![]() |
Why Tom's songs
This may have been asked before but I haven't seen it.
Basically I just want to know why Tom Bombadil sings all the time. Well, I say sings, he more speaks to a tune but never mind. Is there a written reason for this, does Tolkien ever say why? Is it maybe because he is just compulsorily (thats not a word I know) happy so songs just burst out of him? Please, any comments would be gratefully received. |
Quote:
|
In Middle earth songs have real power, eg Luthien, where she used a song as part of 'magic' (whatever that is). I reckon Tom's songs were his method of maintaining his edge against Old Man Willow et al.
After all if you sing something enough it becomes true; 'Free Nelson Mandela' for example (HOORAY!!). And as the saying goes, 'a song from the heart beats the devil every time'. I guess its just rather more immediate in Middle Earth! (Shame the same doesn't apply here!) |
The Music of the Valar created what would exist in E[font='Times New Roman'][font=Verdana]ä[/font][/font].
Out of Pearson's 12 archetypes, I'd say Tom is a Creator. |
Because otherwise we would have to listen to Old Man Willow's bark?
:eek: :p ;) |
I agree with Rumil that Tom sings because music is powerful and Tom is powerful.
However, I disagree with Durelin that Tom is a creator. What does he create? He is more of an observer in my estimation. An observer who will continually burst forth into silly songs because it is part of his nature. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:53 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.