Is he a dwarf?

Is it alive? - Yes.
Is it bipedal? - Yes.
Is it evil? - Well... not exactly evil.
Is s/he mortal? - Yes.
Is it an olvar? - No.
Is it female? - No.
Was it alive in the Second Age? - No.
What about the Third? - Yes.
Gollum? - No.
Is it a bird? - No.
Was he alive during the War of the Ring? - No.
Is he a dwarf? - No.

Is he a hobbit?

Is it alive? - Yes.
Is it bipedal? - Yes.
Is it evil? - Well... not exactly evil.
Is s/he mortal? - Yes.
Is it an olvar? - No.
Is it female? - No.
Was it alive in the Second Age? - No.
What about the Third? - Yes.
Gollum? - No.
Is it a bird? - No.
Was he alive during the War of the Ring? - No.
Is he a dwarf? - No.
Is he a hobbit? - No.

Did he live in Gondor?

Is it alive? - Yes.
Is it bipedal? - Yes.
Is it evil? - Well... not exactly evil.
Is s/he mortal? - Yes.
Is it an olvar? - No.
Is it female? - No.
Was it alive in the Second Age? - No.
What about the Third? - Yes.
Gollum? - No.
Is it a bird? - No.
Was he alive during the War of the Ring? - No.
Is he a dwarf? - No.
Is he a hobbit? - No.
Did he live in Gondor? - Yes.

Was he in any way involved in the Kinstrife?

Is it alive? - Yes.
Is it bipedal? - Yes.
Is it evil? - Well... not exactly evil.
Is s/he mortal? - Yes.
Is it an olvar? - No.
Is it female? - No.
Was it alive in the Second Age? - No.
What about the Third? - Yes.
Gollum? - No.
Is it a bird? - No.
Was he alive during the War of the Ring? - No.
Is he a dwarf? - No.
Is he a hobbit? - No.
Did he live in Gondor? - Yes.
Was he in any way involved in the Kinstrife? - Yes.

:)
Is it Castamir?

Yes! Good work Pitchwife.:) Your turn.

Thanks! I'm ready to go, ask away.

Is it a person?

A place?

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.

A man?

Evil?

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.

Live in the third age?

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.
Live in the third age? - No.

Lived in the First Age?

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.
Live in the third age? - No.
Lived in the First Age? - Yes.

Was he/she alive after the Nírnaeth Arnoediad?

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.
Live in the third age? - No.
Lived in the First Age? - Yes.
Was he/she alive after the Nírnaeth Arnoediad? - Yes he was.

was it an elf?

One of Feänors' sons?

I was just wondering why nobody was answering any questions on this thread anymore, when I suddenly realised it was still my riddle.:o Oops! Luckily, I remember who it was about, so:

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.
Live in the third age? - No.
Lived in the First Age? - Yes.
Was he/she alive after the Nírnaeth Arnoediad? - Yes he was.
was it an elf? - No.
One of Feänors' sons? - See above.

Is he related to Turin?

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.
Live in the third age? - No.
Lived in the First Age? - Yes.
Was he/she alive after the Nírnaeth Arnoediad? - Yes he was.
was it an elf? - No.
One of Feänors' sons? - See above.
Is he related to Turin? - Related as in family? No.

fo
 

Did he live in the Forest of Brethil?

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.
Live in the third age? - No.
Lived in the First Age? - Yes.
Was he/she alive after the Nírnaeth Arnoediad? - Yes he was.
was it an elf? - No.
One of Feänors' sons? - See above.
Is he related to Turin? - Related as in family? No.
Did he live in the Forest of Brethil? - Nope.

Was he/she still alive during the Fall of Gondolin?

Miggy! You're back!*dances*

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.
Live in the third age? - No.
Lived in the First Age? - Yes.
Was he/she alive after the Nírnaeth Arnoediad? - Yes he was.
was it an elf? - No.
One of Feänors' sons? - See above.
Is he related to Turin? - Related as in family? No.
Did he live in the Forest of Brethil? - Nope.
Was he/she still alive during the Fall of Gondolin? - Hmm, not mentioned, as far as I can recollect. (Good question, though.)

Was he of the House of Hador?

Is it a person? - Yes.
A place? - No.
A man? - Yep.
Evil? - No.
Live in the third age? - No.
Lived in the First Age? - Yes.
Was he/she alive after the Nírnaeth Arnoediad? - Yes he was.
was it an elf? - No.
One of Feänors' sons? - See above.
Is he related to Turin? - Related as in family? No.
Did he live in the Forest of Brethil? - Nope.
Was he/she still alive during the Fall of Gondolin? - Hmm, not mentioned, as far as I can recollect. (Good question, though.)
Was he of the House of Hador? - Of their people, but not of the dynasty.

Turin is related to Hador! He's the Lord of Dor Lomin.
Do you mean that it's a person from Hador who is not closely related to Turin?
The only gues I have in that case is Labadach. Or maybe one of those people who helped Turin escape after he killed Brodda. But isn't that still their dynasty?
Or maybe it was Elros, since he's Hador by his grandfather Tuor. But he's still related to Turin, although distantly.

I said the person in question wasn't related to Turin in the sense of family kinship (but still could be connected to him in other ways), and was of the people ruled by the House of Hador but not of the dynasty=the ruling family, to which Turin belonged. No contradiction here.

But to spare you any further guesses, you're right, it's Sador, nicknamed Labadal (whom for some reason you keep calling Labadach). Well guessed, take the thread!

For some reason I keep thinking of him as Labadach.

OK! I'm ready to go! This should be an easy one.

Anyone wanna ask a question?

Ah sorry, I meant to, but quite forgot about it. Blame Werewolf.

Is it an object?

A person?