Is he in LOTR?

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No

Did he live in or visit Beleriand?

Was he an elf?

Did he die in battle?

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No

Was he one of the bad guys/creatures?

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No
Was he one of the bad guys/creatures? Yes

A dragon?

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No
Was he one of the bad guys/creatures? Yes
A Dragon? No

Was he ever captured?

Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No
Was he one of the bad guys/creatures? Yes
A Dragon? No
Was he ever captured? Yes

Was he captured more than once?

You know who this is don’t you? :P


Alive? Yes
Male? Yes
Can he talk? Yes
Was he in lotr? No
Did he live in or visit Beleriand? Yes
Was he an Elf? No
Did he die in battle? No
Was he one of the bad guys/creatures? Yes
A Dragon? No
Was he ever captured? Yes
Was he captured more then once? Yes

I think I do. Morgoth?

I was thinking more like Melkor but what ever! Okay go ahead!

Thanks!:)
Ok, open fire.

Is it male?

Is it a place?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope

As he ever been is Beleriand?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope

Was he a Vala?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope

(By the way, I'm going to be away from my computer from tomorrow till Sunday evening, so have a little patience, please; I'll answer any questions asked in my absence when I get back.)

Is he an elf?

Maia?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope

Ilúvatar?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - Good gracious, no!:D

What? If he's not a Maia, a Vala, or an elf then what else can he be? Oh!

A Man?




Why wouldn't you use Ilúvatar? One of my favorite charactors next to Melkor :D

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No

Or a Dwarf, or an Orc, or an Ent, or a... indeed any number of things. Remember my last one was a pony?

Oh, I could and I would, but the contrast between your guess and the character I'm actually thinking of was just hilarious; you'll understand when you see who it is. I didn't mean that there was anything wrong with your guess as such - sorry if it came across that way.

Is it a person under 4 feet tall?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!

And welcome to the Downs, Kyranger! Enjoy your afterlife!

HoBbit?

welcome to the 'Downs Kyranger!

Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope

Is he ever known to have left the Shire?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope
Is he ever known to have left the Shire? - Er, well... He isn't actually known to ever have been to the Shire. (He may have been, but we're not told.)

Iss it the nice, helpful hobbit (poor Smeagol)
from whom Thief Baggins stole the Preciouss?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope
Is he ever known to have left the Shire? - Er, well... He isn't actually known to ever have been to the Shire. (He may have been, but we're not told.)
Iss it the nice, helpful hobbit (poor Smeagol)...? - Nice and helpful he was, but not Smeagol/Gollum.