Yes he was :)

Edit Sorry no this was a duplicate post because my computerr froze.... NOT Theoden

Brilliant!

Ok, you can start asking...

Sorry I thought my answer hadn't posted. I didn't see Theoden, It isn't Theoden, He was born in Gondor.

Sorry I should have repeated the question but was lazy.

Oooops!


Eomer, then?

Not Eomer either.

Elfhelm?

Yay,,,, Elfhelm it was. I suppose he might have been born in the Wold but I think I read he was a lord of the Eastfold before he became its Marshal. Anyway even though he was a wee bit disobedient, definitely one of the good guys.

Alrighty! I have something in mind...

Place?

Place - no

Living thing?

Place - no
Living thing - erm... yes.

Biped?

Place - no
Living thing - yes
Biped - no

(good question! ;))

Cheers ..now which way to go on the next - 2 routes....... hmm

Plant?

Place - no
Living thing - yes
Biped - no
Plant - yes

Ooh I jumped the right way...... now to narrow it most effectively .... my best guess would be tree?

Herb?

Rare / one-of-a-kind?

Place - no
Living thing - yes
Biped - no
Plant - yes
Tree - yes
Herb - yes
Rare/one of a kind - definitely!

You're very close now!

A tree and a herb?

Oi! What was I doing? :o It is not a herb. Why did I write that? Thank you Mith for pointing this out!

Place - no
Living thing - yes
Biped - no
Plant - yes
Tree - yes
Herb - no
Rare/one of a kind - yes

Does it feature in LOTR?

Don't worry about it... not an impossible combination I just couldn't reconcile the rarity too -it oculd have been a bay tree in Ithilien....

Place - no
Living thing - yes
Biped - no
Plant - yes
Tree - yes
Herb - no
Rare/one of a kind - yes
Features in LOTR - no

Stab in the twilight..
 

Is it the White tree the Eldar give Aldarion and Erendis as a wedding gift?

Place - no
Living thing - yes
Biped - no
Plant - yes
Tree - yes
Herb - no
Rare/one of a kind - yes
Features in LOTR - no

Is it the White tree the Eldar give Aldarion and Erendis as a wedding gift? - no, but heading in the right direction. You're closer with every question!


When I said that it is not in LOTR, I meant that it does not play a part, but IIRC it is mentioned.

Is it a named tree?

Is it a named tree - yup

Was it in Aman?

Was it in Aman - indeed it was!

Laurelin?

Exactly! :D Thread is yours!

Gosh I was sure I would go for the wrong one.

Ok "Have at it" as they say across the water..

Is it a person?

Not a person.

Place?

Yes it is a place.

Is it in ME?

It is

West of the Misty Mountains?