Oui.
 

Sophia - 5
Lindo - 3.5
NK -1

And Sophia wins... but a 10th question anyway:

10. What is the Roll, and what is at the top?

The roll is the list of hobbits who participated in the Battle of Bywater. At the top are the names of the Captains, Meriadoc and Peregrin.

How the heck did I remember that without looking?

Sophia

Correct on both counts.

And the winner is Sophia. Take it away. :)

And the new topic is...
 

"Eliminated Characters", along with this goes characters whose roles in the Legendarium were greatly changed between their first appearance and their final form.

1. Name two roles of the character Erinti and who she later became.

Good Topic, tough question
 

She was the guardian of the stars and handmaided of Varda. I believe she changed her name to Ilmarë and then became Queen of Tol Eressëa?

I'll take that. ;) My favorite part of her history is that she was originally the daughter of Manwe and Varda.

Lindolirian- 1

2. This unconventional hobbit evolved into a character famed for his film filthiness.

Trotter -> Aragorn

Right you are.
 

However, I didn't expect that question to go so fast, so it will take me a minute to cook up the next one.

Lindolirian-1
Saucepan-1

Will edit in #3 as soon as I've finalized the wording. ;)

Sophia

#3
 

Who was the possible son of Balin and companion of Gloin, and who replaced him?

Thorin Oakenshield, and i beleive Dain Ironfoot replaced him as king under the mountain....

nope. Remember, we're looking for a character who didn't make it into the final story, at least under their original name.

Sophia

hintses?
 

I'm looking at Return of the Shadow. If you're that type, I could look in the Index and find something interesting...

been more then ten days...

New Topic: Weapons

1. What did Fingolfin bring with him when he rode againest Morgoth

Ringil and a cool shield studded with jewels.

close, but i need a couple more items/horse

Ok . . .
 

Nahar, Ringil, a blue shield studded with crystals, and mail overlaid with silver.

The horse's name was Rochallor. Nahar was Oromë's horse. :cool:

D'oh!
 

You know you haven't read the Legendarium in months if simplest things like this slip off your mind.

Right. I'm rereading them again.

theres also his helm but whatever...

Firefoot - .3
Nilp - .7

2. Name the weapons that Telchar made

Angrist and Narsil?

pretty much

Firefoot - 1.3
Nilp - .7

3. In the first Kinslaying, what were the two weapons used againest each other

Bows and swords?

be more specific please

The Noldor had swords while Teleri at Alqualondë had mostly bows (though I imagine they must have had some swords... you can't fight a battle of swords vs. bows).

Slender teleri Bows...

Firefoot - 2.3
Nilp - .7

4. How did Huor die(be specific)

Poked . . . I mean, pierced in the eye with a poisoned arrow, in the battle of the Fens of Serech, during the Nirnaeth.

Firefoot - 2.3
Nilp - 1.7

quite so

5. Describe the Orcs weaponary in the first age

Iron shields and great spears with broad blades?

Firefoot - 3.3
Nilp - 1.7

6. What did Theoden state about weapons during his Battle-Speech(movie question)

Firefoot - 3.3
Nilp - 2.7


7. What is the name of Legolas "Melee weapon(s)"

It's a long white knife.

really called 'White Swords"

Firefoot - 3.3
Nilp - 3.7


8. Name a weapon that people thought was useless(trick question!)

Where is this "white swords" reference found?
 

(In answer to your current question . . .)

The shards of Narsil?

nope, hint first age

The Take Over
 

My good friend Gil-Galad will be away for awhile and so he has asked me to take over in his abesence.

Which means I have the answer na, na :p

Then more hintses, praps.
 

Please??? :D :(

Hm, well it's slightly against my better judgment. How long have you guys been going at this one?

Answer this and I'll give you a hint.

Almost a week... can I second the call for a hint?

right i have returned


It is Elven Made