was aragorn the only one not in the battle of five armies... Blast not having the Hobbit anymore

Bard was the only one to not confront a dark lord?

Morsul, both Fingolfin and Fingon we're dead at that time, and had been dead for thousands of years. ;) And Perks, you're wrong too.

Bard was the only one not to get married?

Bard was only one not of long royal lineage

And how long was Fingolfin's royal lineage? ;) Both wrong! :p

hmm...a hint?

and heres a random and wrong guess

Bard is the only one who's name ends in D

Very wrong, yes. ;)

Perks' last guess was on the right track.

Aragorn only one to marry outside his race?

Nope.

bard didnt marry some of royal blood?

Nope. And congrats on 1000 posts. :)

Thank you....

Is it bard at all?

hmmm......BArd met Bilbo
Aragorn Met Frodo...
I doubt the other two met hobbits...

Bard is a title not his name?(I think that was his title I dont think it was his name) Must get the hobbit again too much information lost

Well, it has nothing to do with hobbits.

hint perhaps?

More hints? :p

What happened afterwards?

Aragorn was the only one to live a long life after his fighting climax?

well marriage was close...so If perky doesnt think Bard was married I'll say

Bard was the only one without children

Morsul, he did have children. And that is a BIG hint.

Fingon is odd out because his son (Gil-Galad) did not inherit his kingdom, but established his own. As did the others: Aragorn / Eldarion - Bard / Bain - Fingolfin / Fingon ... maybe?

That's probably what I intended, I don't remember. It was a year ago, and my memory isn't that good...

You go on.

OK here we go...


Hyarmendacil II
Goldwine
Turambar (King of Gondor)
Eomer
Calimehtar

Hyarmendacil because Hyarmendacil is an alias. his real name was Vinyarion.

Sorry no. It has nothing to do with names. Four of them has something in commen.

HINT: Its family related

Correct answer was: Everybody but Goldwine lost their father in battle... :cool:

Im going away for a week (to lovely Spain), and won't be back until next monday, so anybody can continue this thread :)

Yay for lovely Spain. I'll pick up the thread, then.

Beleg
Barahir
Boromir II
Isildur

Beleg was mighty, but no king !

(only Isildur was, the others was chieftans or a steward! This to could be an answer, but I think not) :)

Eep. Put the question on the wrong thread. Lo siento. So, new list:

Isildur
Gil-Galad
Aragorn
Aldor

Thats ok Hiriel
 

Gil-Galad is the only elven one !

(I know it is too simpel, but it was just to get us startet) :D

Simple? Yes. Right? No. Good try, though, Rune.

Aldor is the only one who is not a descendant from Finwë ?

That's it exactly. Your thread, Rune.

Fréaláf
Elessar (Aragorn)
Bard I
Fingon

it should not be that hard ;)

Fingon - the only one to succeed his father?

Thats what I was thinking about. all yours

Elendil
Valandil
Isildur
Meneldil

Three of the have something i common which the fourth lacks.

The 3 of them all have names that ends with dil ! ;)

or maybe(if I was to be a bit more serius)

Elendil
Valandil
Isildur

Was all born in Númenor.

The serious part of your answer is incorrect - but VERY close!

They all escaped from the destruction of Numenor?