I've gone over the above voting a number of times and
it seems that Caradhras should have 2 more votes.
If so then, with voting here of

Hurt Glorfindel Hurt Imrahil Heal Fatty Bolger
makes it?

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (11)
Elladan and/or Elrohir (9)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (4)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (9)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (8)
Saruman (10)

Like I said, we're low on elves.

Heal Gildor. Hurt Grima, hurt Gaffer. All the Gs!

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (11)
Elladan and/or Elrohir (9)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (5)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (9)
Gríma (9)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (8)
Saruman (10)

Even one Elf is one too many.

Double hurt Gildor, Heal Saruman

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (11)
Elladan and/or Elrohir (9)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (3)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (9)
Gríma (9)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (8)
Saruman (11)

Double hurt Dain, heal Gildor

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (11)
Elladan and/or Elrohir (9)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (4)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (9)
Gríma (9)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (8)
Saruman (11)

Double Hurt Denethor Heal Dain

It seems the mountain has some powerful allies indeed.

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (8)
Denethor (9)
Elladan and/or Elrohir (9)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (4)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (9)
Gríma (9)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (8)
Saruman (11)

Double hurt Nob, heal Elladan/Elrohir.

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (8)
Denethor (9)
Elladan and/or Elrohir (10)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (4)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (9)
Gríma (9)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (6)
Saruman (11)

Heal Gollum
Double hurt Elladan and Elrohir (how ironic)

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (8)
Denethor (9)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (4)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (9)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (6)
Saruman (11)

Heal Denethor
Double hurt Gildor

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (8)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (2)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (9)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (6)
Saruman (11)

Kill Gildor, Heal Dain

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Gildor (0) *screams*
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (9)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (6)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom

Hurt Nob and Hurt Gaffer

Heal Grima

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (7)
Gilraen (10)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (9)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (5)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom

Double Hurt Halbarad Heal G. Smeagol

Bergil (9)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (7)
Gilraen (10)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (11)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (5)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom

Double-hurt Gerbil,
Heal Halbarad.

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (7)
Gilraen (10)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (11)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (5)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom

Double hurt Elladan & Elrohir. Heal Gaffer.

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (6)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (11)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (5)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom

Hurt Bergil, hurt Elladan & Elrohir. Heal Denethor

Bergil (6)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (11)
Elladan and Elrohir (5)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (11)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (5)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom

Double hurt Caradhas Heal Bergil

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (8)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (11)
Elladan and Elrohir (5)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (8)
Gilraen (10)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (11)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (5)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom

One elf dead and two elves dying. Nassty elf-haterses.

Heal the Gaffer, hurt Dain and Gilraen.

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (8)
Dain II Ironfoot (8)
Denethor (11)
Elladan and Elrohir (5)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (11)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (5)
Saruman (11)

Double hurt Nob

Heal Dain

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (8)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (11)
Elladan and Elrohir (5)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (11)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (3)
Saruman (11)

Double hurt Denethor, heal the sons of Elrond.

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (8)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (9)
Elladan and Elrohir (6)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (11)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (3)
Saruman (11)

Hurt Nob,
Hurt Gollum,
Heal Caradhras.

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (9)
Elladan and Elrohir (6)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (2)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom

Kill Nob, heal Denethor


Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (6)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Nob (0) Oooohhhch... dies
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Double hurt Dain, heal Elladan and Elrohir

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (7)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (10)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Heal E&E, hurt Lobelia and Saruman.

Bergil (7)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (9)
Saruman (10)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Hurt Bergil Hurt Halbarad Heal Caradhras

Bergil (6)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (9)
Saruman (10)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Hurt Bergil and hurt Fatty

Heal Dain

Bergil (5)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (8)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (9)
Saruman (10)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Double-hurt Gerbil
Heal Halbarad.

Bergil (3)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (8)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (9)
Saruman (10)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Double hurt Dain, heal Bergil

Bergil (4)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (6)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (9)
Saruman (10)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Double hurt Bergil, heal Saruman

Bergil (2)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (6)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (9)
Saruman (11)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Double hurt Saruman, heal Faramir

Bergil (2)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (6)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (11)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (9)
Saruman (9)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Heal Bergil Double Hurt Saruman

Bergil (3)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhas the Cruel (10)
Dain II Ironfoot (6)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (11)
Fatty Bolger (8)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (9)
Saruman (7)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Heal Fatty, hurt Caradhras and Lobelia

Bergil (3)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (6)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (11)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (7)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Hurt Gerbil,
Hurt Faramir,
Heal Dain II Ironfoot.

Bergil (2)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (7)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis

Kill Bergil heal Saruman

(I smell fresh blood!)

Bergil (0)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (8)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (8)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis

Heal Dain II Ironfoot, double hurt Elladan and Elrohir.

Bergil (0)
Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (8)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (6)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (8)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (8)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis

Double hurt Halbarad - did Aragorn really need a standard?

Heal Dain

Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (9)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (6)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (6)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (8)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis

Heal Halbarad Double Hurt Caradhas

Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (7)
Dain II Ironfoot (9)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (6)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (8)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis

Double hurt Dain, heal Saruman

Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (7)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (6)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (9)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis

Double hurt El-boys, heal Saruman

Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (7)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (4)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (9)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (10)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis

Double hurt the Bolger brat, heal Elladan & Elrohir


Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (7)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (5)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (10)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (9)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (10)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis

Heal Faramir, hurt Saruman and Gilraen

Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (7)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (5)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (11)
Fatty Bolger (7)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (8)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (9)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis

Heal Faramir, double hurt Fatty Bolger

Bill the Pony (10)
Caradhras the Cruel (7)
Dain II Ironfoot (7)
Denethor (10)
Elladan and Elrohir (5)
Erkenbrand (10)
Faramir (12)
Fatty Bolger (5)
Gaffer Gamgee (9)
Gilraen (8)
Glorfindel (10)
Gollum (10)
Gríma (10)
Halbarad (7)
Imrahil (10)
Lobelia (8)
Saruman (9)

Gildor by Phantom
Nob by Gordis
Bergil by Gordis