Side cushion, side cushion, corner pocket.
 

And The Saucepan Man pockets the nine ball!

Nil . . .

Errr . . . I mean gets the answer. And he gets the thread with it.

Forgive him. Three numbing months of watching nothing but pool made him that way.

Steve Davis could play Gandy.

Sh.

Well done, SPM! :)
 

So... Is it living?

Third Age?

OK, I thought of one. Ask away ...

... oh, you have already! :rolleyes:

So... Is it living? Yes
Third Age? Yes

Elf?

*pulls out sword and shield for when Nilpaurion Felagund comes by*
 

Is it male?

So... Is it living? Yes
Third Age? Yes

Elf? No
Is it male? Yes

Dwarf?

Hobbit?

man?

So... Is it living? Yes
Third Age? Yes
Elf? No
Is it male? Yes

Dwarf? No
Hobbit? No
man? Yes

From Gondor?

Third Age? Yes
Is it male? Yes
man? Yes

From Gondor? No

From Rohan?

Good?

Third Age? Yes
Is it male? Yes
man? Yes
From Gondor? No

From Rohan? No
Good? Define Good ;)

As in not working for Sauron, and fighting aganest sauron's forces if near

On the basis of that definition:

Good? Yes

Lives or lived in Rhovanion at the time of the War of the Ring?

*throws an early shot*
 

Beorn?

Alive during the Great Years?

From Bree?

Third Age? Yes
Is it male? Yes
man? Yes
From Gondor? No
From Rohan? No
Good? Yes (see posts 2937 and 2938)

Lives or lived in Rhovanion at the time of the War of the Ring? Does your question assume that he was alive at the time of the War of the Ring? If so, unknown but doubtful.
Beorn? No
Alive during the Great Years? Remind me - when were the Great Years?
From Bree? No

I think the Great Years are 3018 and the next few in which Quest of the Ring took place. And since it's unknown if this person was alive during the WotR I'm guessing the answer is no.

From Eriador?

Yes, alive at the time during the WOTR

if not


Is it a Dwarf?

Thanks, Lindol. I have answered the question on that basis below.

Third Age? Yes
Is it male? Yes
man? Yes
From Gondor? No
From Rohan? No
Good? Yes (see posts 2937 and 2938)
Lives or lived in Rhovanion at the time of the War of the Ring? Unknown but doubtful.
Beorn? No
Alive during the Great Years? Unknown but doubtful
From Bree? No

From Eriador? No
Is it a Dwarf? No - see above

sorry about that....


Man of Dale?

Third Age? Yes
Is it male? Yes
man? Yes
From Gondor? No
From Rohan? No
Good? Yes (see posts 2937 and 2938)
Lives or lived in Rhovanion at the time of the War of the Ring? Unknown but doubtful.
Beorn? No
Alive during the Great Years? Unknown but doubtful
From Bree? No
From Eriador? No

Man of Dale? No

Is he mentioned in 'The Hobbit'?

Third Age? Yes
Is it male? Yes
man? Yes
From Gondor? No
From Rohan? No
Good? Yes (see posts 2937 and 2938)
Lives or lived in Rhovanion at the time of the War of the Ring? Unknown but doubtful.
Beorn? No
Alive during the Great Years? Unknown but doubtful
From Bree? No
From Eriador? No
Man of Dale? No

Is he mentioned in 'The Hobbit'? Yes

(Getting very warm now.)

Is it "the Master who ruled them" who couldn't say how Gollum came by the Ring?

Does he have a specific name?

Third Age? Yes
Is it male? Yes
man? Yes
From Gondor? No
From Rohan? No
Good? Yes (see posts 2937 and 2938)
Lives or lived in Rhovanion at the time of the War of the Ring? Unknown but doubtful.
Beorn? No
Alive during the Great Years? Unknown but doubtful
From Bree? No
From Eriador? No
Man of Dale? No
Is he mentioned in 'The Hobbit'? Yes

Is it "the Master who ruled them" who couldn't say how Gollum came by the Ring? Not that I'm aware of
Does he have a specific name? Nope

The Master of Lake Town?

Does he live in Lake town??

We have a winner!
 

Does he live in Lake town?? He does indeed

But I am afraid that Firefoot had already given the correct answer. It is indeed the Master of Lake-Town.

So take it away Firefoot ... :)

Pre-empting . . .
 

First Age? :cool:

Evil at Heart?

Thanks, Saucepan.
 

First Age? No
Evil at Heart? No

Living?

Living? No