Was it the one who unexpectedly got what he deserved?

Is it the wise?

Is it steward of a realm of gift?

It's not Ferny, Finrod or Fortinbras.

Is it the dark but friendly?

It isn't Fangorn Forest.

Is it the one torn in two?

Is it the nailed?

Once more.
 

Is it steward of a realm of gift? ;)

It isn't Fatty Bolger, Finduilas or Fairbarn(s).

Is it the one torn in two?

Is it the First of three?

It isn't Frodo or Fangorn.

Is it the First of three?

Lemme narrow this question a bit:
Is it the one who was torn in two, but left behind?

Is it the one who challenged?

It isn't Ferumbras I or Fingolfin.

Evisse, this is probably not the answer your looking for, but it's not the Faithful (of Numenor).

*throws away all rules of grammar for sake of "Is it . . . "*
 

Is it mentioned but once?

It's not Folco Boffin.

You're right, that wasn't the answer I was looking for. :p
Is it the one torn in two but left behind?

Is it mentioned but once?

Ok, well hopefully I've got it this time when I say it's not Finarfin.

Nil, it's not Fox, as in the fox who saw Frodo, Pippin and Sam in the Shire.

Is it the heirless?

Not Felagund.

Is it the Writer?

It's not Findegil :cool:.

Felagund is not heirless!
 

I'm here, ain't I? ;)

Is it the heirless?

Haha, ok then it's not Fili.

*evil laugh* you think you got rid of me didn'tcha?
 

Is it the one who was torn in two but left behind?

Is it the ones who were torn in two but kept going?

NightKnight, it's not the Followers (as in Men).

Evisse, finally I have no answer. Please tell me who/what you have in mind and I'll gladly yield the second letter :mad: :p.

Brave Fingolfin, you put up a brave fight...
 

It's Firiel. (from Firiel's song, who was tempted to go with the Elves, but at the same time remained 'Earth's daughter, so she was left behind)

OT: Saw Nightwish live for the 1st time, 19th of November. They rock, it was unbelievable! (sorry, I just had to say it, I'm saying it to everybody these days, no matter how off-topic it is :p )

Ah, Firiel, of course! No it's not her :D. So now we have FO.

Is it a title made for someone by his peer?

That's it Nil! It's Fool, the name given by Saruman to Radagast! I got it from Evisse's previous question :o.

Like WHOA, dude.
 

Erm, yeah.

Thanks, Fingolfin! (Must think nick for you . . . )

Meanwhile, I'm thinking E.

Is it a name given to the Last Chieftain of the Dunedain?

Is it a name given to the Last Chieftain of the Dunedain? Not Elessar.

Is it one of the free peoples?

Is it the Renewer?