it is not Took

Dont know the answer to Gil-Galad's

Is it the name Beren gave to Luthien?

was it a man that lived in gondolin

don't know that one either here is a big hint

it isnt in the first or second age

and if i understand the rules

THI is the word so far

Is it the Lord of Doriath?

Is it a family of the men of bree?

it is not thingol nor is it...fine

THIR short game heh... I prefer to be on the guessing side :p

Is it the age between the second and fourth?

it is the third age

is it a man?

Um...Gil-Galad. I haven't given the letter yet, so I'm just gonna ignore that one.


The letter is....E!

Does it know all about runes?

Well, I don't think I know that one. And I think the rule is, if you can't guess it, you have to give the next letter.

So....El

is it a race?

is it a half-elf from rivendell?

It is not elves or Elrond

Is it an object?

It isn't elessar

Is it also known as Varda?

It isn't Elbereth

actually you have to wait for the asker to give the right answer before giving the next letter. since otherwise the asker could ask for the same answer with a slightly different question. I have edited this also in my first post.

ok, well, I'm pretty sure it doesn't matter, since I've already given the next letter, but now i know.

is it someone who could be mistaken for a member of the Rohirrim?

The one that I had in mind was Elrond.

Is it another name for a tall mountain?

is a brouche that Galadriel gave as a gift?

I thought that might have been it, but anyways....hmm. I'm stumped both ways. I can't get the mountain, unless you were going for Erebor, which I highly doubt. As for the mistaken Rohirrim, the only one I can think of is Eowyn, and that's not right. So, if you can, give me your answers, and we can get this over with.

Elerrina is another name for Taniquetil.

And unless you mean the phial of Earendil, then it's not Elfstone

my answer is Elrohir. Rohir could be translated "horse-lord" and thus Elrohir could be mistaken for a rider of rohan.

Well, here's the dead give away: Elo

Is it a tall tower where a palantir was placed?

Yes, it is Elostirion! Good job! Your go!

Paavo is right. The game only works if, when the person setting the clue cannot answer a question, the question-asker gives the answer that they had in mind. Only when they have done so should the next letter be given. Otherwise people could ask questions to which there is no answer that fits and thereby get all the letters.

It would be best of people hold off from asking questions until the asker has given the answer that they had in mind and the next letter has been given. Otherwise it tends to get somewhat confusing.

Thanks. :)

Starts with an F.

Is it the un-loved one?

Is it one from a party of thirteen?

is it probably the biggest living thing in ME?

Is it an elvish name for men?

Is it a ringbearer?

It's not Faramir, Fíli, Flame of Udun, Frodo, or Fírimar.