Is it a place? No
Is it a living being? Yes
Is it among Treebeards list of free people? Yes
Did it ever live west of the Blue Mountians? No
Female? No
Third age? Yes
Mortal? Yes

Was he in The Hobbit?

Is it a place? No
Is it a living being? Yes
Is it among Treebeards list of free people? Yes
Did it ever live west of the Blue Mountians? No
Female? No
Third age? Yes
Mortal? Yes
Was he in the Hobbit? Yes

Is he Beorn?

Yay! That was hard. -_- Okay, now your turn.

Okay. Whenever anyone is ready, begin.

Being terribly unoriginal...

Is it alive?

Is it alive? No.

Is it a place?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.

Do elves live there?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.

Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.

Is it east of the Blue Mountains?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.

Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No

Is it in middle earth?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No

Is it in middle earth? Yes.

Is it neer any place evil?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.

Is it near any place evil? Yes.

Is it located near or on the river Sirion?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.
Is it near any place evil? Yes.

Is it located near or on the river Sirion? I'd say yes.

Just to get that out of the way - it's not Tol-in-Gaurhoth, or is it?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.
Is it near any place evil? Yes.
Is it located near or on the river Sirion? I'd say yes.

Just to get that out of the way - it's not Tol-in-Gaurhoth, or is it?
Nope.

Is it east of Sirion?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.
Is it near any place evil? Yes.
Is it located near or on the river Sirion? I'd say yes.
Just to get that out of the way - it's not Tol-in-Gaurhoth, or is it?
Nope.

Is it east of Sirion? Good question. Yes.

Intuitive stab - the Fen of Serech?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.
Is it near any place evil? Yes.
Is it located near or on the river Sirion? I'd say yes.
Just to get that out of the way - it's not Tol-in-Gaurhoth, or is it?
Nope.

Intuitive stab - the Fen of Serech? No.

Im thinking Minas Tirith only 'cause Sauron once was there.

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.
Is it near any place evil? Yes.
Is it located near or on the river Sirion? I'd say yes.
Tol-in-Gaurhoth? Nope.
the Fen of Serech? No.

Minas Tirith? Nope.

note: "Near" is a relative term. It doesn't necessarily mean
right by the Sirion.

I have no clue. What else is there?

Is it north of Doriath?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.
Is it near any place evil? Yes.
Is it located near or on the river Sirion? I'd say yes.
Tol-in-Gaurhoth? Nope.
the Fen of Serech? No.
Minas Tirith? Nope.

note: "Near" is a relative term. It doesn't necessarily mean
right by the Sirion.

Is it north of Doriath? Yes

South of Ard-galen?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.
Is it near any place evil? Yes.
Is it located near or on the river Sirion? I'd say yes.
Tol-in-Gaurhoth? Nope.
the Fen of Serech? No.
Minas Tirith? Nope.
Is it north of Doriath? Yes
note: "Near" is a relative term. It doesn't necessarily mean
right by the Sirion.

South of Ard-galen? Yes.

North of Ered Gorgoroth?

Is it alive? No.
Is it a place? Yes.
Do elves live there? No, but they've been there.
Is it east of the Blue Mountains? No
Is it in middle earth? Yes.
Is it near any place evil? Yes.
Is it located near or on the river Sirion? I'd say yes.
Tol-in-Gaurhoth? Nope.
the Fen of Serech? No.
Minas Tirith? Nope.
Is it north of Doriath? Yes
note: "Near" is a relative term. It doesn't necessarily mean
right by the Sirion.
South of Ard-galen? Yes.

North of Ered Gorgoroth? No, since it's in that mountain range.

The Pass of Anach?

The Pass of Anach?

Yes. That's it.

Yeah!:D That was a tough one, Tuor (especially as almost anything in that region was 'near some evil place'). Very nice.:)

OK, ready when you are.

Is it alive?

Does it exist in the First Age?