Hurt Sam, heal Boromir

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Nothing against him, but Hama is just too minor a character (both he and Gamling are a bit out of place in this company) and so:

Hurt Hama, Heal Aragorn

Aragorn(16)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(15)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Oh no, somebody already noticed...

But hey, I think they are both quite cool. They are certainly not out of place! Or, they are, but that's exactly what's so interesting about it!

The whiny Frodo in the movie just makes the humiliation of him being killed almost soonest even more insulting. You have to admit - Sauron himself in the movie isn't all that wonderful.

Hurt Sauron, Heal Sam.

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(15)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (17)
Sauron(9)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Cross-posted with Mormegil
so redone below.

Hurt Boromir, Heal Sam.

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(14)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (18)
Sauron(8)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Crossed with Tuor, numbers corrected.

Folwren makes a good point.
But movie Boromir was cool. :cool:

Redone post because of cross-posting. Hope no errors
were made. Sauron fans might want to check.

Hurt Sauron Heal Boromir
Aragorn(15)
Boromir(15)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (18)
Sauron(7)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Hurt Sam, heal Gamling

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(16)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (17)
Sauron(7)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Hurt Sam, Heal Sauron

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(16)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (16)
Sauron(8)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Hurt Gamling (I like Hama), heal zen master.

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (16)
Sauron(8)
Tom Bombadil (13)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Heal Sauron, hurt Hama (I like Gamling better)

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(15)
Samwise Gamgee (16)
Sauron(9)
Tom Bombadil (13)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Hurt Sam, heal Háma (one of my favourites both in book and movie!)


Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(9)
Tom Bombadil (13)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Hurt Chief Warg, heal Gamling (I like him. He is an interesting fella.)

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(10)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(16)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(9)
Tom Bombadil (13)
Witch-King(6)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Heal Witch-King, Hurt Bombadil

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(10)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(16)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(9)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(7)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Okay. There has been some devastation since I last visited. Now let's increase the threat level of those super-goodies just to be sporty - now who's worth 16 points?

Hurt Gamling (nice as he is), heal the Witch-King

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(10)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(11)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(9)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(8)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

With all respect, sir, I think your vote did little than... nothing :D I think it was, hmm, just prolonging the situation, you know.

And by the way, the number of "average" points has already lifted itself - of course, as we go on and more characters drop out, the points are going to accumulate. Nowadays, some 15 or 16 points is "average", soon, 20 will be average and so on...

I'm really starting to think making the hurting give double the effect would make this game more interesting...

Heal Sauron, hurt Fingolfin

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(10)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(8)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

We could allot two hurt votes and one heal or give the option to give two heals or two hurts. What do you all think?


Hurt Boromir Heal Chief Warg

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(15)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(8)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Okay, let's run for it.

Hurt Bombadil, heal Háma

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(15)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (11)
Witch-King(8)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

EDIT: x-ed with Morm. Fixed.

Hurt Boromir, heal Tom Bombadil

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(15)
The Chief Warg(10)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(16)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (13)
Witch-King(8)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

I think it sounds like a good idea to give the possibility to choose either two hurts or two heals. :)

Eönwë, your numbers don't make sense... :confused:

Posting the proper version how it should be including Eönwë's votes:

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(14)
The Chief Warg(11)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(8)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae


And now what's that!!!

Like, what? That you just hurt or just heal? Or that you hurt for 1 and heal for 2 or vice versa? But if it's the latter and people could choose, it will be still the same - people will be equalising it as well.

Ah, I see. I cross-posted with Legate.

And also with Morm. Never mind that, I wrote the fixed list above.

Hurt the warg, heal Boromir

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(15)
The Chief Warg(10)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (12)
Witch-King(8)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Ah, it appears so. Thank you.

So what was the decision now? Two hurts and one heal? And how to make sure everyone - fex. someone coming up here later, like two days from now - will realise the change?

Should it be declared loud and clear?

PS. I see at least Lommy's last one is only 1+1 in comparison with Legate's "corrected version"...

Bah, forgot the beef...

Yes, we need to get some more damage done or otherwise this will become boring indeed.

Maybe we can always say "two hurts Noggie, one heal Lommy" or such. ;)

How about only Phantom gets to do the 2 hurt, 1 heal thing.

Perhaps later more people get to do it- if nominated by me, perhaps?

Objections?

Nah, I think we should just wait with it now, we certainly cannot change the rules like that all of a sudden. More people would have to agree on that, at least, or the one who started the thread coming and making it a rule.

Hurt Bombadil, Heal Witch-King

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(15)
The Chief Warg(10)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (11)
Witch-King(9)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Hurt Chief Warg, heal Éowyn

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(15)
The Chief Warg(9)
Eowyn(17)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (11)
Witch-King(9)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Hurt the Chief Warg, Heal Boromir

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(8)
Eowyn(17)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (11)
Witch-King(9)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae



Don't we just need to find a way to increase the hurting powers with time, so that it doesn't end up uninteresting when three in their 50s compete? I think hurt 2, heal 1 is a good idea, maybe once the field is down to 10.

Hurt Eowyn, Heal Warg. :p

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(9)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(15)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee (15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil (11)
Witch-King(9)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae


Edit: 3 times now! *goes insane* Have edited points.

Hurt warg, heal Gimli :p

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(8)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(16)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee(15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil(11)
Witch-King(9)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Hurt Eowyn, Heal Warg.

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(9)
Eowyn(15)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(16)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee(15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil(11)
Witch-King(9)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

Crossed with Lommy..numbers corrected

Hurt Chief Warg, heal Éowyn, I said!!

Aragorn(15)
Boromir(16)
The Chief Warg(8)
Eowyn(16)
Fingolfin(10)
Gimli(16)
Gamling(15)
Hama(17)
Samwise Gamgee(15)
Sauron(10)
Tom Bombadil(11)
Witch-King(9)

Eliminated:
Haldir by mormegil
Frodo by Legate of Amon Lanc
Gothmog (non-balrog) by Oddwen
Gothmog(Balrog) by Rikae

EDIT: Err. Once again x-ed with Morm. Fixed... but Morm, your counting was also wrong there.

How about in 24 hours from now we begin three votes maximum. You can double hurt somebody or hurt two distinct individuals. Only 1 heal per turn. The 24 hours will give a chance to hear from Bibidi to see what he thinks. I wonder how quick that will make the game end. Of course once this one ends there are so many characters that could be used we could start a new one easy enough.