Freedom? Gollum got caught (by Faramir & co.) when he tried to catch fish, Frodo by Shelob when he tried to "catch" freedom.

Uh, no, you're looking too hard. Your first guess was much closer.

Stewed rabbit?

No again.
 

hint: they're extensively mentioned in the chapter currently discussed in the reading room. ;)

Mushrooms!

Yep! :)

Frodo is to Lothlórien

as

Aragorn is to ____________

Rivendell

Nope.

Alqualonde?

No.

Minas Tirith?

Lothlorien also?

Neither.

Anybody?

Big hint: it has to do with someone they both saw for the first time there.

Cerin Amroth. Aragorn never came there again, and I believe that somewhere it says that Frodo never came again to Lorien.

Nope.

Is it the Argonath?

No.

Is it Celeborn?

No.

Incredibly Wild Guess... Is it Galadriel?

Nope.

The place that is the answer is no where in Lothlórien.

Bree?

Nope.

Is it Isengard? Or maybe Saruman?
:confused:

Neither. The answer is a place.

the dead marshes? they both saw Gollum for the first time.

Correctomundo, paavo!

yey! :)
 

ok, an easy one.

Pippin's son is to Faramir
as
Frodo is to ___________

Frodo Gardener, Sam's son?

yes, indeed.

Turgon is to Gandalf

as

Elendil is to ________.

Aragorn?

Yes!

ten day rule! :p

Lorien is to Gimli
as ______ is to Eomer.

Minas Tirith?

that's the one.

Sam is to Bag End

as

Barliman Butterbur is to ________

The Prancing Pony?