Is it from Rohan?

Is it one of Merry's ponies?

Did it ever change owners?

Could it be Bill?

Is it from Rohan? Yes
Is it one of Merry's ponies? No
Did it ever change owners? Yes
Could it be Bill? No

Shadowfax?

Firefoot got it. :)

Okay, start asking!

Is it a person?

Is it a person? No

Can it be worn?
Was it used by hobbits?

Is it a place?

Is it an object?

Is it from the first age ? :smokin:

Is it an event?

Third Age?

Can it be worn? No
Was it used by hobbits? Yes
Is it a place? No
Is it an object? Yes
Is it from the first age ? No
Is it an event? No
Third Age? Yes

Can it be eaten?

Is it used for travelling?

Is it made of metal ? :smokin:

Is it a weapon?

Can it be eaten? No
Is it used for travelling? No
Is it made of metal ? No
Is it a weapon? No

Smokin'?
 

Is it used for smoking, or can it be smoked?

Is it organic?

Is it used for smoking, or can it be smoked? No
Is it organic? No

Is it a tool?
Did Frodo ever have it in his possesion?

Is it ...
 

... the earth given by Galadriel as a gift to Sam?

Wouldn't the mallorn seed contained within the box be organic though? ...Unless you are speaking strictly of the earth itself.

I'm going to venture a guess based on the rather limited criteria available... Is it the Red Book of Westmarch?

Is it a tool? No
Did Frodo ever have it in his possesion? No
... the earth given by Galadriel as a gift to Sam? No
Is it the Red Book of Westmarch? No

What it bequeathed upon a hobbit/the hobbits by someone not native to the Shire?

A plea for clarification ...
 

But that might be considered organic too, at least in origin.

So, to clarify, when you say that it's not organic, do you mean "not living" or "not organic in origin" (which would preclude materials such as wood, leather, textiles and paper)?

What it bequeathed upon a hobbit/the hobbits by someone not native to the Shire? No

And I mean not organic at all. Not living, and not organic in origin. I hope this clears things up. :)

Is it moveable?

Is it the Three-Farthing Stone?

Did any of the main hobbits in the story own it?

Is it waterproof ? :smokin:

Is it moveable? Yes
Is it the Three-Farthing Stone? No
Did any of the main hobbits in the story own it? No
Is it waterproof ? Yes

A note for clarification on the last two questions: before it is asked, I'm considering the main hobbits to be Merry, Pippin, Frodo, Sam, and Bilbo. And when I say it is waterproof, I mean it can't be harmed by water.

Is it or can it be lethal?
Was it a gift?

Was it used by any other race?

Is it or can it be lethal? It could be.
Was it a gift? No
Was it used by any other race? Yes