Two truths and a lie...
I would guess that most of us have played this game, but I've never tried it online, so I think it would be fun. Just remember that it has to be LotR.
For those who don't know how to play: here are some simple rules. You post two true statements and a fals statement. Such as: 1. Frodo was a hobbit. 2. Gandalf was a hobbit. 3. Sam was a hobbit. Then someone guesses which is the lie. It is then their turn. (You might specify book or movie, too.) So: According to the movies. 1. Pippin ate four pieces of Lembas. 2. Denethor gets his butt kicked by Gandalf for being a crazy, despairing leader. 3. Merry and Pippin found two barrels of Old Toby at Isengard. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I guess number two. Gandalf hits his head with a stuff, not kicks his butt. (But if it isn't literal, then I'm wrong.)
|
Sorry, Thinlómien, it isn't literal. The correct response is number 3.
It is a lie because Merry and Pippin find two barrels of Longbottom Leaf, not Old Toby, which is what Gandalf and Bilbo are smoking in FotR. So it's your turn, Eorl of Rohan. |
Okay, here it goes!
1. Feanor is the most powerful and intelligent elf ever. 2. Morgoth kills Felagund. 3. Eorl was called young because he died young. |
I would say nr. 2 ! Was Feladund not killed by a werewolf or somthing like that!
(Not sure i agree on nr. 1, but i can only choose one) |
No, that is not correct.
|
I'd hazzard a guess towards No. 3. Eorl was called young because he became King young I believe (not entirely sure. actually, I'm like eighty percent sure I'm wrong. :D )
|
Actually, you are right, although the reason is wrong, I think. Eorl the Young (My namesake) is called young, not because he died young, but because he kept his youthful vitality and bright-golden hair (instead of turning white) to the very end of his days.
Your turn, Glirdan! :D |
Sweet!!
Ok, here goes nothing.
1. Galadriel has the Elven Ring of Power Nenya 2. It is not known what happened to Legolas and Gimli and no one has any idea of what or where they went and did. 3. There are eight Valar in the Aratar. Go for it. ;) |
2. They built a boat, and sailed into the west the year King Elessar dies. Thus ends the last of the fellowship in Middle Earth.
|
Ouch!! :o You copied that word for word from the book didn't you? Do you have the bbok in front of you by any cahnce? :confused: Anyway, your thread!!! ;)
|
Perky seems to have forsaken this thread. 0_0
|
so can i give a new set of truths and lies?
if i can.... 1. Saruman claims himself that he is "of many colours" 2. Grima was shot bye a hobbit 3. in the movie, Merry replaces the palantir from under Gandalfs robe w/ a pot, not a tea kettle. |
Yes you can give a new set and feel free to revive some of the old threads.
I cannot remember what he replaces the palantir with in the movie, so my guess would be that it is the lie. (3) and by the way welcome amongst the dead |
well movie wise, 2 would be out cause legolas shoots him...it was a pot
|
In the movie Pippin replaces the palantir from under Gandalf's arm with a water pitcher. Meridoc watched him from under his sheets.
|
very good Valesse, ur turn.
|
On the books:
1) Gimli returned to Rohan after the War of the Ring and became the Lord of the Glittering Caves. 2) The Royal family of Rohan is originally from the Folde. 3) There was no civil war in Gondor during the Third Age. |
well nr. 3. Is a lie as Castamir and Eldacar fought over the throne of Gondor.
(I belive nr. 2 can be debatet) By the way allthoug it was poorly written I did guess on nr. 3 in the previus question and therfor the rightfull winner ! :p |
You are correct: The Kin-strife took place during the Third Age between 1432-1448.
Give us a good one, Rune! |
I hope I don't disapoint you
1)Telemnar was the king of Gondor who rueled for the shortest period of time. 2)The first of the Seven Dwarf-rings to be forged, was given to Thrór, the King under the Mountain 3)Helm’s Deep was originally built by men of Gondor |
Is it 2)The first of the Seven Dwarf-rings to be forged, was given to Thrór, the King under the Mountain. Wasn't it given to Durin III first?
|
It is no fun when you guess it this fast ! ! !
Your absolute correct Celebuial, Durin III got it first(remaind in his line for a long time) then Thrór, then Thráin and last Sauron.
I thought it would give you some trouble as the ring is known as the Ring of Thrór, guess i was wrong. . . :( |
I always thought that it was interesting that it was known as the ring as Thror even though he didn't have it first...well it's weird so I remembered it!
I don't think I'll be any good at setting up a question but here goes anyway: 1) Harry Goatleaf watched the West gate of Bree and refused to help or join Bill Ferny and such like. 2) River Mitheithel passes through land which used to be held by the kingdom of Rhudaur. 3)Ulwrath is the Grandfather of Ulfast who is responsible for the defeat of the sons of Feanor at the Battle of Unnumbered Tears. |
3) Is Ulwarth not Ulfast's son or atleast a decendent ?
|
Damn!!!! I meant to write ULFAST! ooopsss!!! that means that two of them were false!!! Sorry! The other one was Harry Goatleaf, he did infact join Ferny. But Ulwrath is actualy Ulfang's FARTHER.
SORRY! Oh well knew I'd confuse myself, LOL! ok.. you have another go Rune Son of Bjarne seeing as you technically got it right! |
Oh it's ok. If it had not been for that mistace i would have been totaly lost. . .
1)Gwaihir caries the titel King of Eagels 2) Agarwaen son of Úmarth was one of Turin's names 3) The Stone of Elostirion was taken back to Aman on the Ring-bearers' White Ship |
1) Gwaihir's title is Wind Lord, not King of Eagles? Maybe he's the king too, I'm not sure... Nr 2 is true and I have a faint memory telling me nr 3 is also correct...
|
Hmmmmmmmm.... Well Gwaihir was known as The Wind Lord and not the KIng of the Eagles so I'd say 1).
Although I know Elostirion is one of the Towers at Tower Hills and there may have been a palantir there... but I didn't know it was taken back on the Ship.... Hmmmmmmm...... I'll stick with 1) EDIT: Damn Gothmog beat me too it!!!!! |
It is all yours Gothmog.
Gwaihir was known as The Wind Lord and not the King of the Eagles, it was only Thorondor who cairied that titel. |
alright, sry bout saying that rune got it wrong, i thought that he also needed the right reason is that true? or as he said false? and if its false, does anyone want to make it true? if u follow me...
|
Valesse pm and informed me that you wantet another reason so I was wrong.
I belive you decide how correct the answer has to be. |
well, CREDIT ALL AROUND ;)
both r right, so....idk....do u wanna post one Rune? its fine w/ me.... |
Is it my turn or have I missed something? Want to be sure not to take somebody else's turn...
|
It's your turn Gothmog! you won the last one remember. . .
|
OK, I'll try one...
1) Rumil invented the tengwar 2) Lomion is an other name for Maeglin 3) Uinendili is the daughter of Uinen and Osse |
Number 3 is wrong, because the Uinendili were the elves who were followers of sorts of Uinen.
|
You're right of course. Thread is yours!
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:09 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.