If you draw a straight line through Helm's Deep (East to west) is it south of that line?

Is it Cirith Ungol? Or somewhere nearby? No and No
If you draw a straight line through Helm's Deep (North to South) is it east of that line? Yes
If you draw a straight line through Helm's Deep (East to west) is it south of that line? Yes

West of Black Gate...south of Edoras...east of Helms deep...north of Minas Tirith...hmmm...


Is it West of the Anduin?

Is it West of the Anduin? Yes

I'd like to comment something, though, on all of these 'straight line' questions. I'll use an example to explain:

Say my place is Bag-end and someone asks: "If you draw a straight east-west line through Hobbiton, is it south of that line?" I would say "No," because Bag-end is in Hobbiton and Hobbiton is not south of Hobbiton. Just because a place is "Not west" of someplace does not mean it is automatically east of it.

Just thought I'd clear that up.

Is it in Gondor?

Is it in Gondor? Yes

Is it visited alot?

Is it visited a lot? I suppose so

Is it Erech?

Is it Erech? No

Is it Lamedon?

Is it Lamedon? No

Is it some kind of settlement?

Is it some kind of settlement? Not really - but people do live there

Is it the place where the people of Minas Tirith were sent during WotR?

Is it the place where the people of Minas Tirith were sent during WotR? No

(You're getting closer, though.)

Is it Tarlang's Neck?

Is it Tarlang's Neck? No

More of those straight lines...
 

If you draw a straight line through Linhir (North-South) is it west of that line?

If you draw a straight line through Linhir (North-South) is it west of that line? No

Is it Lebennin?

Is it Lebennin? No

Lossarnach?

Lossarnach? No

The South Road?

The South Road? Nope

It can't be THIS simple. Can it?
 

The Pelennor Fields?

Afraid not.
 

The Pelennor Fields? No

Am I really the only person who hasn't given up on this?
 

The place Aragorn and the Dunedain landed the Black Ships at?

I hope not, but it seems so.
 

:(

The place Aragorn and the Dunedain landed the Black Ships at? No

Is it in the general vicinity of Minas Tirith?

Is it in the general vicinity of Minas Tirith? Yes

Is it somewhere inside Minas Tirith?

Is it somewhere inside Minas Tirith? Yes

Is it in the Citadel?

Is it in the Citadel? No

was it used during the seige of Minas Tirith in WOTR?

was it used during the seige of Minas Tirith in WOTR? Not exactly sure what you mean by ''used"... No

Is it the Houses of Healing?

Is it the Houses of Healing? No