Well I do like it, but... Kill Ringil. Heal Gurthang.

Black Arrow (10)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (11)
Gurthang (12)
Belthronding (5)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (7)
The Mithril-Shirt (5)
The Dragon Helm (12)
Ringil (0) *crushed by Morgoth*
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir

Hurt Mithril shirt and Belthronding, heal zee Dragon Helm

Black Arrow (10)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (11)
Gurthang (11)
Belthronding (4)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (7)
The Mithril-Shirt (4)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Ringil (2)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir

fixed

Eönwë, you didn't update with Agan's picks. I have added both yours and hers.

Double hurt Gurthang, heal Black Arrow

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (11)
Gurthang (8)
Belthronding (4)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (7)
The Mithril-Shirt (4)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir

Wow. I hadn't expected it to be so busy (what with the cross-posting) so early on.

edit: Oh, by the way Legate, Aganzir did the wrong thing to Gurthang so it should be:

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (11)
Gurthang (10)
Belthronding (4)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (7)
The Mithril-Shirt (4)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir

edit 2: x-ed again (Well, Agan posted after me... but...).

Whoops I made a mistake and accidentally removed a point from Gurthang instead of adding one. So the list should now be:

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (11)
Gurthang (10)
Belthronding (4)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (7)
The Mithril-Shirt (4)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir

Double hurt Anguirel Heal Gurthang

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (11)
Belthronding (4)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (7)
The Mithril-Shirt (4)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir

Agan seems to be sneaking ahead of me all the time...

Okay I seem to be tired or something... But I thought Eönwë's correction was an actual post & posted although it isn't yet my turn. So, removed my post. Sorry. :rolleyes:

Wait... wait... only 3 people have "hurt and heal"ed since your last "hurt and heal".

edit: ah, well Agan's changed it already.

Let's make this round you only have to wait for 3 instead of 4, let's get it moving along or let it die.

Okay, morm.

Double hurt mithril shirt, heal the Dragon-Helm

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (11)
Belthronding (4)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (7)
The Mithril-Shirt (2)
The Dragon Helm (14)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir

I think that's fair... So few people seem to be interested in weapons. Or then they're losing their interest in the game altogether. ;)

Heal Belthronding, double-hurt Orcrist.

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (11)
Belthronding (5)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (5)
The Mithril-Shirt (2)
The Dragon Helm (14)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir

Oops. The Mithril-Shirt shrank in the industrial washing machine. And yes, I know, I'm silly.

(Ahhhh, the joys of sniping.)


Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (11)
Belthronding (5)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (5)
The Dragon Helm (14)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally

Double Hurt Orcist. Heal Belthronding.

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (11)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (3)
The Dragon Helm (14)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally

Double hurt the Dragon Helm

Heal Gurthang

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (12)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (3)
The Dragon Helm (12)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally

Heal Dragon-Helm, hurt double hurt Orcrist

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (12)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
Orcrist (1)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally

Orcrist is no more. Thanks to Steve for the assist.

Oh, and heal me some Black Arrow. ;)

(I mean, I can go, right? If not tell me and of course I'll edit/delete my post. Anyway....)


Black Arrow (12)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (12)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Is it just me or have I assisted both of your kills?

*checks*

Yup, you sure have. Now I remember why we keep you around. :p

WOLF! WOLF! Oh, wait, wrong thread.... :rolleyes: :p

Heh, heh, heh. You've caught me. Blast, and I was doing so well....


*runs away before the chat skwerls can attack her*

How nasty, to destroy the Orcrist. It was cool, mainly because it was Elvish and at the same time wielded by Thorin.

Heal Black Arrow, double hurt Gurthang.

Black Arrow (13)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (10)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Really all it is, is an arrow. It's not even the bow...

Double hurt Black Arrow Heal Gurthang

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (11)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

That is a very good point

Ditto to morm's


Black Arrow (9)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (12)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Heal Black Arrow. Double Hurt Gurthang.


Black Arrow (10)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (9)
Gurthang (10)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

But ultimately, it is what killed Smaug.

Heal Black Arrow, hurt Anguirel

Black Arrow (12)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (10)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

And that is actually what is cool about it as well.

Heal Black Arrow, double hurt Gurthang.

Black Arrow (13)
Aeglos (12)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (8)
Belthronding (6)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Heal Belthronding, double-hurt Aeglos.

By the way, has anyone ever done anything to Dramborleg? It always seems to have 10 points.

Black Arrow (13)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (8)
Belthronding (7)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

But really any arrow would have worked. There is nothing really special about it. Gurthang was the weapon that slew Glaurung, a much more powerful dragon. So if that is what you base the like of the Black Arrow on perhaps you like Gurthang even more...

Double hurt Black Arrow Heal Gurthang

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (9)
Belthronding (7)
Thorin's Oakenshield (9)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Lucky me, exactly four posts in between this one and my last one.

Heal Black Arrow. Double hurt Thorin Oakenshield.


Black Arrow (12)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (9)
Belthronding (7)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (10)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

I'm almost tempted to leave it alone and see how long it stays that way....nah.


Double hurt it, and heal the Black Arrow.


Black Arrow (13)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (9)
Belthronding (7)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (8)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Hurt the Black Arrows and Dragon helm

Heal Gurthang

Black Arrow (12)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (10)
Belthronding (7)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (12)
Dramborleg (8)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Double hurt Black Arrow Heal Dragon Helm

Black Arrow (10)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (10)
Belthronding (7)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (8)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Double-hurt the Black Arrow, heal Belthronding.

Black Arrow (8)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (10)
Belthronding (8)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (8)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Heal Black Arrow, double hurt Gurthang.

Black Arrow (9)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (8)
Belthronding (8)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (8)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Same as my last turn. (Aka double hurt Dramborleg and heal the Black Arrow. You know, I'm going to laugh if I end up destroying it and am the only person who's ever done anything to it. Just saying.)

Black Arrow (10)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (8)
Belthronding (8)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (6)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

P.s.
 

But Glaurung was no way cooler than Smaug, he was rather pituful - he was a mere crawling worm. Thus, he was also slain in a rather simpler way. You needed a weapon to bring down a flying dragon to kill Smaug. And lo, behold, here you have the Black Arrow, which was NOT like any other arrow, it came down from the forges of the King under the Mountain, what more, Bard always managed to find it when he used it. That said, its owner was also far cooler guy than that of Gurthang's.

Heal Black Arrow. Double Hurt Dramborleg.

Black Arrow (11)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (8)
Belthronding (8)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (4)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally

Fine Hakon. Ruin my fun. ;)

Double hurt black arrow

Heal Gurthang

Black Arrow (9)
Aeglos (10)
Anguirel (7)
Gurthang (9)
Belthronding (8)
Thorin's Oakenshield (7)
Angrist (11)
The Dragon Helm (13)
Dramborleg (4)

The Broken Items:
Sting by Mnemosyne
Anduril by Wilwarin
Grond 2.0 by Mnemosyne
Aranrúth by Aganzir
Grond the I. by Legate
Glamdring by Mormegil
Morgul Blades by Boro
The Barrow Blades by Mnemosyne
Ringil by Aganzir
The Mithril-Shirt by Sally
Orcrist by Sally