I'll let you have that one again– see question 10.

Ah yes, the Calaquendi are the elves of Aman, aren't they? :o

Was he of the Green Elves or the Nandor then?

12. No.

Did he ever come to Gondolin?

Is he Maeglin?

Is it Eöl?

Is it Eöl? Yes.

Well done, Eönwë!

Eönwë?

I don't have much time, so I'll pass it on to whoever wants it.

I'm ready. First question is...?

Is it alive?

#1 Is it alive?

Nope.

Is it tangible?

#2 Is it tangible?

Good question. I'd say No.

Interessant . . .

Was it created?

#3 Was it created?

Somewhat difficult to answer, certainly not as a yes
or no answer. I'd say "it" isn't created as such,
although it's particular existence in the "story" is
related to some creation. (Ooh, that sounds oracular
enough to be at Delphic)! And when the answer is
revealed, rather mundane.

Is it round?

So it's not a law, nor a music, nor a tale (the written account, ich meine) . . .

Hmmm, did it exist during, say, the First Age?

So it's not a law, nor a music, nor a tale (the written account, ich meine) . . .
Correct.

#4 Hmmm, did it exist during, say, the First Age?
No. Not during the First Age.

Did it exist during the Second Age?

Stab!
 

The Flame Imperishable? :D

#5 Did it exist during the Second Age?

No.

#6 The Flame Imperishable?

No.

Tom Bombadil?

#6 Tom Bombadil?

Nope.

I'd say it's too soon for specific guesses.

Did this ethereal 'it' come into contact with any of the Valar?

#7
No.

And a clarification: the "it" is rather
pedestrian, and while insubstantial,
is tangible. Sorry for possible confusion,
but I'm trying to be accurate without
giving too much away.
(Hint, granted a tiny one) Hmm, not in the
First or Second Age,so what Age
could it be?

I see . . .
 

So it could be in the Third Age, Fourth Age, or the time before the Ages. :p

Is it, perhaps, a wind of some sort?

The Deeps of time?

#8

Is it, perhaps, a wind of some sort?
Not a wind as such, but you're on the right track.
You might say it can be wind assisted.
====================================


#9 The Deeps of time?
No. Much more mundane.

The spirit of Saruman?

#9
The spirit of Saruman?

Nope. But you are correct
that it's in the Third Age.

The spirit of Sauron, then?

Or am I barking at[sic] the wrong tree? Rarf!

No. Way off. It's tangible. Try to narrow it down (by area, time,
or person?).

*cough*

Tuor, may I draw your attention to this:

Okay. I give up.
The subject was Fili's
being tortured by the smell of apples.

Someone else please take over.

How. Could. Anyone. Possibly. Get. That?

Nerwen has a point.

Precious.
 

Praps we need to set some limits?

Answers limited to four words, or two nounsss, praps?

OMG. You seriously hafta be kidding... Wind assisted.. but makes sense anyway, now that I've seen the answer. T_T

Tuor's incredibly imaginative answer has rather killed the thread I'm afraid, but it's a fun game so lets start again!

I'm think of something (and it's not as creative as the last). Read my mind!