Is it a forest?

is it probably the biggest living thing in ME? :)

EDIT: whops, forget that question, Perky ent probably has the same answer.

It is not Fangorn. :)

is it probably the most miserable from the four?

Is it a forest?

It is not Fredegar Bolger, and it is not Forest Under Night.

is it probably the most miserable from the four? :p

I had a feeling you would ask that again... and I have no idea.

Firefoot, which? Or are you stumped on both and need answers for both?

Just paavo's question. I gave another answer for your question two posts ago.

Ok, sorry about that! Anyways, is it a forest?

hehe...
 

my brilliant answer is of course... *drums* the Fourth age!

*groans* That was a clever question. So the next letter is I.

Perky, So if your forest starts with "Fi", then you can ask your question again...

is it the shortest of the four? (ok, this is probably not so difficult anymore :) )

Ok. Sorry. Anyways, Is it a forest?

wow, you sure do like forests, perky ent. :D

Well I am an ent, paavo ;)

It is not Firien Wood, and it is not the First Age.

Is that the Forest you wanted? ;)

Yes it was! Anyways, is it a son of Finwë?

Is it a son of Finwe who crossed the Helcaraxe? ;)

It's not Finarfin and...

Oh, Saucepan, you would figure it out, wouldn't you? Yes, it is Fingolfin.

D'oh! Beaten on a technicality. So, even if it's a right question, you can refuse it if there's another possibility? Ouch! That's makes it harder. Oh well, I'll just have to try harder!

Hehe. That was the intention ...
 

... although I nearly asked whether it was a son of Finwe who turned back. :eek: So it was a 50/50 chance. :D

OK. The next letter is 'M'.

Ask away ...

Is it also known as "Mornan"?

Phew, Firefoot, you don't make it easy!
 

You had me using Google there. Think I've got it.

No, it's not Morthond Vale.

Easy? Me? Nah. ;)

Does it have white horses?

Hmm ...
 

... it's not the Mearas.

Does it have white horses?

You're trying my patience now ...
 

How did I know that you were going to ask that again? ;)

It's not the Mark.

Let's try again...
 

Does it have white horses?

Is it a person of evil

is a a valor who was locked in chains but escaped?

Doh! Firefoot ...
 

... but I think that I'm on your wavelength now.

It's not Mouth (thinking of the riddle game).

Gil-Galad, it's not Mauhur.

And Morsul, it's not Morgoth.

is it a person named melkos?

No, it's not Melkor either. :D

Edit: I'm away 'til Sunday now. Keep asking away, but I won't be able to answer until then.

is it the land where baradur lies?

Is the the one who came back?

OK, I'll just answer those, then I'm off.

It's neither Mordor nor Mithrandir (the one of the Istari that we know returned to Aman).

Is it where they found the survivor?

is it no mine it is a tomb