Not Fairbairn.

Thanks, those answers made sense... :)

Is it the people of the bearded one?

My answer was Fingon - a white flame sprung up when he was killed by Gothmog.

is he first of the four?

It's not the Falathrim or Father of the Dragons.
(Thanks, NK for your answer)

is he first of the four?

It's not Fair Elves aka Vanyar.

Is it the first writing?

it's not Fall of the Noldor.

Is it the first writing?

I don't know. What's your answer?

Fall of Gondolin, written in 1915. Next letter! :D

Ah. Should have thought of that. :D

Next letter: N. So it's FAN so far.

Is it one that sounds as if it might have had one too many beers?

did its relative scare Frodo?

Paavo has it, it's Fang. (as for SPM's question, I'm glad I don't have to think about answering it :D )

Paavo, the thread is yours. :)

yey! :)
 

it starts with U

Is it the title that was given due to the person's actions?

it is not Umbardacil.

Is it the title that was given due to the person's actions?

it's not the usurper.

Is it the evil deceived?

It was the mountain, Fanuidhol, which translates as "Cloudy-head". :D

As for the current conundrum:

Does it allow passage?

it's not Uinen nor is it Umbar. I can't come up anything else for Saucepans question so if you have something else, please tell.

The Undeeps - sections of the Anduin shallow enough to be forded.

Next letter? :D

should have thought of that! :)

next letter is l, so Ul.

Is it the one who sent help to Turgon?

it's not Ulmo.

Is it a name for the evil ones in the fair speech?

not the Úlairi.

Is it the Black?

not Ulfang.

Is it one who was slain in the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?

not Uldor.

Is it Aldarion's friend?

it's not ulbar.

Is it one who was slain in the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?

not Ulwarth.

is it the other son of the Black?

neither is it ulfast. :p

oh come on. it can't be that hard! :p
it can be found from the Silmarillion.