Ah.. right . No not a living thing.

An object?

Yes it is an object

Is it made by a person (vs a natural object like a mountain)?

It is a made object.

Made in the first age?

Made by an elf?

It was.

Which question are you referring to?

Oops cross post but the answer is the same. Made in the first age by an elf

Is it a weapon?

'tis a weapon ..you are on a roll here..

Made in Chi... erm, I mean, Gondolin? ;)

Not made in Gondolin...

Anglachel?

Not Anglachel.....

Anguirel?

Nor Anguirel

Hm. Angrist?

Not Ang anything....

Ringil?

Isn't that a river ;)

No.

Isn't that Fingolfin's sword?

Anyways, is it a sword?

I know I was thinking of Ringlo..who was of course drummer with the Beatles..

Not a sword ....

Aiglos?

Not Aiglos... would that be First age...? Maybe I guess the Noldor made stuff to last...

I wasn't sure when it was made, but Elvish things do last! Sting is a great example!

Is it... Belthronding?

It is not Beleg's bow....

Fingon's bow, with which he was about to shoot Maedhros?

Narsil?

Wasn't it made by Telchar=Dwarf?

Not Fingon's bow.

And it still isn't a sword ;) so not Narsil regardless of who constructed it.

Hmmmm....mmmmm.....mmmmm.....

Is it a bow at all?

No not a bow.

Is it named? (eg having 'Anduril' versus 'Aragorn's sword')

Not a named weapon

Hurin's axe? He had quite a few Elven weapons...

No ... you were closer earlier maybe but went astray....

*(metaphorically) bangs her head on the wal*

The speare that Beren tried to throw at Carcharoth?

Ps - lol for your siggy! :D

No but you are getting warmer again.

Gosh I didn't think this was so obscure!!! Honestly it isn't something that is only mentioned in the deeper recesses of HoME