Sorry, I only realised now that I meant to right "brother of the Ring winner" as my second question.

Anárion. He was Isildors brother.

Sorry about that.

Weeellll, in this case I shouldn't be giving out the next letter. :D
(you got me really curious about this one, so I'm not sure if I can accept your apologies so easily :p )

Ok, the letter is still only A. Ask away!

Is it were Middle earth is?

Not Arda

Is it part of a command used by a great Elven-lord?

Evisse:
 

You already answered Anduin!

I demand a new answer for my question! :smokin:

Oh, no. Not the "I have my rights, too!" mode again.

Is it part of a command used by a great Elven-lord? Not Aiya

Sorry, Nil. :o
Is it a verbal body of water? Not Aelin

Is it part of a command used by a great Elven-lord?

Not aurë as in 'Utulie'n aurë!'

I really want this second letter........
 

Is it part of a command used by a great Elven-lord? ;)

Is it a name of a great greyness to the north?

Is it a verbal body of water?

Is it a verbal body of water? - (Gosh, I have no idea what you mean by this but I'll make one final try): Not Aelin-uial

Is it a name of a great greyness to the north? - Not Angband

Is it part of a command used by a great Elven-lord? - Not 'Ai' as in 'Ai na vedui, Dunadan...' Eh, that's probably not it. :p

Is it a name of a great greyness to the north?

Not Ash Mountains

sorry not that one.

Is it a name of a great greyness to the north?

First I gave up, then I realized I had one more:

Not Angmar.

:D

Sorry still not it.

Is it a name of a great greyness to the north?

*sigh*

I give up. Do tell. :D

YAY! Ok my answer was Aryador from The Lays of Beleriand, it's the name of Hithlum among men. We can use HoME right?

Good one! :)
 

Yes, I see no reason why HoME shouldn't be used...even for those of us who don't have it (like me), it's an opportunity to learn more.

Next letter is N.

Is it someone who was slain in the Battle of Sudden Flame?

Not Sauron in Mordor when his fingers were chopped off? O yeah it has to be with a N

Not Angrod.

@Finwe-89: Actually it has to be with AN, and only I may answer because I posed the original riddle, and the others have to ask me until they guess what I had in mind. Check the rules of the game on page 1. :)

Oh srry, I have read the rules, but now again, srry I read a part wrong, tnx that you told me

Is it the father of someone who was depressed?

Is it the second fairest?

Not Angrim, nor Andor (second fairest to Valinor)

again...
 

did he die an unexpected death?

Gil-Galad, what's your answer? :D

it is Anarion, after he unexpectly gets crushed by a stone thrown by a Mordor Catapult at the siege of barad Dur

But Anarion was already mentioned! See Hookbill's post, the first one on the page...So I thought it kind of redundant to say it wasn't him, but I figured it was obvious for everyone it wasn't him, or else I would have told Hookbill he's right.
Hmm, I think we need the opinion of a third party here. Someone with authority and wisdom. ;)
Should I give the next letter or not?

I'm authoritative and wisdom-izing!? Yes you should absolutely give the third letter. :p

Aw, look who I'm asking! You guys have all the reasons for me giving the next letter. :rolleyes: ;)
Alright, alright, I will.

Third letter: N

Is it a fabled city of the north?

Not Annuminas.

Is it the foster-father of the father of the Blessed?

Not Annael.

Is it someone who would have been great on Christmas day? :)

lol! Santa!
 

Not Annatar.