Is he a servant of Barliman Butterbur?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope
Is he ever known to have left the Shire? - Er, well... He isn't actually known to ever have been to the Shire. (He may have been, but we're not told.)
Iss it the nice, helpful hobbit (poor Smeagol)...? - Nice and helpful he was, but not Smeagol/Gollum.
Is he a servant of Barliman Butterbur? - Yep!

Did he work often with ponies?

Is it male? - Yep
Is it a place? - Nope
Ever been in Beleriand? - Nope
Was he a Vala? - Nope
Is he an Elf? - Nope
Maia? - Nope
Ilúvatar? - No
A Man? - No
Is it a person under 4 feet tall? - Yep!
Hobbit? - Yes
Was he in Gondor during the battle of the Pelennor Fields? - Nope
Is he ever known to have left the Shire? - Er, well... He isn't actually known to ever have been to the Shire. (He may have been, but we're not told.)
Iss it the nice, helpful hobbit (poor Smeagol)...? - Nice and helpful he was, but not Smeagol/Gollum.
Is he a servant of Barliman Butterbur? - Yep!
Did he work often with ponies? - *goes to check* No, it's the other one.:)

Ill make a wild guess:D is it Nob?

Yes it is!:D Well done, Estanesse; the thread is yours!

Thank you Pitchwife.
Ask away.

Is it a person?

Is it an Elf?

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No

Man?

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No
Man? - No

A short person?

Is it evil?

A vala or maia?

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No
Man? - No
A short person?- define short
Is it evil?- Yes
A vala or maia? No

Has it ever flown(this includes Balrogs)?

Was it alive in the Third Age?

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No
Man? - No
A short person?- define short
Is it evil?- Yes
A vala or maia? No
Has it ever flown(this includes Balrogs)?- no
Was it alive in the Third Age?- yes

An orc?

Did it play a part in the War of the Ring?

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No
Man? - No
A short person?- define short
Is it evil?- Yes
A vala or maia? No
Has it ever flown(this includes Balrogs)?- no
Was it alive in the Third Age?- yes
An orc?- Yes
Did it play a part in the War of the Ring? No

Did he* have any hostile business with Dwarves?
*(since it's an Orc, and there are to my knowledge no female Orcs mentioned in the books)

I've wondered if there were female orcs.
I ment Man as the race not the sex.


Azog?

Bolg?

Is it a person?- Yes
Is it an Elf? - No
Man? - No
A short person?- define short
Is it evil?- Yes
A vala or maia? No
Has it ever flown(this includes Balrogs)?- no
Was it alive in the Third Age?- yes
An orc?- Yes
Did it play a part in the War of the Ring? No
Did he* have any hostile business with Dwarves?- Yes
Azog?- Yes
Bolg?- No

You got it Blind Guardian, the floor is yours

Thank you. Okay people shoot!

A place?

Is it a living being?
(x-ed with Tuor)

Is it a place? No
Is it a living being? Yes

Hmm hoom hoom.
Is it among Treebeard's amended list of the free peoples of
Middle-earth (so as to include hobbits)?

Is it a place? No
Is it a living being? Yes
Is it among Treebeards list of free people? Yes

Did it ever lived west of the Blue mountains?

Female?

Is it a place? No
Is it a living being? Yes
Is it among Treebeards list of free people? Yes
Did it ever live west of the Blue Mountians? I have no clue. Where are the Blue Mountians?
Female? No

Near the sea in the north-west of the LotR Map, north and south of the Gulf of Lhûn; they used to form the border between Beleriand and Eriador in the First Age, before Beleriand was sunk.

He lived east of them.

Is it a place? No
Is it a living being? Yes
Is it among Treebeards list of free people? Yes
Did it ever live west of the Blue Mountians? No
Female? No

Third Age?

Is it a place? No
Is it a living being? Yes
Is it among Treebeards list of free people? Yes
Did it ever live west of the Blue Mountians? No
Female? No
Third age? Yes

Mortal?