Is it the horns of Ulmo? *crosses fingers*

crossing fingers really seems to work :)
 

that's the one. :) you are up.

Great, thanks! :D

Starts with a B

Is it a hobbit family?

it's not Baggins.

Did he prove that arguing really isn't good for your health?

It's not Boromir. :D

Did he prove that arguing really isn't good for your health? :p

Is it a dwarven place?

It's not Bilbo, nor is it Balin's tomb.

Did he and his two friends prove that arguing really isn't good for your health?

Oh! I think I finally know what you're looking for here: It's not Bert the troll.

Is it a dwarven place?

It's not the Bridge of Khazad-Dum.

is the name used by the fouls of the "tool" of the wise one? (even I don't understand that question :) )

Is it a dwarven place?

It's not Baraz.

Paavo, what's your answer?

the answer is Biter aka glamdring. it is the sword of Gandalf (the wise), and it is called biter by orcs (the foul). I admit that this was quite a vague question so you really don't need to give the next letter (unless if you want to, of course. :) )

No, it was a good question. Nothing wrong with being a bit cryptic. I understood your question, but I couldn't come up with the answer so it's only fair I give the next letter. It's I.
So it's BI so far.

is he kinder than what his name would suggest?

Is it the one who kicked his master?

Is it something that Hobbits avoid?

It's not Bill the Pony (for Paavo's and NK's question) and it's not Big Folk (for SPM's question).

Did he go on the Quest of Erebor?

Is it an adventurous one?

Not Bifur nor Bilbo.

Is it the faithful's son?

Is it the original Ringbearer?

Is it the original name of a nine-fingered hero?

It's not Bilbo Gardner, and it's not Bingo (I'm guessing Fingolfin and SPM had the same person in mind).

Is it a name of mockery given by the Fallen Wizard?

That's the one!:)
 

Yes, Fingolfin, it's Birdtamer!

Cheers,

Next letter is an F.

Is it one of the lost ones?

did he compensate his unjust deed?

It's not Fimbrethil or Feanor.

Is it steward of a realm of gift?

Was it the one who got what he deserved?

did he compensate his unjust deed?

It's not Faramir, Freca or Felarof.