Us too, I had just finished beating Mac at Settlers of Catan. ;)

Whoever they are, they should.

Sounds like a nice afternoon at home... :)

Don't get me wrong though. I think Melian is great. But she's a bit too good compared to Maedhros. Maedhros has an edge to him - a fault that makes him much more interesting as a character...

Afternoon and late night in different hemispheres, but yeah. Heheh...

I generally like the flawed characters too - and, for the record, didn't hurt Turin because of his tragic flaws, if you will, but because I just find him... creepy, somehow. (And this from a Grima fan...)

Any interest in a round 3?

Only in LOTR now ;)

That was my thought too.

Yay! The top three (or actually top four) are all my favourites and Maedhros might be my most favourite ever. Well played, everybody. :D ;)