doesn't have too, kind of hard to go from minas tirith to Gondolin. its up to whomever turn it is, they can decide whether to continue on or start new. we may get bored of Middle Earth and go to Beleriand or the Undying Lands.

How about Lothlorien?

Sorry, but no all wrong.
From all further SW. (guess this won't take too long)

Btw, sorry, must have missed that rule. It would btw, be south of Chetwood, but I think you figured that out anyway now.

Is it Helm's Deep?

Or is it Tharbad?

Tharbad - South
Helm's Deep - West

I think we are pretty much there. ;)

You sure it is west and not north-west?

But if so, then I say Drúwaith Iaur.

I know this is a little out North-West of Helm's Deep, but is it The Gap of Rohan?

Nope, Leg-it already got it.

Okay. From Drúwaith Iaur, let's go North-Eastern.

The Gladden Fields?

Oh no! How did you know so fast? :eek:

Indeed, your turn :D

Thank you, Legate. With pleasure, we go from the Gladden Fields => Northeast.

What about the Mountains of Mirkwood?

As I doubt it's the Iron Hills again, I'll go ahead and say Erebor.

Mountains of Mirkwood - North
Erebor - still North

In that case it's most probably Withered Heath.

Most Correct, Legate.

Withered Heath it is. Your turn.

Okay. For the New Year, let us move to Beleriand.

We arrive together with Fëanor and his sons. We pass through Lammoth and stop on the very southern end of Ered Lómin. And from here, from the camps and firelights in cold New Year's night we have to set on our path eastwards to reach the place we want to move to.

Have fun.

With the sons of Feanor we would probably want to challenge Morgoth so what about the Fen of Serech.

Nay. Still east.

Lothlann

A very good orientation point to pick. South from there.

Following Feanor and his sons, could it be the hill of Himring?

Maybe Mount Rerir

Of course, correct :) A bonus question (easy for a Tolkien-loremaster): who are we? (Or who is with us, taking where we started and where we ended?)

You can take the thread anyway :)

Which one of us is right?

(Puzzlement ensues)

The Might is right. I forgot to quote his post.

Well, I know Caranthir was there.

Anyway, from Mount Rerir I suggest we go SW.

Yup, I meant Caranthir. :)

From one mountain to another mountain: what about Amon Ereb?

Nan Elmoth perhaps?

My guess is the Falls of Sirion.

From all SW

go to the extreme...

Isle of Balar?

And going to the extreme was a good choice.
You're next Gil.

alright!

from Isle of Balar let us go... North-East

Menegroth

Menegroth > South-east

Amon Ereb