for stealing it, but I just had to. ;)

First born, first grieving, first slain.

Not very good, I know. :p

Finwe? he was one of the first elves, greivid for the death of Miriel and first to die by the hand of melkor

Precisely. :)

Wormtoung? Voice of Sauron?

nope! guess again!

Denethor!

nope!

Saruman?

nope.. i'm trying to watch strongbad!!!

trying to watch strongbad? is that suppost to be a hint?

it can be or it can't, but my bet is that it isn't...

Glaurung?

Maeglin?

neither! though your getting closer...

Hint: the second guess might throw people off...

Smaug?

now your getting farther away...

Morgoth?

little bit closer but no...Maeglin was closest so far...

Eöl then?

Getting a tad bit closer, though i need explantions...hint its an elf...

Galadriel when she fell out of a flet and started swearing? ;) :D

Abercrombie, aaah, that would have been my guess too! :D

If Abercrombie is not correct how about Feanor?

Gil-Galad???? Come on I'm dying here...

nope nope nope....heh...

Mega Hint: First age wood elf

Thingol?

close...Thingol knew this fellow

Saeros.

Hurting words - mocked Turin
hurting stare - apaprently had Beaming eyes
hurting head - Turin threw a cup at his head...good times...



your go NightKnight!

Thankies.

Slave, Leader, Seeker.

sounds like Hurin too me...

Nope. Could have been, though.

Gollum

seeking the ring
leading sam and frodo
kind of their slave at the same time?

The Witchking, perhaps? Slave of Sauron, leader of the Nazgul, seeker of Frodo and the Ring.