Er ...!
 

I'll come back to this when I have my books to hand. :rolleyes:

Take your time, Saucepan! We're not going anywhere :rolleyes:

OK, I'm back ...
 

It's not Master Samwise.


It's not Mamandil.


It's not a Master of Spirits.


Hmm, there are a number of names that I could give, but they would all be guesses. So I'm going to have to call you again, paavo. What's your answer?


It's not Maglor's Gap.

Is it the creator of a race?

my answer is Master aka Tom bombadil.

"No one has ever caught old Tom walking in the forest, wading in the water, leaping on the hill-tops under light and shadow. He has no fear. Tom Bombadil is master."
from "in the house of Tom bombadil"

Well done, paavo. You have forcibly extracted the next letter from me. :D

It is 'R'.

Fingolfin II, it's up to you whether you want to put your question again.

my pleasure. :D

is it highest of the three?

Is he called the faithful?

is it the end of this phrase Eriol the ________?

Is it the founder?

And the game goes on ...
 

It's not the Marshall of the East-Mark.


It's not Mardil (although I have given him as an answer earlier so, if you have a different one, I'll concede the next letter).


It's not Mariner.


It's not Marcho.

Is it the name of their land?

is it marigold?

My bad, I guess I didn't look over the thread carefully enough.

Is it the leader of the Northmen after the Battle of the Plains?

Running out of "mar-"s here ...
 

Well, that's pretty vague, so I'll just say it's not the March of Maedhros. :p


It's not Marigold, no.


It's not Marwhini.

Is it a region in the Shire?

Is it another name for Rohan?

And the winner is ...
 

... for persistent questioning beyond the call of duty ...

... Firefoot!

Yes, it's the Marish. Well done! :)

Beat me again :o Well played Firefoot, well played ;)

Thank you, thank you.

Starts with an E.

Is it a helpful individual if you need some r and r?

Honestly, I don't know what r and r is so I have no idea...

is it where theoden's hall is?

r and r= rest and recreation
military leave, a vacation, etc. epecially when needed to recuperate.

In that case, it is not Estë, and it is not Edoras.

Is it a mariner who learned of the valar in the book of lost tales?

It's not Eriol.

is it theoden's sister-son?

It's not Éomer.

is it eomer's sister?

It's not Éowyn.

is it a half elf that lives at rivendell?

Is it the one who killed the dragon?

Is it a mountain range?

It is not Elrond, Eärendil, or Ered Luin.

is it another name for Aragorn?

Is it the twin?

Is it a gift?

It is not Estel, Elrohir, or the Elessar.

Is it one of the three?