Hurt and Heal revisited
 

You remember that game we've played occasionally during the last four years or so? I want to play some more.

There have been 2 rounds of LOTR characters and one of Silmarillion characters, Hobbit characters, Ainur (non-Valar), Weapons, Dwarves, Elves, and female characters each.

THE RULES:

• Each player has 3 nominations and 5 secondings.
• You are not allowed to second your own nominee.
• Characters have to be seconded twice before they get in. In other words, they need 3 votes (one of which is the nomination).

The actual game:

• From 20 to 7 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts are allowed.
• From 6 to 4 - each player has 3 votes: 2 hurts and 1 heal. Double hurts ar not allowed: a player has to hurt 2 different characters and heal one, or he may use only 1 hurt and 1 heal.
• When but 3 characters are left each player has either a hurt or a heal.
• Wait for at least three posters to vote prior to you voting again.

I suggest doing countries/kingdoms/geographical ares, so without further ado...

Nominating Dol Amroth, Lebennin and Dorthonion.

In:

Nominated:
Dol Amroth
Lebennin
Dorthonion

Nominations / secondings:
Agan 0/3

Please include the list of the nominees, as well as how many nominations people have left, when you nominate or second someone.

(Also, credits to G55 whose rules I shamelessly stole.)

Nah, the female one didn't end up happening. It just stalled.

...or rather to those people from whom I shamelessly stole them... :smokin: :D

++Arnor
++Helcaraxe
++The Void (does that count?!) :p

And second:

++Dorthonion

Nominated:
Dol Amroth
Lebennin
Dorthonion (2)
Arnor
Helcaraxe
?The Void?

Nominations / secondings:
Agan 0/3
G55 0/2

Whoops. It was a time I wasn't very active so all I saw when I now scrolled through M-E Mirth was that there was a thread. If we get this one done, we could perhaps try and do it again too.

Second The Void. It's awesome. :D

Nominated:
Dol Amroth
Lebennin
Dorthonion (2)
Arnor
Helcaraxe
The Void (2)

Nominations / secondings:
Agan 0/2
G55 0/2

Oooh, so many to choose from...

Of course I'd like to nominate the famous Hithlum, Gondolin, Doriath, etc.- but what about some of the lesser known places? Maybe Arandor, Nevrast, Arthedain, or Emerië.... *sigh* But okay, I'll restrict myself to nominating-

++Withered Heath, playground of dragons
++Region, the forest of Doriath is just named too perfectly to be left off
++Hollin, the dwarf-friendly one-time home to Celebrimbor, Galadriel, and of course Sauron & the rings of power

Nominated:
Dol Amroth
Lebennin
Dorthonion (2)
Arnor
Helcaraxe
The Void (2)
Withered Heath
Region
Hollin

Nominations / secondings:
Agan 0/2
G55 0/2
TP 0/3

The creaking of bones for ages unmoved echoes through the forsaken mounds. A spectre of old times arises once more to sound his words of consequence among the lifeless...


I will nominate:
++Himring
++Lothlórien
++Tirion

I also second:
++Dorthonion
++Hollin


On the list:
Dorthonion (3)

Nominated:
Dol Amroth
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe
The Void (2)
Withered Heath
Region
Hollin (2)
Himring
Tirion
Lothlórien


Nominations / secondings:
Agan 0/2
G55 0/2
TP 0/3
Mac 0/1

Mac! Welcome back! :D

Things are being slow so I suggest increasing the number of our allowed secondings to five for now, just so we might perhaps get started sooner. They have been edited to the new correct number in this post.

I second
++Tirion

On the list:
Dorthonion (3)

Nominated:
Dol Amroth
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe
The Void (2)
Withered Heath
Region
Hollin (2)
Himring
Tirion (2)
Lothlórien

Nominations / secondings:
Agan 0/3
G55 0/4
TP 0/5
Mac 0/3

Sweet!

++Lothlorien

On the list:
Dorthonion (3)

Nominated:
Dol Amroth
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe
The Void (2)
Withered Heath
Region
Hollin (2)
Himring
Tirion (2)
Lothlórien (2)

Nominations / secondings:
Agan 0/3
G55 0/3
TP 0/5
Mac 0/3

I shall second ++Himring and ++Dol Amroth

On the list:
Dorthonion (3)

Nominated:
Dol Amroth (2)
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe
The Void (2)
Withered Heath
Region
Hollin (2)
Himring (2)
Tirion (2)
Lothlórien (2)

Nominations / secondings:
Agan 0/3
G55 0/3
TP 0/3
Mac 0/3

If it keeps going by this rate, we might as well remove the nomination/seconding limits altogether. I believe they were added in the first place because there were so many players, but we hardly have that problem.

So I'll second
++Himring
++Hollin
++Helcaraxë

And nominate
++Losgar
++Tol Sirion
++Lórien

On the list:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring

Nominated:
Dol Amroth (2)
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe (2)
The Void (2)
Withered Heath
Region
Tirion (2)
Lothlórien (2)
Losgar
Tol Sirion
Lórien

Even sweeter!

++Tol Sirion
++Withered Heath
++Tirion

And nominate ++Tol Morwen

On the list:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion

Nominated:
Dol Amroth (2)
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe (2)
The Void (2)
Withered Heath (2)
Region
Lothlórien (2)
Losgar
Tol Sirion (2)
Lórien
Tol Morwen

Allrighty- let's get a few more on the nomination list...
++Hithlum
++Anórien
++Nevrast
++Arandor
++Arthedain
++Emerië
++Ithilien
++Dor Daedeloth

And I shall second
++Tol Morwen

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion

NOMINATED:
Dol Amroth (2)
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe (2)
The Void (2)
Withered Heath (2)
Region
Lothlórien (2)
Losgar
Tol Sirion (2)
Lórien
Tol Morwen (2)
Hithlum
Anórien
Nevrast
Arandor
Arthedain
Emerië
Ithilien
Dor Daedeloth

After all, it's us playing the game, not the other way round.

Seconding
++Anórien
++Ithilien
++Dor Daedeloth
++Region

Also, nominating
++Taur-nu-Fuin

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion

NOMINATED:
Dol Amroth (2)
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe (2)
The Void (2)
Withered Heath (2)
Region (2)
Lothlórien (2)
Losgar
Tol Sirion (2)
Lórien
Tol Morwen (2)
Hithlum
Anórien (2)
Nevrast
Arandor
Arthedain
Emerië
Ithilien (2)
Dor Daedeloth (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin

++Anorien and ++Dor Daedeloth are just too awesome to pass up.

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth

NOMINATED:
Dol Amroth (2)
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe (2)
The Void (2)
Withered Heath (2)
Region (2)
Lothlórien (2)
Losgar
Tol Sirion (2)
Lórien
Tol Morwen (2)
Hithlum
Nevrast
Arandor
Arthedain
Emerië
Ithilien (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin


EDIT: Afterthought: We better get more than four players! (or else.)

I advertised this on Facebook (which, I believe, is how phantom and Mac found their way here). Of course it's possible more people join in if this keeps popping up in Active Topics.

Let's try to get to 20 places now anyway.

You know how I advertise. ;)

I'm onto it! :D

seconding
++Hithlum
++Nevrast
++Ithilien
++Lothlorien
++The Void




ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void

NOMINATED:
Dol Amroth (2)
Lebennin
Arnor
Helcaraxe (2)
Withered Heath (2)
Region (2)
Lorien (2)
Losgar
Tol Sirion (2)
Lórien (2)
Tol Morwen (2)
Hithlum (2)
Nevrast (2)
Arandor
Arthedain
Emerië

Taur-nu-Fuin

Alright, I'll bite.

Seconding:

++Dol Amroth
++Lebennin
++Losgar
++Tol Morwen
++Helcaraxe
++Tol Sirion (Because, really, how could it not be on the list?)
++Emerië

Nominating:
++Angband
++Andúnië
++Drúwaith Iaur

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Withered Heath (2)
Region (2)
Lorien (2)
Losgar (2)
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Nevrast (2)
Arandor
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Angband
Andúnië
Drúwaith Iaur

Seconding
++Angband
++Andúnië

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Withered Heath (2)
Region (2)
Lorien (2)
Losgar (2)
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Nevrast (2)
Arandor
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Angband (2)
Andúnië (2)
Drúwaith Iaur

Thirding

++Angband

Nominating

++Tol-in-Gaurhoth
++Barrow Downs

:smokin:

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion
Angband

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Withered Heath (2)
Region (2)
Lorien (2)
Losgar (2)
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Nevrast (2)
Arandor
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Andúnië (2)
Drúwaith Iaur
Tol-in-Gaurhoth
The Barrow-Downs

Seconding
++Nevrast
++Arandor

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion
Angband
Nevrast

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Withered Heath (2)
Region (2)
Losgar (2)
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Arandor (2)
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Andúnië (2)
Drúwaith Iaur
Tol-in-Gaurhoth
The Barrow-Downs

What, isn't Tol Sirion good enough for you? :p

Seconding
++Andúnië
++The Barrow-Downs

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion
Angband
Nevrast
Andúnië

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Withered Heath (2)
Region (2)
Losgar (2)
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Arandor (2)
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Drúwaith Iaur
Tol-in-Gaurhoth
The Barrow-Downs (2)

Once we have four more on the list, we can start.

A Legate is never late.
 

Nominating:
Nurn
Nindalf
Morgai

Seconding:
++Drúwaith Iaur
++Withered Heath (=>goes)

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion
Angband
Nevrast
Andúnië
Withered Heath

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Region (2)
Losgar (2)
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Arandor (2)
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Drúwaith Iaur (2)
Tol-in-Gaurhoth
The Barrow-Downs (2)
Nurn
Nindalf
Morgai

Hey with good luck we'll get this started today. :)

Thirding Region, then.

If anyone could still get at least one of my three nominees to the list, it would be sweet :) If not, then I'll just have to wait for some future one.

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion
Angband
Nevrast
Andúnië
Withered Heath
Region

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Losgar (2)
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Arandor (2)
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Drúwaith Iaur (2)
Tol-in-Gaurhoth
The Barrow-Downs (2)
Nurn
Nindalf
Morgai

Okay.

++Nurn

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion
Angband
Nevrast
Andúnië
Withered Heath
Region

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Losgar (2)
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Arandor (2)
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Drúwaith Iaur (2)
Tol-in-Gaurhoth
The Barrow-Downs (2)
Nurn (2)
Nindalf
Morgai

Also, I want Losgar! What's not cool about Fëanor burning some ships?

I wouldn't mind either of them.

++Nurn
++Losgar

ON THE LIST:
Dorthonion
Hollin
Himring
Tirion
Anorien
Dor Daedeloth
Ithilien
Lothlorien
The Void
Dol Amroth
Tol Morwen
Helcaraxe
Tol Sirion
Angband
Nevrast
Andúnië
Withered Heath
Region
Nurn
Losgar

NOMINATED:
Lebennin (2)
Arnor
Lórien (2)
Hithlum (2)
Arandor (2)
Arthedain
Emerië (2)
Taur-nu-Fuin
Drúwaith Iaur (2)
Tol-in-Gaurhoth
The Barrow-Downs (2)
Nindalf
Morgai

Would that be twenty? Would we start with that? Yay! Thanks in any case :)

Yes. :)

Hurt Region and Withered Heath, heal Losgar.

Andúnië (10)
Angband (10)
Anórien (10)
Dol Amroth (10)
Dor Daedeloth (10)
Dorthonion (10)
Helcaraxë (10)
Himring (10)
Hollin (10)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (11)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (10)
Nurn (10)
Region (9)
The Void (10)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (9)

Heal Helcaraxe, hurt Hollin an Himring

Andúnië (10)
Angband (10)
Anórien (10)
Dol Amroth (10)
Dor Daedeloth (10)
Dorthonion (10)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (9)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (11)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (10)
Nurn (10)
Region (9)
The Void (10)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (9)

++Dol Amroth
--Withered Heath
--Nevrast

Andúnië (10)
Angband (10)
Anórien (10)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (10)
Dorthonion (10)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (9)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (11)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (9)
The Void (10)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (8)

Heal Dorthonion
Hurt Withered Heath and The Void

Andúnië (10)
Angband (10)
Anórien (10)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (10)
Dorthonion (11)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (9)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (11)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (9)
The Void (9)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (7)

Hurt Losgar Hurt Tol Morwen
Heal Hollin

Andúnië (10)
Angband (10)
Anórien (10)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (10)
Dorthonion (11)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (10)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (9)
The Void (9)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (9)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (7)

++Tol Morwen
--Region
--Hollin

Andúnië (10)
Angband (10)
Anórien (10)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (10)
Dorthonion (11)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (9)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (8)
The Void (9)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (7)

++Andúnië
--Hollin
--Himring

Andúnië (11)
Angband (10)
Anórien (10)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (10)
Dorthonion (11)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (8)
Hollin (8)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (8)
The Void (9)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (7)

Heal Himring
Hurt Anórien and Dor Daedeloth

Andúnië (11)
Angband (10)
Anórien (9)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (9)
Dorthonion (11)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (8)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (8)
The Void (9)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (7)

Hurt The Void
Hurt Angband
Heal Hollin

Andúnië (11)
Angband (9)
Anórien (9)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (9)
Dorthonion (11)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (9)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (8)
The Void (8)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (7)

Double-hurt Region
Heal The Void

Andúnië (11)
Angband (9)
Anórien (9)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (9)
Dorthonion (11)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (9)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (6)
The Void (9)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (7)

Hurt Angband Hurt Dorthonion
Heal The Void

Andúnië (11)
Angband (8)
Anórien (9)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (9)
Dorthonion (10)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (9)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (6)
The Void (10)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (7)

++Withered Heath
--Andunie
--Hollin

Andúnië (10)
Angband (8)
Anórien (9)
Dol Amroth (11)
Dor Daedeloth (9)
Dorthonion (10)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (8)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (6)
The Void (10)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (8)

Heal Region
Double Hurt Dol Amroth

Andúnië (10)
Angband (8)
Anórien (9)
Dol Amroth (9)
Dor Daedeloth (9)
Dorthonion (10)
Helcaraxë (11)
Himring (9)
Hollin (8)
Ithilien (10)
Losgar (10)
Lothlórien (10)
Nevrast (9)
Nurn (10)
Region (7)
The Void (10)
Tirion (10)
Tol Morwen (10)
Tol Sirion (10)
Withered Heath (8)