alright lets take the next step Morgoth?

Nope. Morgoth it is not.

saruman? http://instagiber.net/smiliesdotcom/...kcrystalz3.gif

No, it's not Saruman! And by the way, what's with the legend of zelda guy? http://instagiber.net/smiliesdotcom/...nktriforce.gif

Well i just learned of the site with tons of smileys I was seeing if they actually work

is it the Witch King?

No, It's not http://instagiber.net/smiliesdotcom/...ink/linkan.gif

wow I'm so silly I think I found the answer

Balrog http://smilies.jeeptalk.org/contrib/.../FIREdevil.gif

You're close, but you still don't got it! http://instagiber.net/smiliesdotcom/.../mon/ganon.gif

Mouth of Sauron?
http://smilies.jeeptalk.org/contrib/ruinkai/GRIM2A.gif

No, I'm afraid not http://instagiber.net/smiliesdotcom/...n/stalfos2.gif

troll?

Gothmog, Lt of Minas Morgul...maybe even Gothmog lord of Balrogs

Gil-Galad got it. But, can you explain it?

umm which one is it? Gothmog Lt or Gothmog Lord?

You tell me! You got it right, so now tell me why!

this one here is for Gothmog LT


Faced the noble-Faced Gondorians
killed the rescuer-killed some of the Rohirrim
Killed the vain-killed his own kind
and retreated into darkness-was thought to be a dark Numernorean
guarded by stone
and weilded a dwarfs favor
My kin saved the light-Numenoreans were allies of the Elves and enemies of evil people
and retreated from it-Served Sauron
Killed by the one born twice more
I ruled with a firm grip-he was second in charge of hte attack on Minas Tirith

I've got two problems with that: 1, There's some gaps, and 2, the correct answer was Gothmog the Balrog. So, please explain the Gothmog the balrog!

rightio!

Faced the noble-Faced Feanor and others...
killed the rescuer-Killed Fingon who rescued Maedrhos? and probaly some others...
Killed the vain-Killed the Men of Dor-Lomin...
and retreated into darkness-Hid in Angband when Melkor was captured
guarded by stone-7o troll Guards that turn to stone at light
and weilded a dwarfs favor- being of fire...dwarfs good with fire?
My kin saved the light- he was a fallen Avari
and retreated from it- ran away when Valar came?
Killed by the one born twice more-killed by Echthelion
I ruled with a firm grip-He was Lord of the Balrogs...very powerful

You got it. But before I give it to you, just a few corrections. 1, when I said killed the vain, I was refering to Feanor. Then, he weilded an ax, which is a dwarf's favorite weapon. Finally, when I said my kin saved the light, I am refering to Balrogs saving Morgoth and the Simarils from Ungoliant. Sorry for the corrections, but I just wanted to get it all out. Anyways, its your turn!

meh close enough...


i'll get back to you on the next question

No rush. Take your time. The more thought out, the better!

Gil-galad, I'd say your time is up :D Give us the next one!

ha forgot about it...


two people that served the "god" not much is spoken about us though, just our names and our heritage

hmm... this seems again a bit too easy... :)
the blue wizards, Alatar and Pallando

well its not seeing how you got it wrong

This is probably a long shot, but.....Uldor and Ulfast?

Another long shot: Elladan and Elrohir?

close but no...i also wouldn't mind some explanations

Fingolfins guess was closer

Azog and Bolg?

Lol
 

hum how about Merry and Pippin *falls over laughing at her stupidity* :D

nope, hint they were mono-evil

Uh...gollum and Smeagol?

before them...

Isildur and Sauron?

Around there time...

is it too late to guess?
 

Herumor and Fuinur?

well you got it right, it was Herumor and Furinur, good job

I'll try
 

This is....a mediocre riddle
Victims of the potent wrath of the one who served
he who was once dear to the heart of Amân,
only one out of the same number as the elf-banes survived,
to bring hope to the lost quest of a man.
(BTW the circumflex thing above the a is meant to be there ).

second one is Elrond... i think