Fingon and Maedhros?

Nope. Fingon and Maedhros are both Noldor.

Fingolfin and Ingwë?

Finwe and Elwe?

NightKnight has it.

Name one elf that has been reborn (not Glorfindel).

Luthien

Finrod atarinya.

Atarinya? What is that? But it was your dear father that I had in mind, so please carry on.

Luthien, you never really died. You just walked away to Mandos and then went back.

Atarinya:
 

Atar, father + inya, possessive pronoun of second degree.

In short, it means "my father".

Anywhen, which of the Eldar had his own land named after him?

Lorien?

Wrong.
 

Eldar, Morsul. :p

just wanted to be wrong in another thread for a change cryptic clues is annoying me ;)

oh eldar why didn't you say so? :)

umm...dont know then

Amroth --> Cerin Amroth?

Maedhros?

No hits.
 

Hint: First Age.

Maglor- Maglor's Gap?

Crap!
 

I didn't know there were two answers. I was thinking of Caranthir.

*sigh* Very well, Fingolfin II.

Cheers,

Name 35 Elven princes/princesses who were born before Elrond/Elros.

(A prince can include people who later became High Kings- e.g. Gil-galad, or Fingolfin- so you couldn't have anyone like Finwe, because he was a King, not a prince).

Have fun ;).

Wow...fun question. :p

Feanor, Fingolfin, Finarfin, Earwen, Maedhros, Maglor, Celegorm, Curufin, Caranthir, Amrod, Amras, Fingon, Gil-Galad, Turgon, Idril, Earendil, Aredhel, Maeglin, Finrod, Orodreth, Finduilas, Angrod, Aegnor, Galadriel, Luthien, Dior, Galathil, Galadhon, Nimloth, Celeborn, Elwing, Denethor, Legolas, Elured, Elurin.

I'm not quite sure about Legolas, but those are all I could come up with. 35! :p

Wow, all 35!
 

I didn't even think of Denethor or Legolas- I had Gelmir and Gwindor. But your way is better. You're up :).

Ah, forgot those. But they weren't royalty, that's why. ;)

Who were Luthien's cousins?

Cousins? With an S?

The only first cousin is Eärwen, but maybe you mean Galadriel, Aegnor, Angrod, Orodreth, and Finrod?

She had more than one first cousin. And no, I'm not counting Finrod &co.

Earwen and Galadhon?

Still not it.

Do you also mean to include first cousins through marriage? THen, Belegund, Baragund, Bereth, Earwen and Galadhon?

Nope, not through marriage.

Too tough! Too tough!
 

Give us the answer, Master NightKnight, and have for us a new question!

I'm confused. To me it seems that Luthien had the answer, I must have been distracted. That's the only reasonable answer I can find. So Luthien should ask a new question.

Whoop--a cheer for luthien. (oops, just a bit vainglorious, to be leading a cheer for one's self :rolleyes: )

The "most infamous" of all treachery was caused by 'what' in which elf.

(Hope I worded this question so that it makes sense :confused: )

Maeglin's desire for Idril?

That is one-half of the answer ;)

anyone want a clue?

His desire for Idril and his hatred for Tuor (which made it easier for him to concede to Morgoth's demands)?

perfect answer! your go, firefoot

*bump*
 

Firefoot?

Huh? Oh...
 

What events did Galadriel refuse to tell Melian about?

the gory details of
 

the Kinslaying?

Partial credit
 

And....