![]() |
Female?
|
Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No Is it an Elf? - No Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;)) Is it a Dwarf? - No Is it a Maia? - No Female? - No |
Is it a Vala?
|
Manwë?
|
Is it an orc?
|
Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No Is it an Elf? - No Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;)) Is it a Dwarf? - No Is it a Maia? - No Female? - No Is it a Vala? - No Manwë? - See above Is it an Orc? - No |
Those giant eagle birds? Like the one that saved bilbo and co in The Hobbit? And the one that rescued Fingolfin's body from Angband?
|
Is it Tom Bombadil?
|
Is it an evil creature/individual?
|
Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No Is it an Elf? - No Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;)) Is it a Dwarf? - No Is it a Maia? - No Female? - No Is it a Vala? - No Manwë? - See above Is it an Orc? - No Is it a giant eagle? - No Is it Tom Bombadil? - No Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p |
Is it in The Hobbit?
|
Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No Is it an Elf? - No Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;)) Is it a Dwarf? - No Is it a Maia? - No Female? - No Is it a Vala? - No Manwë? - See above Is it an Orc? - No Is it a giant eagle? - No Is it Tom Bombadil? - No Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p Is it in The Hobbit? - No |
Did he live in the First Age?
|
Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No Is it an Elf? - No Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;)) Is it a Dwarf? - No Is it a Maia? - No Female? - No Is it a Vala? - No Manwë? - See above Is it an Orc? - No Is it a giant eagle? - No Is it Tom Bombadil? - No Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p Is it in The Hobbit? - No Did he live in the First Age? - Hmm... interesting question, now I think about it; but to avoid misleading you, let's say "Presumably not".:cool: |
Did he take part in LotR?
|
Is he a bird?
|
Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No Is it an Elf? - No Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;)) Is it a Dwarf? - No Is it a Maia? - No Female? - No Is it a Vala? - No Manwë? - See above Is it an Orc? - No Is it a giant eagle? - No Is it Tom Bombadil? - No Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p Is it in The Hobbit? - No Did he live in the First Age? - Hmm... interesting question, now I think about it; but to avoid misleading you, let's say "Presumably not".:cool: Did he take part in LotR? - Yes!!! Is he a bird? - No |
THere's only two yes answers.
Ent? |
Is it Gollum?
|
@Sally Would you consider Gollum evil?
|
Is he a wose?
|
Did it help the fellowship in any way?
|
Is it alive? - Yes
Is it a Man? - No Is it an Elf? - No Is it an olvar? - No (nor a plant by any other name;)) Is it a Dwarf? - No Is it a Maia? - No Female? - No Is it a Vala? - No Manwë? - See above Is it an Orc? - No Is it a giant eagle? - No Is it Tom Bombadil? - No Is it an evil creature/individual? - Not evil, but definitely a creature, and quite individual:p Is it in The Hobbit? - No Did he live in the First Age? - Actually, scrap what I said above and make that a clear NO. I was just being nasty and allowing for a crazy theory which isn't substantiated by anything in the book. Sorry for any confusion this may have caused. Did he take part in LotR? - Yes!!! Is he a bird? - No Ent? - No Gollum? - No Is he a wose? - We've established above that he's not a Man, which would include the Woses (or Drú-edain); therefore obviously No. Did it help the fellowship in any way? - Yes, I think you could say he was helpful to some of them. Quote:
EDIT: x-ed with Estanesse (hi, pleased to meet you!), question & answer added above. |
Is it Shadowfax?
|
(This is getting rather too long to repeat all the Q&A every time, I trust you're all able to look 'em up above)
Is it Shadowfax? - No, but getting warmer! |
oliphant
like elephant? |
Did it pass the dark door?
|
Oliphaunt? - No
Did it pass the dark door? - I suppose you mean the entrance to the Paths of the Dead? No, it (or he) came nowhere near the place. |
Is he Bill the Pony?
|
Is it BIll?
Edit: darn... Okay then, Fatty Lumpkin! |
Is it Bill the Pony? - Sorry, no. But you're getting closer.
|
Fatty Lumpkin?
|
...and we have a winner!
Well done, BG - Fatty Lumpkin it is! Take the thread! (To clear up the First Age ambivalence up there: considering that Bombadil has been around for a long, long time and we're never told how old Fatty was, I had that madcap idea that Iarwain Ben-adar's mount could perhaps have been some equally enigmatic long-lived beast along the lines of e.g. Huan or Thorondor; but there's really nothing pointing in that direction beyond his connection with ole Bombadillo, and nothing indicating that he was anything but a regular pony. Sorry if anybody was led astray!) |
Derp. I just realized how stupid my guess was. That's what I get for not reading more carefully. *blushes*
|
yEah! When he said bill I thought fatty!
Okay let's see! GO! |
Alive?
|
Alive? Yes
|
Is it a male?
|
Alive? Yes
Is it male? Yes |
Can it talk?
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:23 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.