Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?

Did it involve Maedhros?

Was there any violence involved?

Did it involve Sindar?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

After Feanor's death?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

Did it happen after the ships were burned?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

?21 Did it happen after the ships were burned?
It's not entirely clear, but I believe the answer is no, although at
essentially the same time.

Involve a Son of Feanor and another Noldor? not nessercerilly Follower of Feanor

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

?21 Did it happen after the ships were burned?
It's not entirely clear, but I believe the answer is no, although at
essentially the same time.

?22 Involve a Son of Feanor and another Noldor? not nessercerilly Follower of Feanor
No, with an explanation. The event certainly included sons of Feanor and other
Noldor among those involved, but all involved were clearly followers of Feanor.

A Secludued meeting? or met with full arms?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

?21 Did it happen after the ships were burned?
It's not entirely clear, but I believe the answer is no, although at
essentially the same time.

?22 Involve a Son of Feanor and another Noldor? not nessercerilly Follower of Feanor
No, with an explanation. The event certainly included sons of Feanor and other
Noldor among those involved, but all involved were clearly followers of Feanor.

?23 A Secluded meeting? No
or met with full arms? Yes, those involved were armed at the time but
armor wasn't used actively at the event.

Maedhros turning away from the burning of the ships?

Was it when Maedhros asked Fëanor regarding those left behind?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

?21 Did it happen after the ships were burned?
It's not entirely clear, but I believe the answer is no, although at
essentially the same time.

?22 Involve a Son of Feanor and another Noldor? not nessercerilly Follower of Feanor
No, with an explanation. The event certainly included sons of Feanor and other
Noldor among those involved, but all involved were clearly followers of Feanor.

?23 A Secluded meeting? No
or met with full arms? Yes, those involved were armed at the time but
armor wasn't used actively at the event.

?24 Maedhros turning away from the burning of the ships?
Nuh-uh.

?25 Was it when Maedhros asked Fëanor regarding those left behind?
Wrong.

Hint: It's not related to the burning of the ships.

They looked up and saw the moon rising for the first time?

?1 First Age?
Yes.

?2 Unique?
Ah...Yes.

?3 Third Age?
Nein.

?4 Living?
Well...Nyet.

?5 Is it an object?
Hmm...Nope.

?6 A place?
No way, Jose. Although it takes place in a place.

?7 An event.
Yes.

?8 Happen in Valinor?
Nay.

?9 Is it a battle?
Nag. (Welsh)

?10 Does it involve men?
Ochi [no] (Greek)

?11 Involve one (or more) of the Noldor?
Yes.

?12 Did it involve one (or more) of the sons of Fëanor?
Yes. It included one (or more) of them.

?13 Did it happen before the rising of the Sun?
Yes.

?14 Did it involve Maedhros?
Yes, it included him.

?15 Was there any violence involved?
Non.

?16 Did it involve Sindar?
Hapana [no] (Swahili)

?17 Did it happen before the Nirnaeth Arnoediad?
Yes. (See ?13 above).

?18 Was it the taking of the Oath of Feanor?
Tisn't.

?19 When Fëanor and his following slipped away on the Teleri's ships, leaving Fingolfin et al. behind?
Incorrect.

?20 After Feanor's death?
Good question. But the specific answer to it is the obverse of yes.

?21 Did it happen after the ships were burned?
It's not entirely clear, but I believe the answer is no, although at
essentially the same time.

?22 Involve a Son of Feanor and another Noldor? not nessercerilly Follower of Feanor
No, with an explanation. The event certainly included sons of Feanor and other
Noldor among those involved, but all involved were clearly followers of Feanor.

?23 A Secluded meeting? No
or met with full arms? Yes, those involved were armed at the time but
armor wasn't used actively at the event.

?24 Maedhros turning away from the burning of the ships?
Nuh-uh.

?25 Was it when Maedhros asked Fëanor regarding those left behind?
Wrong.

?26 They looked up and saw the moon rising for the first time?
Ooh. Wish I had thought of that. But.......that's not it.

Perhaps a hint is in order.

Yess, but must be a bit tricksy.

Well then, what about:

Is it in the Sil?

?27 Yes. Chapter 13.

The voices of the Noldor are echoed and multiplied by the hills in the Lammoth?

That's it!

Specifically:
Perhaps when the tumult was heard one of Morgoth's
lieutenants (Sauron?) turned to him and said
"They're ba---ack!" :eek:

Pre-empting.
 

Third Age?

Pre-Empting the Pre-empt
 

Living?

Event?

First Age?

Object?

Thanks, Tuor.
 

Object? No
Living? No
Event? No
First Age? No
Third Age? Yes

Idea?

A place?

Object? No
Living? No
Event? No
First Age? No
Third Age? Yes

Idea? No
Place? No

Story?
Song?

Statement?