Being subtle doens't do any thing face to face with obvious ;) It's ok. To quote myself man? Yes

king?

King? No...well that just got rid of about 60 people ;)

Steward?

Steward? Nope. Let's remove around 20 more people from the list ;)

Warrior?

Warrior? Yes...let's remove some odd dozens of people ;)

i might actually change to Trogdor avvies


Rohirrim?

Is he in LotR?

Gondorian?

Re: confirmation: Yes, technically it was Perky's turn to go, since he guessed the exact answer.

Did he die in battle?

Trogdor is good too!

Rohirrim? no
Is he in LotR? yes
Gondorian? yes
Did he die in Battle? yes

That narrows it down. Let's remove the tons of rohirrim, characters mentioned in every book that isn't LotR, men of dale, and those living. That's a good help :D

Did he Die by Minas Tirith?



Damrod?

Did he die by Minas Tirith? Yes

Damrod? No

That really narrows it down.

Was he born in Minas Tirith?

Halbered?


or perhaps the last king of Gondor before Aragorn came?

Three questions at once? We're getting desperate, aren't we!

Born in Minas Tirith? Unknown

Halbered? No

or perhaps the last king of Gondor before Aragorn came? Well since I said it wasn't a king, I'm gonna have to say no on that one :D

Did he Serve Gondor?

Forlong?

If not, did he come from outside of Minas Tirith?

Did he serve Gondor? Yes
Forlong? No
If not, did he come from outside Minas Tirith? Yes


That really narrows it down :D


And BTW Firefoot, congrats on 2,000 posts!

Hirluin?

Thanks. :)

Hirluin Yup

Good Job! Your go!

Where's Firefoot?

What's the rush. Firefoot has up to ten days!


Anyways, living?

Sheesh, I don't live here.

Anyways, living? No

Or do you :eek: Place?

Place? Yes

Well, technically none of us are living here :rolleyes: ;)...

Halls of Mandos?

barrowdowns?


man i wanted to go...

Did it exist after the First Age?

Is it in ME?

is it in the south?

Is it in Valinor?

Halls of Mandos? No
barrowdowns? No
Did it exist after the First Age? Yes
Is it in ME? Yes
is it in the south? I'd say so
Is it in Valinor? No

Mordor?

Is it the Dwimmorberg?

Is it a country? Is it a city?

Mordor? No
Is it the Dwimmorberg? No
Is it a country? No
Is it a city? No

Is it in a city?

DO people Visit it?

Is it a forest?