Nope, its something they all did... for someone. [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

They all died in search of someone.

Except for Tar-Amadil I mean. Opps. I forgot that.

You are correct! See, that wasn't hard.

COOL!!

Bregalad
Aragorn
Saruman
Gimli
Boromir

Bregalad is the only one who hasn't been to Minas Tirith.

no

Boromir is the only one who hasn't been in Fangorn Forest.

Thats right!

*frodo because he is the only one whose name isnt shortened
*frodo because he is the only one who left middle earth

Finrod Felagund
Gil-Galad
The Mouth of Sauron
Faramir
Aulë

I'd hazard a guess at Faramir as all the others have had first-hand dealings with The Great Eye.

Ahh, yes. They all had first-hand dealings with Sauron who later was known as the Great Eye.

Fingon
Hurin
Thorin
Frodo
Legolas

Frodo is the only one who has never taken part in a battle.

You could argue he had a role of sorts in the Battle of Bywater. Anyway, that's not the answer ... keep going!!

Thorin, only one to not see a Balrog. Aye, far-fetched I know.

It's good but it's not the answer.

Frodo is the only one whose father has not fought either Morgoth or Sauron.

They're all good guesses, but not it ...

Clue: - It's about something they've experienced that is not natural to their being.

They all wandered far => Men, Elves and dwarfes all do that => Hobbits don´t =>Frodo is a hobbit => Frodo is the OMO. Isn´t he?

Russandol? Was I correct? [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

Fraid not.

something not natural to their being? What, like killed?... Please elaborate.

Without giving this one away [which would be unfair as it's foxed you all for so long [img]smilies/biggrin.gif[/img] ] I'll say only this. Four of them have had a rare honour


[img]smilies/evil.gif[/img]

I´ve got it!!(i think). THORIN didn´t sail to Valinor! I wasn´t sure if Hurin had, but he did!
I´m positive I´m right this time...

*bump*

You could say something a bit more than "bump".
Make it non-spamish like, "Hey Russandol! You on vacation? Not been around for a while. Don't forget, you have 10 days from my post to confirm it, or it's anybodys!"

Sorry. I just don't like one word posts. Well, answers are okay as one word... but now I'm just going on. Ok thats it.

Sorry if I was being rude. No such thing intended... what´s that 20 day thingy?

No, you weren't being rude. In fact, maybe I was. Anyways, its the 10 day thing which you can check out here: Quiz Room Rules

Your quite proud of that clause you had me put in aren't you Lind.? lol.

Anyway, I would say that Manardariel should go as Russandol seems to be long gone. She did have the best (and more than likely correct) guess so far.

Beren87- Thank you. If you say it´s correct, it should be! [img]smilies/wink.gif[/img]
Lindolirian- thanks for clarification. Now I know!

Everybody- Here´s an new OMU game:

Elrond
Aragorn
Denethor
Sam
Ganadalf

Have fun!

Denethor has never been to Rivendell.

Actually, I misread it. I thought it was 10 days without a post. I've posted clues(ish) since my original question but no matter. I shall reveal the answer ... Legolas - all the others have flown on or been carried by eagles. Legolas merely watched one from afar.

Ooooops.. ok then, sorry.

Are we doing mine anyway??
Lindolirian, you weren´t correct.

Denethor has never been to Mordor.. or before it's Gates which is really close anyways.

Denethor never met Frodo

Nope, Nope, Nope...

But I think I have to change it:

Elrond
Galadriel
Denethor
Sam
Gimli

Sorry about that!! [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]

Denethor never went to the Havens? He stayed in Middle Earth?

Nope!
Think books, everyone [img]smilies/smile.gif[/img]