No, it wasn't Dol Amroth. Prince Imrahil rules there. I know it's somewhere in Ithilien and I do believe that NightKnight is right.

i know he rules there, AFTER WotR i'm pretty sure when Imrahil doesn't rule there Faramir and Eowyn take residency, seesh Glirdan i'm not stupid, Imrahil is like my idol i try to know as much as i can about him ,way to insult me and make me mad... :mad:

I'm not saying you're stupid. I'm saying that I'm pretty sure Imrahil was still ruling there after the WotR. Didn't Aragorn give Itilien to Faramir to have Stewardship in? And I'm sorry that I made you angry Gil. :(

NK has it.
 

And, welcome back. :)

Your thread. Boggle our minds. ;)

Thank you. And I'm too lazy to be active here nowadays. :P

Where did Radagast live?

Rhovanion, right?

More specificly, please.

Rhosgobel?

Yep.

Who was the first bearer of Narya?

Cirdan the Shipwright.

Well done!

By whose permission did Gandalf and Pippin pass through the Rammas Echor on the way to Minas Tirith?

Is it Ingold?

Yup!
 

Your thread, Val!

I thought that would be harder, since I didn't know it myself without looking it up. ;)

That's just weird that I know that....;)

Who was one of the first people that Frodo set free from the lockholds?

Will Whitfoot?

Not the one I was thinking of...Before Will...

um...um...Lobelia? For some reason my brain has her as the last, not the first, but my brain is crazy.

Fatty Bolger?

Oh duh. My brain is crazy. Of course it's Fatty, and much the worse for wear, no?

Silly Jen.

You are right TUOR!! The thread is yours!:D

Okay. What characters based in Cirith
Ungol were still alive (other then hobbits) after
Sam and Frodo left Cirith Ungol?

That's a difficult one. The Watchers??

Mmm...well, one of them survived, because Frodo's stuff was brought to Barad-dur.....

Gorbag and Radbug
________
EXTREME VAPORIZER

Ooooo!! If it's who brought the stuff back to Barad-dur that you're asking about, that would be Shagrat.

Shagrat is one of them. It's actually a tricky question,
on several levels. I considered counting the Watchers,
but wasn't sure how to classify them, so they're not
counted here. But there are either one, two, or more then
two to add. The more then two (maybes) are the orcs
that shot arrows killing two of Shagrat's lads. But since
they aren't mentioned again, and Sam and Frodo got out
without being shot, I suppose you could reasonably
assume they died after unloosing
the arrows? I've also come across a reference to "two"
survivors, and if you consider the question there
is another individual who presumably fits the criteria.

The other would be the Witch-King, as he was away.

But if you admit that, then whatever of his own armies he took with him also survived. I always got the impression the main contingent based there had all left, and Minas Morgul was staffed by a smaller garrison.

well if the Witch-King is accepted then wouldn't Gothmog?

A good point about the Witch-king of Angmar,
but I'm thinking of an orc. (Hint: when last
seen he wasn't very happy with his fellow orcs).

Here's the indication of two surviving orcs (from
Wikipedia)

P.S. I think I know the second orc, although if it's the one I'm
thinking of it's a bit of a trick question.

P.P.S. I don't think this reference to two survivors would refer to
Gorbag and Shagrat, since when they were alive Snaga, the
two orcs sent by Shagrat to Sauron, and the orcs firing arrows
at them were also still alive and it's hard to imagine a scenario
where just two of the above could be considered definitively
alive at the same time after fighting for the mthril-shirt.
(Sorry for any confusion here).

P.P.P.S. If there is dispute over the existence/name of this
other orc then Glirdan could be considered the (answrerer ?)
of the question.

seven?

Why is no one ever here? Well, anyway I think ten days have passed since the last question (if they haven't, then I'm sorry) so it is time for a new question.


How many children does Sam have?

Oh, a random guess: 13?

Well since no one has been on here in awhile...Thinlomien your are correct! (I checked his family tree to be sure) Take it away!:D

Thank'ee, Valier. :D



Who was Edrahil?

He was an Elf of Nargothrond who accompanied Finrod and Beren on their quest.

Correcto. Take the thread. :)

To Middle-Earth I am come!!!
 

Ok it has been three years since anyone posted a question so I am taking the liberty.

Who received Gollum as a prisoner after Aragorn captured him?

Thranduil the Elf-King?

Actually, it's only been one day, so your question is cancelled out so Dimturiel can post one.