One of the Kings?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.
Númenorean? Yes
Did he spell his name in Adûnaic? No.
Was he of the Line of Elros? Yes.

One of the Kings? No.

Time to try a name...

Valandil, Lord of Andúnie?

Is it large? Um . . . No-ish.
Is it a person? Yes.
Does its name start with a letter between A and L? No.
Is the person male? Yes.
Did he live during the Third Age? No.
Is he an Elf? No.
Maybe a Dwarf? No.
1st Age? No.
Númenorean? Yes
Did he spell his name in Adûnaic? No.
Was he of the Line of Elros? Yes.
One of the Kings? No.

Valandil, Lord of Andúnie? Nope, sorry.

I just discovered this is still unsolved, so:

Did he live in the first millennium of the Second Age?

May I go?

I'll go.Let's see...I thought of something.

Can I go?

It's been a while so sure, go ahead.

Does the name begin with Tar-?

BG, it rather looks like Nilp has completely forgotten about this thread, and I haven't seen him on the Downs for quite a while anyway, so I don't think it makes much sense to ask him any more questions about the last riddle. So if you'd like to take over, just think of something/somebody new, and we can start firing our questions at you, OK? (If in doubt how this works, just read the very first post on this thread.)

Okay. I have something. Start asking!

Is it a person?

Is it a person? NO

Can it be held in a hand?

Is it a place?

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES

Is it or was it located in Middle-earth? (meaning east of the Great Sea)

Is it an artificial construct (city, fortress, house, rtc.)?

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES
Is it in Middle-Earth YES
Is it a structure (ie building city wagon) YES

Did it exist after the First Age?

Was it made by an elf or elves?

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES
Is it in Middle-Earth YES
Is it a structure (ie building city wagon) YES
Did It exsist after the First Age? YES
Was it made by an elf or elves? NEITHER as far as I'm sure, no elves help make it

Was it made by dwarves?

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES
Is it in Middle-Earth YES
Is it a structure (ie building city wagon) YES
Did It exsist after the First Age? YES
Was it made by an elf or elves? NEITHER as far as I'm sure, no elves help make it
Was it made by dwarfs NO

Is it west of the Anduin?

Is it north of Caradhras?

Making me get my map out hm?

Is it a person. NO
Can it be held NO
Is it a place YES
Is it in Middle-Earth YES
Is it a structure (ie building city wagon) YES
Did It exsist after the First Age? YES
Was it made by an elf or elves? NEITHER as far as I'm sure, no elves help make it
Was it made by dwarfs NO
Is it west of the Anduin NO-ish
Is it north of Caradhras NO*




*I can't find Caradhras on my map, but it should be between Rivendell and Moria, right?

NO-ish? Hmmm...
It's not by any chance Osgiliath, is it?

(Caradhras, by the way, is sitting more or less right on top of Moria.)

Darn you!

Okay your turn. :p

Thanks!:D I suppose that answer of yours was a bit give-away-ish...;)

OK, fire away everybody!

Is it alive?

Is it a Man?

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No

Is it an elf?

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No

Is it an olvar?

Is It a dwarf?

Is it a Maia?

Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No
Is it an Elf? - No
Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;))
Is it a Dwarf? - No
Is it a Maia? - No