Oi, shut up you mangy insect! Jack loves me for who I am, and....erm, I mean that's a pile of rubbish. You imagine things, you crazy villain.

Admittedly true... but I can't really be said to have said anything more towards Nerwen or Nienna either. Scolding Sally for being suspicious of me is hardly the same as being unwilling to vote for her. At this stage in the game, it's much too late to keep someone around because they're fun.

If I have little to go on, I go on the little I have.

Well, I'm not faulting that, obviously--but if I see error, it's my duty to point it out, I rather think.

Well, now that that is out of the way, who do you suspect and why?

Actually, I'd like to have that question answered from everyone - it's possibly the last day and nobody but me seems to be playing with open cards. :rolleyes:

I suspect Sally. She has been the one acting most consistently suspicious all game. Earlier in the game I didn't think that she was guilty but now that we are down to so few and I don't think that a Nessa-wolf would be not around.

Okay... here's the village as I see it:

Formendacil--that's me--innocent.
Macalaure: presumably Innocent. Presumably because no one else has come out as being the other Shirriff and I think at this stage in the game there's no way a shirriff would let that slide (well, unless it's Nessa...). But no, seriously, I'm as certain as I can be of anything in this game that Mac is innocent.
Nerwen: Quite possibly evil of some sort. Insofar as I think Sally is the Cobbler, she's therefore a wolf.
Nessa: I also incline to think she's evil, but if she's the Cobbler, she's singularly the worst Cobbler I've seen. At this stage in the game, you'd think the Cobbler would want attention. So... a wolf.
Nienna: Less evil than Nerwen or Nessa, I'm not writing her off. If Sally's not the Cobbler, Nienna's my alternate for either Cobbler or Wolf--leaning towards Cobbler at the moment.
Sally: Cobbler. I'm not sure of it, but I'm rather implacably opinionated... but she's not a wolf. I think.

I think I'm tending back to thinking Nerwen is the cobbler. Of the other three, the current order would be:

Sally
Form
Nienna

*is exasperated*

Look! What is wrong with you all? Don't you see that at this point a wolf would want to be thought cobbler-ish? Would I have objected to that if I were a wolf? That's the last thing a wolf would do!

EDIT:X'd with Mac.

*buzzer*


Wrong. Thanks for playing, please try again.


EDIT: Whoops! Didn't see I x'd with Nerwen

++Form


?



Really, I'm not sure. It's driving me bonkers. :(

Unless you were a wolf who wanted us to think you were a cobbler who wasn't a wolf pretending to be the cobbler...

There's always another layer that can be put on that particular onion, and it gets dizzy trying to sort them out.

Quite frankly, the Cobbler this game baffles me completely... unless it's Nessa, in which case that's less her role than her lack of posts. With 6 people left alive, (3 baddies), the Cobbler could play a pivotal role--indeed, if it isn't Nessa, probably will, so it seems worth trying to figure out whom that would be.

That's a good point, actually. Although it is possible that a wolf would do it - for credibility.

Sally dear, that makes me very sad... but you should really highlight it if you want it to count--and then it's locked in, and--try to imagine--what if you've voted for the Cobbler? The Cobbler's death is just as bad today as an Ordo's.

It's not my vote, it's a proposal. And at this point making you sad isn't an issue. Sorry, my sweet savior from unsavory social situations.


Cobbler, eh? So that's what you're saying?

Why would an ordo say such a thing? :confused:

See? Now you see my dilemma!


Mac, you're the only person I trust. (And if you're lying I will END you.) I know you're fallible, but what are you thinking?

Right now, I'm changing my opinion every two minutes...

Also, if we do get a baddie toDay *crosses fingers* Mac will undoubtedly be the Night kill. In such a case, Mac dear, who do you have set up as pairings? (Aka if X is a wolf Y is also.) Again, I know you're not always right, but I trust your opinions more than people who may have fur or sharp nails.


EDIT: x'd with Mac. Heh, tell me about it. Also, did you already post what I just asked? I'll go check.

At the moment, my money is on Nienna and Form.

Oh, and if you're here, please to be saying so. I'd like to know who's around so someone doesn't just show up out of the blue and vote. Thanks.


Stolen from Wilwa's earlier post:

Sally --> Nessa
Nerwen --> Form
Form --> Nessa
--Sally --> Nessa

Nessa & Form 1

Left to vote
Sally (no retraction)
Mac (retraction available)
Nessa (retraction available)
Nienna (retraction available)

I'm here. Just as confused as the rest of you. I'm leaning toward Sally though for Fangs and Fur.

Okay. I'm not sure I agree about Nienna but I agree about Form.

He couldn't be double, nay, triple bluffing about being a cobbler, could he?

Hey, I'm right here! You don't need to talk about me like that! :p

I don't believe an ordo would. Unless he thinks Sally's a baddie and is trying to bluff, of course.

...So you're saying you're the Cobbler, Form?

Well, there's some kind of bluffing going on, definitely, but what?

I'm fairly sure I didn't say that. :smokin: And now I'm just being coy. :Merisu:

Exactly my point. He was almost blatantly manipulative of me yesterDay (not that I minded:Merisu:) and I'm not sure if it was cobblerism or wolfery.

I say he's a wolf pretending to be a cobbler pretending to be a wolf.


Does that make sense?

I'm not going to bother with Nessa.
I'm guessing Nerwen is not a wolf, though I could be wrong.
Sally is most involved, so I'm tending to not voting for her just out of appreciation.
Nienna's absence makes me sad.
I remember suspecting Form a lot, and I remember I only let go of him because there was too much suspicious support.

If Form and Nienna are indeed the wolves, then, heck, how close at their heels were we on the Day we foolishly lynched morm...

edit: cross-posted a lot

Fellas? Fellas? I resent that statement!

I'm sooo confused. I don't want to waste a very important lynch on someone who might be a wolf bluffing as a cobbler bluffing as a wolf... I want a real wolf!

But, Sally lovely my love, I'm not pretending to be a Wolf at all, or even being slightly coy about it.

At least acknowledge my affections!:D

What he said, minus the part about me obviously.

I'm so confused right now. Every time I think I know who people are I change my mind. :(

Self-vote! :p

Love you too, Formie too. *blows kiss* But....erm, yeah. You're gonna die either way. Even if you are the cobbler, the wolves are hardly going to keep you around. ;)

I would like us to win, thanks. And we can't win if we lynch me today. k thanks.

++Nienna

I remember her kind of anxiousness from when I was a wolf myself and the game was on the line for the last 10 minutes with the votes possibly going anywhere.

edit. bloody highlighting...

You hear that everyone?

Sally said she's going to eat me tonight!